EVS' FLEETS IN PRACTICE - 4TH E-MOBILITY STAKEHOLDER FORUM - #EMSF2016 @EMOBILITYFORUM - FREVUE
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
4th E-MOBILITY STAKEHOLDER FORUM
Evs’ Fleets in Practice
CTT Correios de Portugal
José Guilherme
#eMSF2016
@eMobilityForumAgenda o FREVUE Lisbon Demonstration o CTT - short presentation o Preparation Project o Initial Impact o Project Development o Other Electric Vehicles
FREVUE Lisbon Demonstration-
short
Lisbon presentation
Municipality: 104 Evs
10% of the total Municipality fleet
CTT - short presentation
EMEL – Lisbon Mobility and Parking: 16 Evs
23% of the total EMEL fleet
EV Positive Discrimination: Green Parking Permit exempt EV
from parking fees
Promotion and Dissemination (FR-EVUE)CTT Short Presentation -
short
o Onepresentation
of the main employers in Portugal with more than
12,000 workers
CTT - short
o Our presentation
Shops (over 600) and agents (over 1800) serve daily
about 130,000 customers
o We move daily over 5 million postal items we distribute in
about 5.5 million households
o Some of the CTT Group companies:
CTT Expresso – Serviços Postais e Logística, SA
Mailtec Holding SGPS
PayShop (Portugal), SA
PostContacto – Correio Publicitário, Lda.CTT Short Presentation -
Shops Network:
short presentation129 000 customers day
623 Shops
CTT - short presentation
1820 Agents
Delivery: Sorting:
5.5 M Housing Over 5 million objects
5050 postmen
285 Delivery Centers
About 56 M km / year
Transport:
10.3 M km / year
600 day trips
200 driversCTT Short Presentation -
short presentation
The Fleet: total of 3,195 vehicles, with average age of 2.5 years
About 59 million km / year (heavy fleet 6.9 million Kms)
CTT
Total- short presentation
consumption of 5,346,072 liters, Fuel costs exceed 6
million € annually
alternative fleet: 300 vehicles and is growing
5% 9%
6%
27 electric quadricycles 6%
18 electric scooters 6% electric quadricycles
19 conventional bikes electric scooters
203 electric bikes conventional bikes
electric bikes
17 electric light vehicles electric light vehicles
16 electric tricycles electric tricycles
68%CTT Short Presentation -
short presentation
The Sustainability goals for 2016
CTT - short presentation
• Reduction fuel consumption by 4%
• Efficiency gains in fuel consumption of 1.8% / year
• Expansion of electric fleet
• Reduction of direct and indirect emissions of 20% (period
2008-2020)
• 20% reduction of carbon intensity by postal object and
parcel in the period 2013-2025
• Labor mortality zero rateCTT Short Presentation -
short presentation
CTT, among the world's best
CTT
EMMS- short presentation
2014: 5th place among 21 participants (89.96 points out of 100)
Global benchmark in 3 criteria: Disclosure and Reporting; Principles and
Standards; Policy and Procedures
Reduction of emissions by 50% over the year based analysis (2008)
CO2 emissions per object 13.1 grams (18.1 in the CPI)
The alternative fleet corresponds to 9.4% of total vehicles (CPI average: 16.0%)
Improvement opportunities suggested by IPC to CTT:
Continued investment in electric vehicles, route optimization and
continuous training of drivers
Increased energy efficiency of buildings and the purchase of green
electricityPreparation Project- short CTT conducted market research in order to evaluate the main characteristics of the EFVs available on the market at the desired range. Regarding range (autonomy), the actual values of service should be in the order of 80-100km. CTT understood that range could increase if routes were planned with few stops or consequently reduce if a routes topography was highly irregular. CTT prepared terms of reference for the purchase of ten EFVs (five light commercial vans of 2m3 and five light commercial vans of 4m3) according to the needs identified in the selection of routes for these vehicles. drivers.
Preparation Project- short Two Kangoo ZE technical demonstrations were conducted at Renault´s installations (on December 10th, 2013 and January 21st, 2014) with the following objectives: learning the main features of the electric Kangoo and ensure its proper use (driving and battery charging) and maximizing its potential. The demonstrations were aimed at fleet managers, supervisors of the Postal Distribution Centres and Drivers. Only Renault presented a proposal and after analysis, it was determined to order five Renault Kangoo ZE and five Renault Kangoo ZE Maxi in September 2013, according to the specifications present in the terms of reference of the tender. All ten vehicles entered operation in March 2014.
Preparation Project
Preparation Project CTT has analysed the circuits in Lisbon’s downtown area taking into account the type of vehicle used (considering only the type envisaged in the project) and the distances. This resulted in 10 routes being identified as suitable for EFV operation. CTT vehicles are charged on the Postal Distribution Centres. The charging equipment supplied by Renault includes the standard and occasional charging cables. In February 2014, CTT proceeded with the installation of Schuko type sockets (16 A) in the Postal Distribution Centres for the battery charging of Kangoo ZE with the occasional charging cable. All drivers and managers had specific training provided by Renault as well as fleet management technicians.
Initial Impact Customers Reception very positive of electric vehicles Marked environmental concerns Drivers and Managers Satisfaction and confidence in the use of electric vehicles Fleet Management No problems
Project Development
Viatura Colocação Kms Drivers
C-6457-V CPLS/SAD 32788 Drivers keep the confidence on the vehicles
C-6458-V CPLS/SAD 26896 and their reliability - have been driven more
C-6459-V 1200 Lisboa 23732 than 200,000 Kms since 2014
C-6460-V 1100 Lisboa 9079
C-6461-V 1100 Lisboa 14339
Fleet Management
C-6462-V SAD 17047
Still no problems
C-6463-V CPLS 20365
C-6464-V SAD 19337
C-6465-V SAD 18842
C-6466-V SAD 17604Project Development Managers Nuno Pica SAD - quite satisfactory evaluation. João Abrantes CDP 1200/1250 Lisbon - the vehicles have an excellent performance at the level of load (weight) to which they are subject and irregular pavement, particularly in CDP 1200. With regard to autonomy, is well within the desired limits. Rui Cândido CDP 1000/1100/1150/1170 Lisbon - those vehicle in our opinion and in our geographical area are very versatile with good autonomy, Excellent vehicle work, compared the other car with different combustible in our view are equal, the only negative aspect is that they do not emit sound at low speed for pedestrians alert seems to us a very important aspect to take into account; the consumption level is better. In summary we just have to say well about the vehicles.
Project Development As a result of the EMS service integration in CTT network the operation of electric vehicles became more uniform with daily averages distances about 30 Kms. There are no changes in the vehicle charging system and there is no incidence to report. An important improvement would be the manufacturer provide an adequate service for monitoring of the vehicles. Developed process for reallocating some vehicles (3) together with the 7 new Nissan vehicles and other electric types such as bicycles, motorcycles and tricycles will allow CDP with almost entirely green fleet.
Other Electric Vehicles CTT has gradually acquired a number of electric vehicles in order to reduce their ecological footprint: New electric bicycles in May 2013 (190 vehicles) GOALS: - Replace motorcycles by electric bicycle models - Use electric bicycles in deliveries of "last mile“ - Environmental benefits - reducing CO2 emissions, noise pollution - To contribute to the comfort and safety of postmen
Other Electric Vehicles
and other electric types such as bicycles, motorcycles and tricycles will allow CDP with
almost entirely green fleet (March 2014)
Govec (motorcycles) Goupil (quadricycles)Other Electric Vehicles
and other electric types such as bicycles, motorcycles and tricycles will allow CDP with
almost entirely green fleet (2015)
Ligier (tricycles)
Paxter (quadricycles)Other Electric Vehicles CTT has gradually acquired a number of electric vehicles in order to reduce their ecological footprint: 7 new Nissan vehicles (2016)
Thank you
jose.guilherme@ctt.pt
#eMSF2016
@eMobilityForum4th E-MOBILITY STAKEHOLDER FORUM
The eBRIDGE Project
Urban eMobility 2020
Marco Menichetti
eBRIDGE Dissemination Manager – Legambiente
#eMSF2016
@eMobilityForumTHE VISION
eBRIDGE Urban e-Mobility 2020
eBRIDGE experience: 150 EVs and +1,800 usersMILAN
Web 2.0 Communication
1,162 people answered
(GuidaMI-IKEA questionnaire)
e-Mobility has to be
smart and adaptable
market awareness is
changingAUSTRIA P2P e-CS in rural areas
LISBON
Greening the local administration fleet (1)
Political will and
commitment to long-
‐term global
sustainability are crucialLISBON Greening the local administration fleet (1)
KEY FINDINGS Improved attitudes
KEY FINDINGS EV acceptance
LESSONS LEARNED Global o Electric mobility is a sound way to reduce emissions and improve quality of life o EVs alone will not work: holistic approach towards integrated urban development o Technology and charging infrastructure must develop accordingly o Further research to clear up uncertainties
LESSONS LEARNED Policy o Policy can induce sustainable fields of application o Monetary incentives greatly influence decision-making towards EVs adoption o Non-monetary incentives should seek long-term effects o EVs have big potential but also constraints
LESSONS LEARNED Operation o EVs enjoyed greater user acceptance o Uncertainty on maintenance costs o Car sharing market presents fierce competition o Adaptation and resilience are crucial
LESSONS LEARNED Users o EVs can cover short-distance and short-term trips o e-Fleets help users get familiarised and build confidence on EVs o Lack of knowledge creates artificial barriers o Driving trainings proved effective o Knowledge transfer and public events are essential
LESSONS LEARNED Marketing and promotion o Branded EVs to increase visibility and raise awareness o Workshops and information events o Mobility Management Tools for operators o Online Participation Tools for efficient planning
THE LEGACY eBRIDGE Start Up Kit Toolkit & Guidelines : o Practical tips and recommendations to operate and promote electric fleets successfully o Available now on ebridge-project.eu
THE LEGACY
Networking
EnthusiasmThank you Marco Menichetti m.menichetti@intranet.legambiente.org mmenico@gmail.com Tel.: + 39 392 4350742 Skype ID: marmenico #eMSF2016 @eMobilityForum
Electric bus operation Opportunities and risks Jan Barchánek 4th EU Electromobility Stakeholder Forum Brussels, 25th May 2016
Is it possible to change diesel bus operation to
electric bus operation ?E-bus operation – need of charging Diesel buses § operational range – more than 400 km (fuel tank capacity) § operation planning – driver working time regulation Electric buses § operational range limitation § operational planning – incl. charging time è Overnight charging (120 km – 200 km in city traffic) § high capacity batteries (decrease pax capacity) § need of night charging capacity and time – 6-8 hours slow charge è Opportunity charging (250 km – 350 km in city traffic) § less of batteries – more pax capacity § need of special charging infrastructure § more charging cycles – decrease lifecycle of batteries
Charging trade-offs
operational battery lifecycle
reasons reasons
short (mins) charging time long (hours)
high (>100 kW)
charging power low (10-25 kW)
è temperature rise
è energy looses rise
once a week balancing once a day
Ø choose proper type of batteries to operational condition
Ø combine speed and slow charging for efficient LCC
Ø take care of battery cooling / heating (vehicle construction, A/C)Heating and air-conditioning è significant part of e-bus power balance § technical reason – heating + A/C of batteries § comfort reason – heating + A/C of interior § nearly no waste heat from electric engine Electric heating J 100% zero emission vehicle (in place of operation) L impact on power consumption à decrease of operational range Diesel / Gas heating J stable operational range L 4-5x more fuel consumption, than preheaters in diesel buses Ø decrease need of heating + A/C (battery ventilation, double glasses, etc.) Ø allow heating + A/C also during charging (directly from supply network)
Battery capacity – daily operation cycle
Opportunity e-bus incl. electric heating
9/2015 0% heating 1,08 kWh/km
10/2015 50% heating 1,60 kWh/km
1/2016 100% heating 2,13 kWh/kmFleet solution – charging facilities
1 e-bus is OK → what about fleet of 100 e-buses ?
Electric power consumption
§ 100 x 12m e-bus (1,2-2,0 kWh/km) x 250 km = 30-50 MWh / day
§ 100 x 18m e-bus (1,8-3,0 kWh/km) x 250 km = 45-75 MWh / day
Overnight charging
§ number of charging places = number of buses
§ need of upgrade depot supply and installation
Opportunity charging
§ route and timetable planning – optimization of charging places
§ need of high power connection + infrastructure
Ø share another electricity supply network (tram, metro)
Ø need of IT support (charging verification, failure alert)Fleet solution – required number of vehicles
example diesel e-bus
Overnight charging
no. of vehicles 100 125 (+25%)
§ limitation by average max.
operational range daily mileage / vehicle
250 km / day 200 km / day
daily mileage total 25 000 km 25 000 km
example diesel e-bus
Opportunity charging
no. of vehicles 100 107 (+7%)
§ limitation by
85% : 15% 80% : 20%
charging breaks operation time : breaks (driver legal (legal + charging
breaks) breaks)
Today e-buses are still limiting on operational efficiency
A) wait for battery development …
B) choose only suitable parts of network (lines, shifts)
C) re-plan network and timetables for e-busesE-bus operation – cost drivers
cost / km
e-bus / diesel key reasons
(example)
staff 100 – 110 % charging breaks
fuel / electricity 30 – 50 % price and tax policy
amortization could be
covered
purchase price, lifecycle of
- vehicle 200 – 250 % batteries, operational range
need of
- infrastructure quite significant charging infrastructure subsidies
maintenance 80 – 120 % reliability
Need of real support of low emission solution
Ø tax reduction – electricity for PT, (e-buses toll, …)
Ø subsidies – charging infrastructure, (e-buses purchase)E-bus operation – possible solutions
operation (lines/shifts) solution (technology)
§ light Ø overnight charged e-bus
(low mileage, peak only, etc.) Ø overnight + out of peak
§ mediocre Ø opportunity charged e-bus
Ø terminus + key stops
§ heavy Ø partial trolleybus
(high mileage, high demand, Ø trolleybus
hilly profile)
Ø plug-in hybrid
§ heavy independent Ø hybrid
There is no miracle nor universal solution
Ø choose proper solution to real operational conditions
Ø do not be afraid of combined solutionsE-bus project recommendation Strategic phase § compare all possible solutions (feasibility, reliability) § discuss proper ratio between flexibility and dependence § calculate power supply possibilities (esp. for fleet solutions) Planning phase § need of complex solution (vehicle + infrastructure) § calculate reserve for irregularities § avoid too many unproven innovation (risk of reliability) § do not forget operational IT support Contracting phase § share of responsibilities and risks (maintenance, reliability, LC risks) § prefer open interfaces (HW, SW) for possible future development
Not easy, but possible ... Thank you for your attention barchanekj@dpp.cz , www.dpp.cz
You can also read