GUNAIKURNAI AND VICTORIAN GOVERNMENT JOINT MANAGEMENT PLAN - BUCHAN CAVES RESERVE - KRAUATUNGALUNG COUNTRY - GUNAIKURNAI AND VICTORIAN ...

Page created by Leo Mccarthy
 
CONTINUE READING
GUNAIKURNAI AND VICTORIAN GOVERNMENT JOINT MANAGEMENT PLAN - BUCHAN CAVES RESERVE - KRAUATUNGALUNG COUNTRY - GUNAIKURNAI AND VICTORIAN ...
GUNAIKURNAI  
     AND  VICTORIAN  GOVERNMENT  
        JOINT  MANAGEMENT  PLAN  
                                  
             BUCHAN  CAVES  RESERVE  
       —  KRAUATUNGALUNG  COUNTRY  
  
                                

                                      
GUNAIKURNAI AND VICTORIAN GOVERNMENT JOINT MANAGEMENT PLAN - BUCHAN CAVES RESERVE - KRAUATUNGALUNG COUNTRY - GUNAIKURNAI AND VICTORIAN ...
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people are advised that this document may contain images,
names, quotes and other references to deceased people.
Authorised and published by the Gunaikurnai Traditional Owner Land Management Board (GKTOLMB)
574 Main Street, Bairnsdale VIC 3785.
Copyright © Gunaikurnai Traditional Owner Land Management Board and State of Victoria 2018.
This publication is copyright. No part may be reproduced or transmitted by any process except in
accordance with the provisions of the Copyright Act 1968.
For further information, visit the GKTOLMB website at www.gunaikurnai.com.au
Copies of the complete Joint Management Plan, as well as individual park and reserve plans, may be
downloaded from the GKTOLMB website or obtained from the Board’s office, 574 Main Street,
Bairnsdale.

National Library of Australia Cataloguing-in-Publication entry
Gunaikurnai and Victorian Government Joint Management Plan. Buchan Caves Reserve –
Krauatungalung Country. Gunaikurnai Traditional Owner Land Management Board.

ISBN 978-0-6483380-2-4 (PDF version)
Note: Page numbering in this plan is consistent with page numbering in the complete Gunaikurnai and
Victorian Government Joint Management Plan.

Disclaimer
This plan does not limit the operation or exercising of Native Title or Traditional Owner rights held by
the Gunaikurnai people.
Every effort has been made to ensure that the information in this plan is accurate. The Board does not
guarantee that the publication is without flaw of any kind and therefore disclaims all liability for any
error, loss or consequence that may arise from you relying on any information in the publication.
The Board acknowledges that there are differing views about the meaning and spelling of some
Gunaikurnai words, and recognise that these may change in the future. The same applies to the telling
and meaning of Gunaikurnai mythological stories. Where Gunaikurnai language or stories are used in
this plan, the spelling or story contained in the Gunaikurnai Land and Waters Aboriginal Corporation
Gunaikurnai Whole-of-Country Plan (2015) has been adopted for the purpose of consistency.
Quotations included in this plan are reproduced verbatim, including spelling, punctuation and
capitalisation. These may differ from the style adopted in this plan.

Parks Victoria Act 2018
References to Parks Victoria in this plan should be read in the following context:
The Parks Victoria Act 2018 (Vic.) will commence later in 2018. Under this Act, Parks Victoria will
change from being an authority providing park management services by agreement to being an
authority with park and reserve management responsibilities in its own right. It will continue to be a
Committee of Management of particular reserves under the Crown Land (Reserves) Act 1978 (Vic.).

Acknowledgements
This plan was prepared with assistance from Chris Halstead and Penny Spoelder of TRC Tourism, Simon
Faivel and Jonathan Finighan of SVA Consulting, and Brian Doolan of Montane Planning, with input
from GKTOLMB members and staff, and partner organisations: Gunaikurnai Land and Waters
Aboriginal Corporation, Parks Victoria and Department of Environment, Land, Water and Planning.
The Board thanks the following people for providing photographs and images for the overall Joint
Management Plan: Alfie Hudson, Bradley Hood, Alice Hughes/Pepper, Robbie Farnham, Sean
Phillipson, Jessica Shapiro, Rob Willersdorf, David Meagher.
GUNAIKURNAI AND VICTORIAN GOVERNMENT JOINT MANAGEMENT PLAN - BUCHAN CAVES RESERVE - KRAUATUNGALUNG COUNTRY - GUNAIKURNAI AND VICTORIAN ...
                                  

Buchan  Caves  Reserve  —  Krauatungalung  Country  
Buchan  Caves  were  traditionally  an  important  meeting  place  for  our  people.  The  area  connects  
to  the  high  country  and  was  a  place  of  refuge  during  the  seasonal  migrations  to  and  from  the  
mountains,  where  our  mob  would  go  to  chase  the  Bogong  Moth  and  other  food  sources…  
Although  Gunaikurnai  people  did  not  traditionally  venture  very  deep  into  the  limestone  caves,  
there  is  evidence  going  back  more  than  18  000  years  of  the  important  role  they  played  in  the  
lives  of  our  old  people,  including  burials  in  the  caves  and  ceremonial  rings  all  through  the  
Buchan  area.  
                                                 —  Gunaikurnai  Whole-­‐of-­‐Country  Plan  (GLaWAC  2015)    

                                        BUCHAN  CAVES  RESERVE  —  KRAUATUNGALUNG  COUNTRY         66  
GUNAIKURNAI AND VICTORIAN GOVERNMENT JOINT MANAGEMENT PLAN - BUCHAN CAVES RESERVE - KRAUATUNGALUNG COUNTRY - GUNAIKURNAI AND VICTORIAN ...
CONTENTS  
  
1   INTRODUCTION  ...................................................................................................................................  66  

     1.1   Basis  of  the  management  plan  .....................................................................................................  66  

     1.2   How  to  read  this  plan  ...................................................................................................................  67  

     1.3   The  reserve  ..................................................................................................................................  67  

2   The  Buchan  Caves  Reserve  under  joint  management  ........................................................................  68  

3   ZONING  ...............................................................................................................................................  69  

4   CARING  FOR  COUNTRY  .......................................................................................................................  70  

     4.1   Gunaikurnai  cultural  heritage  ......................................................................................................  70  

     4.2   Land  and  water  values  .................................................................................................................  70  

     4.3   Historic  heritage  ...........................................................................................................................  72  

     4.4   Threats  to  Country  and  heritage  ..................................................................................................  73  

     4.5   Conservation  strategies  to  deal  with  threats  ...............................................................................  74  

5   PEOPLE  IN  THE  RESERVE  .....................................................................................................................  76  

     5.1   Traditional  Owners  connecting  with  Country  ..............................................................................  76  

     5.2   Visitors  to  the  reserve  ..................................................................................................................  76  

     5.3   Visitor  strategies  ..........................................................................................................................  78  

6   WORKING  TOGETHER  .........................................................................................................................  80  

     6.1   The  joint  management  delivery  partners  —  GLaWAC,  Parks  Victoria,  DELWP,  GKTOLMB  .........  80  

     6.2   Community  and  other  partners  ...................................................................................................  80  

     6.3   Authorised  uses  ...........................................................................................................................  81  

     6.4   Reserve  boundaries  .....................................................................................................................  81  

7   GOALS  AND  ACTIONS  ..........................................................................................................................  82  

8   PLAN  MONITORING  AND  REVIEW  .......................................................................................................  85  

REFERENCES  ...............................................................................................................................................  87  

                                                         BUCHAN  CAVES  RESERVE  —  KRAUATUNGALUNG  COUNTRY                                                  65  
GUNAIKURNAI AND VICTORIAN GOVERNMENT JOINT MANAGEMENT PLAN - BUCHAN CAVES RESERVE - KRAUATUNGALUNG COUNTRY - GUNAIKURNAI AND VICTORIAN ...
1   INTRODUCTION  
1.1   BASIS  OF  THE  MANAGEMENT  PLAN  
In  a  2010  Native  Title  Determination,  the  Federal  Court  recognised  that  the  Gunaikurnai  hold  
native  title  rights  over  much  of  Gippsland.  At  the  same  time,  the  Victorian  Government  took  
additional  steps  to  recognise  Gunaikurnai  peoples’  traditional  rights  and  ownership  and  entered  
into  a  Recognition  and  Settlement  Agreement  (RSA)  under  the  Traditional  Owner  Settlement  Act  
2010  (Vic.)  with  Gunaikurnai  Land  and  Waters  Aboriginal  Corporation.  The  Recognition  Statement  
from  the  RSA  is  reproduced  in  full  in  the  Introduction  to  the  Joint  Management  Plan  (JMP).          
The  Gunaikurnai  Land  and  Waters  Aboriginal  Corporation  (GLaWAC)  is  the  ‘traditional  owner  group  
entity’  for  the  purposes  of  the  RSA.  GLaWAC  is  also  the  Prescribed  Body  Corporate  for  the  purposes  
of  the  Native  Title  Act  1993  (Cwlth)  and  the  Registered  Aboriginal  Party  for  the  area  for  the  
purposes  of  the  Aboriginal  Heritage  Act  2006  (Vic.).    
As  part  of  the  RSA,  Buchan  Caves  Reserve  has  been  granted  to  the  Gunaikurnai  as  Aboriginal  Title  
by  the  Victorian  Government  and  will  be  managed  jointly  by  Gunaikurnai  and  the  Victorian  
Government.  The  Aboriginal  Title  grant  is  subject  to  the  Gunaikurnai  giving  the  State  the  right  to  
occupy,  use,  control  and  manage  the  land  for  the  same  purpose  as  applied  immediately  before  the  
grant.  In  the  case  of  Buchan  Caves  Reserve,  the  land  continues  to  be  managed  as  a  reserve  for  
public  purposes  and  the  protection  of  natural  features,  under  the  Crown  Land  (Reserves)  Act  1978  
(Vic.).      
This  Management  Plan  for  Buchan  Caves  Reserve  has  been  prepared  under  Section  82  of  the  
Conservation,  Forests  and  Lands  Act  1987  (Vic.)  and  the  provisions  of  the  Gunaikurnai  Traditional  
Owner  Land  Management  Agreement  2010.  It  is  consistent  with  the  objects  and  requirements  of  
the  Crown  Land  (Reserves)  Act  and  the  regulations  made  under  that  Act.  (Additional  legislation  and  
policies  which  have  been  considered  in  the  preparation  of  the  Management  Plan  are  listed  in  Appendix  
4  of  the  Strategic  Plan.)  It  also  recognises  and  is  consistent  with  the  Buchan  Caves  Reserve’s  listing  
on  the  Victorian  Heritage  Register  under  the  provisions  of  the  Heritage  Act  2017  (Vic.)  for  its  
aesthetic,  scientific  and  historical  significance  to  the  State  of  Victoria.      
Because  Buchan  Caves  Reserve  is  within  the  area  covered  by  the  2010  Determination  and  the  RSA,  
the  rights  of  the  Gunaikurnai  to  undertake  traditional  activities  apply  to  the  reserve.  Existing  rights  
and  interests  in  the  reserve  that  are  held  by  others  are  not  affected  by  the  RSA,  but  remain  subject  
to  management  policies  and  regulation.  
The  Gunaikurnai  Traditional  Owner  Land  Management  Board  (GKTOLMB)  was  established  in  
accordance  with  the  Recognition  and  Settlement  Agreement  between  GLaWAC  and  the  State  of  
Victoria,  with  the  statutory  objective  of  enabling  the  knowledge  and  culture  of  the  Gunaikurnai  to  
be  recognised  in  the  management  of  10  Aboriginal  Title  areas,  including  Buchan  Caves  Reserve.  The  
Board  was  responsible  for  preparing  this  management  plan  jointly  with  GLaWAC,  Parks  Victoria  and  
the  Department  of  Environment,  Land,  Water  and  Planning  (DELWP).    
There  have  been  few  opportunities  in  the  past  for  Gunaikurnai  to  participate  in  the  decision-­‐
making  and  management  of  public  land.  Through  this  plan,  GLaWAC  and  the  Victorian  Government  
seek  to:  
•   ensure  that  Buchan  Caves  Reserve  is  well  managed,  its  values  and  assets  are  protected  and  
    conserved,  and  the  statutory  requirements  for  reserve  management  are  fulfilled,  through  an  
    equitable  partnership  between  the  Victorian  Government  and  GLaWAC    
•   increase  opportunities  for  Gunaikurnai  people  to  connect  with  Country,  foster  employment  and  
    economic  development  opportunities  and  build  their  capacity  and  skills  to  take  a  central  role  in  
    joint  management  with  the  other  management  partners    
•   benefit  the  Gunaikurnai  and  the  State  by  recognising,  valuing,  promoting  and  incorporating  
    Gunaikurnai  culture,  knowledge,  skills  and  decision-­‐making  into  the  reserve.  

66      GUNAIKURNAI  AND  VICTORIAN  GOVERNMENT  JOINT  MANAGEMENT  PLAN  
1.2   HOW  TO  READ  THIS  PLAN  
This  plan  provides  a  description  of  joint  management  strategies  and  actions  that  are  specific  to  
Buchan  Caves  Reserve.  The  following  sections:  
•   describe  values,  uses  and  threats  relating  to  the  land,  water  and  heritage  of  the  reserve,  and  
    goals  and  strategies  to  protect  and  conserve  those  values  
•   describe  Traditional  Owner,  visitor  and  community  connections  to  the  reserve  and  their  uses  
    and  activities,  and  the  goals  and  strategies  for  managing  and  enhancing  those  connections  and  
    uses  
•   identify  government  and  community  relationships  and  partnerships  that  are  key  to  managing  
    the  reserve  
•   state  the  actions  that  will  be  undertaken  over  the  next  10  years  to  achieve  the  goals  and  
    implement  the  strategies  described  in  the  plan.  
In  addition  to  the  specific  actions  for  Buchan  Caves  Reserve  in  this  plan,  the  strategic  initiatives  for  
joint  management  described  in  the  Strategic  Plan  chapter  of  the  JMP  may  include  actions  that  
relate  to  Buchan  Caves  Reserve.  
The  Parks  Victoria  Act  2018  (Vic.)  will  commence  later  in  2018.  Under  this  Act,  Parks  Victoria  will  
change  from  being  an  authority  providing  park  management  services  by  agreement  to  being  an  
authority  with  park  and  reserve  management  responsibilities  in  its  own  right.  It  will  continue  to  be  
a  Committee  of  Management  of  particular  reserves  under  the  Crown  Land  (Reserves)  Act  1978  
(Vic.).  

1.3   THE  RESERVE  
Buchan  Caves  Reserve  covers  295  hectares  on  the  Buchan  River  at  the  township  of  Buchan  
(population  approximately  150),  57  kilometres  north  of  Lakes  Entrance.  Most  of  the  reserve  is  
covered  by  forest  and  woodland.  Prior  to  the  grant  of  Aboriginal  Title  the  reserve  was  set  aside  for  
public  purposes  and  the  protection  of  natural  features.  
Some  of  the  best  cave  formations  in  Victoria  are  found  in  the  Buchan  Caves  (See  Section  4.2).  The  
caves  are  part  of  the  Buchan–Murrindal  cave  system,  a  large  outcrop  of  cave  and  karst-­‐forming  
limestones  extending  beyond  the  reserve  boundary.  This  is  one  of  the  most  extensive  cave  systems  
in  Victoria,  containing  between  four  and  five  kilometres  of  stream  passage  cut  at  several  levels  and  
in  some  places  widened  into  caverns  by  block  collapse.  
There  is  evidence  of  Gunaikurnai  burials  dating  from  the  Pleistocene  era  in  some  cave  entries  in  the  
area  around  Buchan,  outside  the  reserve.      
The  reserve  is  also  significant  for  its  modern  history  and  the  development  of  cave  tourism.  It  is  one  
of  East  Gippsland’s  major  tourism  attractions,  attracting  a  large  number  of  visitors  from  interstate  
and  overseas.  
  
                                           

                                              BUCHAN  CAVES  RESERVE  —  KRAUATUNGALUNG  COUNTRY                        67  
2   THE  BUCHAN  CAVES  RESERVE  UNDER  
    JOINT  MANAGEMENT  
The  Buchan  Caves  Reserve  is  on  the  Country  of  the  Krauatungalung  clan.  The  Gunaikurnai  Whole-­‐
of-­‐Country  Plan  (GLaWAC  2015)  sets  out  the  following  management  priorities  for  the  reserve:  
•   establishing  cultural  business  and  training  enterprises  around  tourism  and  education  
•   ensuring  that  all  non-­‐Gunaikurnai  people  working  in  the  Buchan  Caves  area  undertake  cultural  
    awareness  training  
•   taking  a  more  active  role  in  the  administration  of  visitation  and  receiving  commensurate  income  
    from  camping  and  other  fees.  
While  recognising  these  priorities,  this  plan  sets  out  actions  that  are  consistent  with  and  limited  to  
the  terms  of  the  2010  Recognition  and  Settlement  Agreement.  
Parks  Victoria  operates  well-­‐developed  tour  and  accommodation  booking  systems  and  cave  guiding  
services,  and  also  sells  food  and  merchandise.      
The  main  changes  that  will  take  place  as  part  of  joint  management  of  the  reserve  will  be:    
•   the  establishment  of  Buchan  Caves  as  a  primary  training  and  development  location  for  
    Gunaikurnai  people  to  acquire  and  build  skills  in  tourism,  hospitality,  and  commercial  business  
    operations  
•   the  development  of  new  programs  and  activities  for  visitors  that  are  built  on  Gunaikurnai  
    cultural  heritage  themes,  as  part  of  ongoing  improvements  to  the  visitor  services  and  
    experiences  in  the  reserve.  
The  partner  agencies  will  explore  how  the  revenue  from  these  operations  can  be  applied  within  the  
overall  resourcing  of  joint  management.  
  
                                          

68      GUNAIKURNAI  AND  VICTORIAN  GOVERNMENT  JOINT  MANAGEMENT  PLAN  
3   ZONING  
A  simple  zoning  scheme  has  been  developed  to  provide  a  geographic  framework  to  manage  the  
reserve.    The  zones  will:  
•      communicate  which  management  aims  have  priority  in  different  parts  of  the  reserve  
•      indicate  the  types  and  levels  of  use  allowed  
•      assist  in  minimising  conflicts  between  uses  or  between  those  and  the  protection  of  reserve  values  
•      provide  a  basis  for  assessing  the  suitability  of  future  activities  and  use  proposals.  
The  location  of  the  zones  is  shown  on  Map  1,  and  their  purposes  are  described  in  Table  1.  The  
developed  areas  of  the  reserve  along  Caves  Road  and  the  Northern  Arm  Track  are  zoned  as  
Recreation  Development.  This  includes  the  Parks  Victoria  office,  visitor  centre,  cabins,  camping  
area  and  Wilderness  Camp  tents.  The  areas  outside  this  zone,  in  the  headwaters  of  Spring  Creek,  
are  zoned  as  Conservation  and  Recreation.    
  
Table  1:    Management  zones  and  overlays,  Buchan  Caves  Reserve.  

     Zone                       Description  and  purpose  

     Conservation  and          Areas  where  the  management  emphasis  is  on  protection  of  land,  water,  ecological  
     Recreation  Zone           and  cultural  values  while  encouraging  dispersed  recreation  and  nature-­‐based  
                                tourism.      
                                Low-­‐impact  recreation  activities  are  allowed;  dispersed,  small-­‐scale  facilities  are  
                                provided,  without  significant  impact  on  natural  processes  and  landscape  
                                character.  

     Recreation                 Small  areas  with  a  high  level  of  visitor  facility  development,  catering  for  a  high  
     Development  Zone          number  of  visitors.  

     Cultural  Values           Areas  where  the  extent,  nature  or  significance  of  Aboriginal  cultural  heritage  
     Overlay  (future)          and/or  historic  heritage  is  high.  Specific  protections  and  restrictions  on  use  and  
                                activities  may  be  applied.  

Cultural  heritage  and  cultural  values  in  the  reserve  need  to  be  systematically  surveyed  and  
mapped.  The  zoning  scheme  therefore  includes  provision  for  a  future  Cultural  Values  Overlay  to  be  
applied  if  cultural  values  locations  requiring  conservation  are  not  within  the  Conservation  and  
Recreation  Zone.      
This  overlay  would  be  activated  by  means  of  a  future  amendment  to  the  Management  Plan.  
Implementation  of  this  overlay  may  require  amendment  of  the  description  or  provisions  of  other  
zones  and  overlays,  and  integration  with  Aboriginal  Heritage  Act  and  Heritage  Act  provisions  to  
ensure  compatibility.  
Under  the  Traditional  Owner  Settlement  Act  2010  (Vic.),  natural  resource  agreements  can  authorise  
activities  such  as  hunting  wildlife  and  game,  fishing,  and  gathering  flora  and  forest  produce.    
No  agreement  over  Buchan  Caves  Reserve  is  in  place.  A  future  agreement  may  require  variation  to  
the  zoning  scheme  and  provisions  of  this  management  plan.  
  
                                             

                                                BUCHAN  CAVES  RESERVE  —  KRAUATUNGALUNG  COUNTRY                           69  
4   CARING  FOR  COUNTRY  
4.1   GUNAIKURNAI  CULTURAL  HERITAGE    
Buchan  Munji,  the  Buchan  Caves  area,  was  used  by  the  Gunaikurnai  as  a  place  to  camp  and  meet  
during  seasonal  migrations  to  and  from  the  high  country.  Although  the  Gunaikurnai  people  did  not  
venture  far  beyond  the  cave  entrances  (caves  were  places  thought  to  be  inhabited  by  wicked  
creatures  such  as  the  Nargun  and  the  Nyols)  the  caves  are  of  high  spiritual  significance,  which  has  
been  maintained  through  traditional  stories.  
Archaeological  evidence  of  Gunaikurnai  use  of  the  area  remains  in  and  around  cave  entrances,  
along  the  Spring  Creek  valley  and  in  artefact  scatters  throughout  the  reserve.    
Four  quarry  sites  and  three  artefact  scatter  sites  have  been  recorded.  Evidence  in  the  broader  
Buchan  region  indicates  the  important  role  of  caves  to  Gunaikurnai  going  back  thousands  of  years,  
including  burials  inside  caves  and  ceremonial  rings.  
Gunaikurnai  oral  history  holds  that  Frank  Moon’s  party,  which  made  the  first  documented  
exploration  of  the  caves  (see  Section  4.3),  was  guided  by  local  Gunaikurnai  people,  who  were  not  
acknowledged.1  
Today  the  caves  remain  important  to  Gunaikurnai  as  a  meeting  place  with  spiritual  significance  that  
holds  important  stories  to  be  shared  with  young  people.  
There  are  other  culturally  important  cave  sites  in  the  vicinity  that  are  not  within  the  reserve.  Cloggs  
Cave,  located  on  private  land  about  four  kilometres  south-­‐east  of  Buchan  Caves  Reserve,  was  used  
as  a  shelter,  and  contains  highly  important  Gunaikurnai  archaeological  deposits.    
The  roof  of  the  rock  shelter  outside  this  cave  is  heavily  blackened,  evidently  from  campfires.  Some  
of  the  artwork  is  extremely  rare,  particularly  the  drawings  done  in  animal  fat  (GLaWAC  2015).    
The  cave  has  an  undisturbed  cultural  sequence  recently  dated  to  around  30  000  years,  with  bone  
and  stone  tools  being  uncovered  in  excavations.    It  is  closed  to  the  public.  

4.2   LAND  AND  WATER  VALUES  
The  Fairy–Royal–Federal–Dukes  cave  system  within  the  reserve  is  approximately  one  kilometre  
long  and  contains  spectacular  stalactite  and  stalagmite  formations,  pillars,  shawls,  rim  pools,  cave  
sediments  and  a  permanent  flowing  stream  (Rosengren  and  McRae-­‐Williams  1981).  It  is  part  of  a  
large  outcrop  of  cave  and  karst-­‐forming  limestones  known  as  the  Buchan–Murrindal  cave  system,  
which  extends  beyond  the  reserve.  This  is  one  of  the  most  extensive  cave  systems  in  Victoria,  
containing  between  four  and  five  kilometres  of  stream  passage,  cut  at  several  levels  and  widened  
in  places  into  caverns  by  block  collapse.    
The  limestone  rock  at  Buchan  was  laid  down  about  380  million  years  ago  under  shallow  seas  that  
covered  much  of  East  Gippsland.  Vertical  joint  lines  across  the  layers  of  limestone  allowed  water  to  
seep  through  the  rock,  dissolving  the  limestone  to  form  the  caves.  Water  dripping  from  the  ceiling  
of  the  caves  and  then  evaporating,  deposited  calcite,  forming  stalactites  and  stalagmites.  There  are  
numerous  fossils  in  the  limestone.
Bats  inhabit  some  caves  in  the  reserve.  They  are  known  to  use  caves  in  the  area  for  overwintering  
and  roosting,  but  recent  survey  and  monitoring  data  is  limited.    
Cave  invertebrates  were  surveyed  in  the  1980s  (Yen  and  Milledge  1990),  but  there  is  no  current  
data  on  their  presence  and  condition.  

                                                                                                                                        
1  Gunaikurnai  Elder  Auntie  Rita  Watkins  (deceased)  

70                        GUNAIKURNAI  AND  VICTORIAN  GOVERNMENT  JOINT  MANAGEMENT  PLAN  
The  reserve  includes  four  Ecological  Vegetation  Classes  (EVCs),  the  standard  categorisation  of  
native  vegetation  used  in  Victoria.    Around  40%  of  the  reserve  is  covered  by  Shrubby  Dry  Forest,  
which  is  relatively  common  in  the  East  Gippsland  uplands  bioregion.    
Grassy  Woodland  and  Valley  Grassy  Forest,  both  of  which  are  depleted  in  the  East  Gippsland  
bioregion,  cover  approximately  half  of  the  Reserve  area,  and  there  is  a  small  pocket  of  endangered  
Warm  Temperate  Rainforest  on  Spring  Creek.    
The  reserve  contains  a  variety  of  native  and  introduced  vegetation,  including  several  species  listed  
as  threatened  under  the  Flora  and  Fauna  Guarantee  Act  1988  (Vic.)  and  the  Environment  
Protection  and  Biodiversity  Conservation  Act  1999  (Cwlth)  such  as  Limestone  Blue  Wattle  and  Leafy  
Greenhood  Orchid.  
Buchan  Caves  Reserve  supports  significant  wildlife,  and    over  100  species  of  birds  have  been  
recorded  there.  King  Parrots,  White-­‐winged  Choughs  and  currawongs  are  commonly  seen  in  the  
reserve,  along  with  Eastern  Grey  Kangaroos  and  Brush-­‐tailed  Possums.  Platypuses  inhabit  the  
reserve’s  waterways,  particularly  at  Moon  Cave,  which  is  an  important  breeding  location  and  has  
management  guidelines  in  place  to  control  disturbance.  They  are  also  present  in  Dukes  Cave.  
There  are  records  of  several  species  rare  or  threatened  fauna  species  in  the  reserve.  They  include  
two  endangered  species  (Spot-­‐tailed  Quoll  and  Growling  Grass  Frog)  and  three  vulnerable  species  
(Australian  Grayling,  Powerful  Owl  and  Speckled  Warbler)  and  the  near-­‐threatened  Hooded  Robin.  
However,  it  is  not  certain  whether  these  species  are  still  present  in  the  reserve.  
DELWP’s  NatureKit  biodiversity  data  products  provide  important  information  for  conserving  flora  
and  fauna  in  the  reserve.    
  
Table  2:    Significant  species  in  Buchan  Caves  Reserve.  

     Scientific  name                         Common  name                  Conservation             FFG  Action  
                                                                            status                   Statement  

     Prototroctes  maraena                    Australian  Grayling          vulnerable                    57  

     Ninox  strenua                           Powerful  Owl                 vulnerable                    92  

     Melanodryas  cucullata  cucullata        Hooded  Robin                 near  threatened               —  

     Chthonicola  sagittatus                  Speckled  Warbler             vulnerable                     —  

     Dasyurus  maculatus  maculatus           Spot-­‐tailed  Quoll          endangered                    15  

     Litoria  raniformis                      Growling  Grass  Frog         endangered                     —  

     Acacia  caerulescens                     Limestone  Blue  Wattle       vulnerable                   222  

Landscape  and  catchment  context  
The  reserve  lies  within  the  Far  East  Catchments  landscape  program  of  the  East  Gippsland  
Catchment  Management  Authority  (EGCMA).  The  program  aims  to  maintain  the  condition  of  
significant  and  relatively  undisturbed  landscape  of  these  catchments  with  their  large  and  
continuous  extent  of  natural  ecosystems,  from  the  mountains  to  the  coast.    
The  Regional  Catchment  Strategy  (EGCMA  2013)  identifies  the  broad  landscape  objectives  for  
public  land  as:  
•   maintenance  and  targeted  improvement  of  the  condition,  security,  diversity  and  integrity  of  
    natural  ecosystems  and  the  status  of  threatened  species  and  communities  
•   maintenance  of  soil  condition  and  stability  on  public  land.  

                                           BUCHAN  CAVES  RESERVE  —  KRAUATUNGALUNG  COUNTRY                        71  
4.3   HISTORIC  HERITAGE  
Buchan  Caves  Reserve  is  listed  on  the  Victorian  Heritage  Register  under  the  provisions  of  the  
Heritage  Act  2017  (Vic.)  for  the  aesthetic,  scientific  and  historical  significance,  notably  the  
spectacular  caves  and  geological  formations  that  comprise  the  underground  features  of  the  
reserve.    
The  caves  were  known  to  the  Gunaikurnai  for  at  least  30  000  years.  The  earliest  known  post-­‐
settlement  reference  to  the  caves  was  in  1840,  and  the  earliest  known  tourist  reference  is  in  a  
Gippsland  Lakes  guide  from  1886,  but  the  caves  were  probably  a  visitor  curiosity  before  then.    
The  first  government  reservation  was  a  camping  reserve  of  19  acres  in  1887  along  the  line  of  the  
Buchan–Gelantipy  Road,  while  the  caves  continued  to  be  used  unofficially  for  picnics  and  functions.    
In  1889  a  government  party  reported  on  and  photographed  Duke's  Cave,  Wilson  Cave,  Spring  Creek  
Cave,  Dickson's  Cave,  O’Rourke  Cave,  and  Moon  Cave.  The  first  regulations  for  the  protection  of  
the  caves  were  promulgated  and  between  1903  and  1910,  when  the  Shire  of  Tambo  was  appointed  
as  Committee  of  Management.  
In  1906  Frank  Moon  explored  Moon's  Cave,  and  Moon  was  subsequently  appointed  to  officially  
search  for  new  caves.  This  led  to  exploration  of  Kitson’s  Cave  in  1906  and  Fairy  Cave  in  1907.    
By  the  time  of  the  First  World  War  the  area  was  being  promoted  by  the  Victorian  Railways  and  
other  organisations,  and  the  caves  had  become  a  very  popular  tourist  attraction.  Infrastructure  
works  in  the  caves  before  this  time  included  some  lighting  and  barriers.  After  the  war  an  electric  
lighting  plant  was  installed,  and  a  tunnel  was  dug  to  link  Fairy  Cave  with  Royal  Cave.  
The  Statement  of  Significance  in  the  Victorian  Heritage  Register  notes  a  range  of  elements  that  
contribute  to  the  importance  of  the  reserve:    
•   The  Buchan  Caves  Reserve,  part  of  the  outstanding  Buchan–Murrindal  cave  system,  set  aside  in  
    1901  for  public  purposes  and  the  protection  of  natural  features  and  landscaped  in  the  1930s,  is  
    of  State  cultural  significance:    
    –   as  an  example  of  an  early  tourist  attraction  in  Victoria  based  on  natural  themes;  the  ongoing  
         use  of  the  caves  for  tourist  purposes  is  an  important  aspect  of  this  significance,  as  is  the  
         tradition  of  guiding  and  transmission  of  oral  history;  early  attributes  of  the  reserve  include  
         the  caves  and  their  entries,  caretaker's  residence  and  the  landscaping  of  the  1930s  
    –   aesthetically  and  scientifically,  for  the  spectacular  caves  and  geological  formations  which  
         comprise  the  underground  features  of  the  reserve;  these  natural  features  have  been  
         exploited  by  human  intervention,  especially  the  use  of  light  and  the  use  of  barriers  to  
         protect  formations;  this  last  attribute  is  part  of  the  careful  work  of  Frederick  Wilson  from  
         1907  onwards  and  is  now  rare  on  a  national  and  even  international  basis  
    –   as  a  mature  example  of  the  landscape  work  of  Hugh  Linaker,  a  pioneering  designer  of  public  
         landscapes;  the  1930s  landscaping  at  Buchan  has  been  carefully  tended  and  sympathetically  
         augmented  in  subsequent  years  and  is  exemplified  by  the  mature  trees  in  the  reserve,  the  
         high  proportion  of  deciduous  exotic  species,  the  road  layout  and  small  rustic  rotunda  
    –   for  the  manner  in  which  the  reserve  demonstrates  the  influence  of  contemporary  1930s  
         National  Parks  landscape  ideals;  here  represented  by  the  incorporation  of  recreational  
         facilities  such  as  the  swimming  pool  and  tennis  courts  and  the  use  of  a  self-­‐consciously  
         rugged  design  idiom  (such  as  the  bold  log  structures  at  the  entry  gateway,  the  rugged  stone  
         construction  of  the  kitchen  and  the  log  construction  of  the  kiosk)  
    –   for  its  high  aesthetic  values,  including  the  exploitation  of  seasonal  contrast  by  the  use  of  
         deciduous  trees,  the  contrast  between  exotic  trees  with  the  surrounding  landscape,  the  
         manner  in  which  the  roadway  winds  up  the  Spring  Creek  valley,  and  for  views  within  and  out  
         of  the  reserve  
    –   for  the  manner  in  which  in  the  Caves  Reserve  and  Buchan  township  demonstrate  the  
         development  of  tourism  within  Gippsland,  and  the  demands  of  that  tourism  on  the  natural  
         environment.  

72     GUNAIKURNAI  AND  VICTORIAN  GOVERNMENT  JOINT  MANAGEMENT  PLAN  
4.4   THREATS  TO  COUNTRY  AND  HERITAGE  
Visitor  impacts  
Visitor  impacts  on  the  cave  system  can  include  changes  to  the  physical  structure  of  the  cave,  water  
movement,  cave  hydrology,  air  movement  and  microclimate,  as  well  as  the  effects  of  artificial  light,  
compaction  of  floors,  changes  to  cave  biota  and  surface  impacts  such  as  erosion  and  vegetation  
change.  These  effects  can  be  independent  of  one  another,  cumulative,  or  synergistic.  They  can  also  
be  related  to  the  number  of  visitors  to  the  cave  at  any  one  time,  and  the  frequency  of  visits.      
A  number  of  tools  are  available  to  ensure  tourist  visits  and  other  uses  of  the  caves  are  sustainable.  
These  include  the  Buchan  Caves  Guiding  Resource  Manual,  resources  on  the  Australasian  Cave  and  
Karst  Management  Association’s  website  (http://www.ackma.org),  and  Principles  for  Guided  Cave  
Interpretation  (Davidson  and  Black  2007).  
Victorian  and  international  management  guidelines  provide  general  guidance  on  management  and  
conservation  of  karst  and  caves  (Davey  and  White  1986;  IUCN  1997).    More  detailed  management  
guidance  for  the  substantial  cave  complex  at  Buchan  Caves  is  needed  in  the  form  of  a  Cave  and  
Karst  Plan,  incorporating  input  by  speleological  bodies  and  Parks  Victoria’s  Cave  and  Karst  Advisory  
Group.  This  plan  should  include:  
•   an  inventory  of  all  known  caves  and  other  karst  features  
•   information  on  all  natural  and  cultural  values  associated  with  a  feature  or  group  of  features,  
    including  significance  levels,  condition,  threats  and  visitor  use  of  caves  in  the  reserve  
•   management  regimes  for  each  karst  area  and  cave  based  upon  the  establishment  of  acceptable  
    limits  of  disturbance  
•   tailored  monitoring  regimes  to  measure  disturbance  within  karst  catchments  and  at  individual  
    karst  features  including  caves  
•   general  and  feature-­‐specific  management  responses  to  disturbance  
•   environmental  management  practices  that  will  ensure  the  ongoing  protection  of  the  reserve  
    and  its  significant  karst  formations  
•   records  of  management  works  and  operations  carried  out  in  each  karst  area  and  at  individual  
    karst  features  
•   cave  search  and  rescue  protocols  
•   a  register  of  karst  and  karst  management  specialists  
•   records  of  all  past  and  ongoing  karst  research  undertaken  in  the  reserve  
•   research  priorities  for  individual  karst  areas  and  features.  

Invasive  plants  and  animals  
Weeds  have  the  potential  to  affect  the  significant  vegetation  communities  and  some  of  the  
reserve’s  important  habitats.  The  challenge  is  to  maintain  the  relatively  intact  nature  of  the  
vegetation  within  the  reserve  and  protect  it  from  new  introductions.  
Browsing  and  soil  disturbance  from  introduced  herbivores  such  as  deer  and  rabbits  has  a  significant  
impact  on  the  reserve’s  plants  and  animals.  

Climate  change  
Climate  change  is  a  potential  intensifier  of  existing  and  new  threats.  These  include  changes  to  
hydrology,  increased  frequency  and  severity  of  extreme  events,  changes  in  vegetation  arising  from  
rainfall  and  evaporation  changes.    
Changes  to  the  hydrology  would  threaten  the  karst  and  those  caves  and  cave  biota  that  have  a  
continuing  relationship  with  water  levels  or  water  quality.  Changes  to  the  karst  system  may  also  
have  hydrological  affects.    
Changes  such  as  vegetation  alteration  are  likely  to  occur  gradually,  while  more  extreme  events  
such  as  storms  and  floods  could  occur  at  any  time.  Storms  increase  the  risk  of  inundation  and  
damage  to  physical  assets  and  public  safety.  The  Reserve  has  a  relatively  small  catchment,  but  the  

                                          BUCHAN  CAVES  RESERVE  —  KRAUATUNGALUNG  COUNTRY                         73  
You can also read