Status and perspec-ves of AP in Spain: Cosmology

Page created by Dave Carter
 
CONTINUE READING
Status and perspec-ves of AP in Spain: Cosmology
Status	
  and	
  perspec-ves	
  of	
  AP	
  in	
  Spain:	
  Cosmology
                                                          Francisco Prada
                                      Campus	
  of	
  Interna-onal	
  Excellence	
  UAM+CSIC	
  
                                          Ins-tuto	
  de	
  Física	
  Teórica	
  (UAM/CSIC)	
  
                                        Ins-tuto	
  de	
  AstroGsica	
  de	
  Andalucía	
  (CSIC)

Granada,	
  Nov	
  27th	
  2012	
  
Status and perspec-ves of AP in Spain: Cosmology
Outline

• Science	
  mo-va-on	
  
• Current	
  and	
  future	
  experiments:	
  	
  
	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  Spain	
  par-cipa-on	
  
• Theory	
  and	
  Simula-on	
  efforts	
  
• Remarks	
  
Status and perspec-ves of AP in Spain: Cosmology
Accelerated expansion of the Universe

                        (Ωm , ΩΛ) = (0.27, 0.73)	
  

Hubble Diagram
Status and perspec-ves of AP in Spain: Cosmology
http://supernova.lbl.gov/

ORM,	
  La	
  Palma	
  -­‐	
  ICTS	
     Acknowledgements
Status and perspec-ves of AP in Spain: Cosmology
Observational evidences
               Matter-Energy
                 WMAP	
      Density of the Universe	
  

                                                           BOSS

BOSS+WMAP+SN
Status and perspec-ves of AP in Spain: Cosmology
Top Scientific Objectives

The two highest level questions in the field are the following:

•   Is cosmic acceleration caused by a breakdown of GR on cosmological scales, or is it
    caused by a new energy component with negative pressure ("dark energy") within
    GR?

•   If the acceleration is caused by "dark energy," is its energy density constant in space
    and time and thus consistent with quantum vacuum energy or does its energy
    density evolve in time and/or vary in space? 	
  
Status and perspec-ves of AP in Spain: Cosmology
Main Goals
For physical cosmology, the clearest path forward is to measure the history of cosmic expansion and
the growth of dark matter clustering over a wide range of redshifts with the highest achievable
precision, searching for deviations from the concordance model based on GR and a cosmological
constant for a spatially flat universe, i.e. Lambda Cold Dark Matter (ΛCDM):

          H 2 (z)
                  = !m (1+ z)3 + !r (1+ z)4 + !DE Friedmann equa-on	
  for	
  the	
  expansion of a
           H0 2                                   homogeneous and isotropic flat universe	
  

Supernova surveys measure the distance-redshift relation using "standardized candles" whose
luminosities are calibrated by objects in the local Hubble flow. Redshift surveys (e.g. BOSS and other
upcoming future experiments), on the other hand, employs a "standard ruler," the BAO feature
imprinted on matter/galaxy clustering by sound waves that propagate through the baryon-photon fluid
in the pre-recombination universe .

                                                         The current BAO distance-redshift relation. The flat ΛCDM
           Measuring DA(z) and H(z)                       prediction from the best-fit WMAP7 model is also shown.
Status and perspec-ves of AP in Spain: Cosmology
The BAO scale can be computed, in absolute units, using physics and cosmological parameters that are
well constrained by cosmic microwave background measurements. BAO are predicted to appear as a
bump in the matter correlation function at a comoving scale corresponding to the sound horizon (r =
153.2 ± 1.7 Mpc; WMAP) or as a damped series of oscillations in the matter power spectrum.
Status and perspec-ves of AP in Spain: Cosmology
Current & Future Surveys: Galaxies & QSOs

                         BigBOSS	
          Euclid	
  
Status and perspec-ves of AP in Spain: Cosmology
Cosmology from galaxy & QSO surveys
                                                              What	
  are	
  the	
  cons-tuents	
  of	
  maZer?	
  
                                                              What	
  is	
  the	
  physics	
  of	
  infla-on?	
  
                                                              e.g.	
  neutrino	
  mass,	
  primordial	
  P(k)	
  

                                                              What	
  is	
  the	
  expansion	
  
                                                              rate	
  of	
  the	
  Universe?	
  
                                                              e.g.	
  quintessence,	
  Λ	
  
                                                                                                         Understanding	
  	
  
                                                                                                         accelera-on	
  
                          RedshiX-­‐Space	
  distor-ons	
  
                                                              How	
  does	
  structure	
  form	
  
  Galaxy	
  RedshiX	
                                         within	
  this	
  background?	
  
      Survey	
                                                e.g.	
  modified	
  gravity,	
  GR	
  

                                                              Is	
  the	
  Universe	
  homogeneous	
  	
  
                                                              on	
  large	
  scales?	
  
                                                              e.g.	
  Non-­‐Gaussianity	
  

                                                              Other	
  non-­‐cosmology	
  science	
  
                                                              e.g.	
  galaxy	
  forma-on	
  &	
  evolu-on	
  
10	
  
Current & Future Surveys: CMB & X-rays

    South Pole Telescope   eROSITA	
  
Current & Future Surveys:
21cm fluctuations and 21cm redshift surveys
                                              LOFAR	
  

                                         MWA	
  

                                                   SKA	
  
Approved ongoing and future cosmology projects
               SURVEYS             Method            Leading           Status
       [S] VIPERS                   RSD                EU            2009-2015
       [S] SDSS-III BOSS        BAO/RSD/Lya           USA            2009-2014
       [Ipz] VST/KIDS          WL, SN, Clusters,       EU            2011-2016
                                    BAO
       [Ipz] DES               WL, SN, Clusters,       USA         Late 2012-2017
                                    BAO
       [S] HETDEX                   BAO                USA           2013-2015
       [S] eBOSS                BAO/RSD/Lya            USA           2014-2020
       [Ipz] Subaru HSC        WL, SN, Cluster         Japan            ----
       [S] Subaru PFS               BAO                Japan            ----
       [I+S] Euclid             WL, BAO, SN             EU           2020-2027
       [S] BigBOSS              BAO/RSD/Lya            USA           2018-2022
       [S] 4MOST                    BAO                 EU           2018-2022
       [Ipz] LSST             WL, SN, Clustering       USA           2020-2030
       [Ipz] PAU                    BAO                Spain        construction
       [Ipz] J-PAS                  BAO                Spain        construction
       [R] DESpec                 BAO/RSD              USA              ----
       [X] eROSITA                 Clusters             EU           2014-2019
       [R] LOFAR                Radio sources,          EU           2013-2018
                               21cm fluctuations
       [R] SKA                21cm galaxy survey      Global       2019-onwards
       [I] SCP                       SNe              USA            2014-2017
       [I] SN Factory, PFT,          SNe              USA           Up to 2018
       QUEST
       [I] SkyMapper                SNe              Australia       2014-2019
       [I] Pan-Starrs PS1         WL, SNe,            USA          2010-onwards
                                 Clustering
       [M] Planck                  CMB                 EU             ongoing
       [M] SPT, ACT            (CMB) SZ, Pol          USA             ongoing
       [M] Quijote               (CMB) Pol            Spain           ongoing
       [21cm] EDGES,BOABAB,   21cm fluctuations    USA/Australia      ongoing
       PAPER, MWA

      [S] spectroscopic, [I] imaging, [Ipz] imaging photo-z,
      [X] X-ray, [M] Microwave, [21cm] neutral hydrogen 21cm
Dark energy: theoretical aspects
                    Model Building & Simulations
 Is there a more fundamental theory for cosmic acceleration?

Gµν	
  +	
  GµνMG = 8πG (Tµν +Tµν DE)	
  
  	
  Modified	
  gravity	
                                    	
  Dark	
  energy	
  

                                   Mul.Dark	
  Run	
  1	
  
Working Projects or in Commissioning Phase
        with Spanish Participation
SDSS-­‐III	
  Collabora-on:	
            BOSS = Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey

    Spanish Participation Group (IFIC,
    UB-ICREA, MultiDark: IFT-UAM/CSIC)

                                                   First BOSS spectroscopic data release, DR9 @ Jul 2012

http://www.sdss3.org/
BOSS Galaxy clustering statistics
                                                 Turnover in the power spectrum

                                                                                                     Anderson	
  et	
  al.	
  2012	
  
                                                                    Wiggles in the power spectrum
     SDSS-­‐III/BOSS	
                               P(k)	
  

                              Galaxy Sky Map

                                                                                                     Sanchez	
  et	
  al.	
  2012	
  
                                                 2-­‐pt	
  CF	
  

                                                                             Bump in the CF

http://www.sdss3.org/
                              Galaxy Redshifts                                    Zero Crossing in the CF

     17	
  
BOSS Ly-alpha forest results
The Lyman-alpha forest is detected through the
       imprint of hydrogen cloud absorpt
ion lines on the light from background quasars.

http://www.sdss3.org/
                                                  Baryon	
  Acous.c	
  Oscilla.ons	
  in	
  the	
  Ly-­‐alpha	
  
                                                              	
  forest	
  of	
  BOSS	
  quasars
BOSS Cosmology: first results from DR9!

Ωm –ωDE plane for LDCM redshift                       The BAO distance-redshift relation divided by the best-fit
   -independent value of wDE                               flat, CDM prediction from WMAP (grey band)

                                                                                          Ly-­‐alpha	
  
                                  http://www.sdss3.org/

ω0–ωa plane by allowing for
   variations on wDE(a)
DES:	
  The	
  DARK	
  ENERGY	
  SURVEY	
  
•	
  Southern	
  Hemisphere	
  	
  5000	
  deg2	
  galaxy	
  survey	
  in	
  5	
  bands	
  (g,r,I,z,Y)	
  Op-cal	
  and	
  NIR	
  
•	
  World	
  leader.	
  Involves	
  groups	
  in	
  USA,	
  Spain,	
  UK,	
  Brazil,	
  Germany,	
  Switzerland.	
  
                                                              525	
  nights	
  in	
  5	
  years	
  
                                                     FIRST	
  LIGHT	
  IN	
  	
  SEPTEMBER	
  2012	
  
Credit: Dark Energy Survey Collaboration
Main	
  Spanish	
  Contribu.ons	
  to	
  DES	
  
•	
  Electronics:	
  
       –	
  Design	
  of	
  the	
  Clock	
  &	
  Bias	
  (CIEMAT),	
  Transi-on	
  (IFAE/CIEMAT)	
  and	
  
       Master	
  Control	
  (IFAE)	
  Boards	
  
       –	
  Produc-on	
  and	
  commissioning	
  of	
  the	
  whole	
  read-­‐out	
  electronics	
  
       for	
  the	
  camera:	
  108	
  boards,	
  finished	
  in	
  fall	
  2010	
  (IFAE/CIEMAT)	
  
       –	
  CCD	
  characteriza-on	
  (CIEMAT/IFAE/IEEC)	
  
       –	
  Guider:	
  develop,	
  integrate	
  and	
  commission	
  the	
  camera	
  guider	
  
       algorithm	
  (IEEC)	
  	
  
•	
  Simula.ons:	
  
       –	
  Large	
  scale	
  simula-ons	
  of	
  the	
  universe	
  (ICE-­‐CSIC)	
  
       –	
  Data	
  management	
  (PIC)	
  
       –	
  Data	
  quality	
  checks	
  (CIEMAT)	
  
•	
  Science:	
  
       –	
  Large	
  scale	
  structure	
  (ICE-­‐CSIC,	
  IEEC,	
  UAM,	
  CIEMAT)	
  
       –	
  Photo-­‐z	
  (IEEC,	
  IFAE)	
  
       –	
  Supernovae	
  (IFAE)	
  
DES	
  Science	
  Reach	
  
Four	
  Probes	
  of	
  Dark	
  Energy	
                                              Forecast	
  Constraints	
  on	
  DE	
  
• Galaxy	
  Clusters	
                                                                   DES	
  
                                                                                      Equa-on	
  of	
  State	
  
    • ~100,000	
  clusters	
  to	
  z>1	
  
    • Synergy	
  with	
  SPT,	
  VHS	
  
    • Sensi-ve	
  to	
  growth	
  of	
  structure	
  and	
  
          geometry	
  
• Weak	
  Lensing	
  
    • Shape	
  measurements	
  of	
  200	
  million	
  
          galaxies	
  	
  
    • Sensi-ve	
  to	
  growth	
  of	
  structure	
  and	
  
          geometry	
  
• Baryon	
  Acous.c	
  Oscilla.ons	
  
                                                                                  Planck	
  prior	
  assumed	
  
    • 300	
  million	
  galaxies	
  to	
  z	
  =	
  1	
  and	
  beyond	
  
    • Sensi-ve	
  to	
  geometry	
  
• Supernovae	
  
    • 30	
  sq	
  deg	
  -me-­‐domain	
  survey	
                            Factor	
  3-­‐5	
  improvement	
  over	
  	
  
    • ~4000	
  well-­‐sampled	
  SNe	
  Ia	
  to	
  z	
  ~1	
  
                                                                             Stage	
  II	
  DETF	
  Figure	
  of	
  Merit	
  
    • Sensi-ve	
  to	
  geometry	
  
The Planck mission

ØMedium	
  size	
  mission	
  of	
  the	
  ESA	
  scien-fic	
  
program.	
  
ØPlanck will provide all-sky measurements
of the microwave sky with unprecedented
sensitivity, resolution and spectral range.
ØTwo instruments (each one provided by an
international consortium):
       • Low Frequency Instrument, LFI
       PI: R. Mandolesi, INAF/IASF, Bologna                             Herschel
       LFI is still functioning (until 2013-2014)
       • High Frequency Instrument, HFI
       PI: J.L. Puget, IAS, Paris                                  Planck
       HFI was switched-off on January 2012
ØSpanish contribution to the two
instruments
Ø Launched, together with Herschel, in an
Ariane 5: 14 May, 2009
Spanish contribution to the instruments
  Ø IFCA (UC-CSIC) + DICOM (UC) + DTSC (UPC), E. Martínez-
  González (Co-I LFI), E. Artal (technical responsible)
        BEM (Back End Module) of the 30 and 44 GHz radiometers
  Ø IAC, R. Rebolo (Co-I LFI)
     REBA (Radiometer Electronic Box Assembly), REBA
  software and software of data compression onboard of LFI
  Ø Univ. of Granada, E. Battaner (Co-I HFI)
        Preregulator for the 4 K cooling system of the HFI

There	
  is	
  also	
  an	
  important	
  Spanish	
  contribu-on	
  to	
  the	
  scien-fic	
  exploita-on	
  of	
  the	
  data!	
  
Scientific Objectives of the Planck mission

Ø Measure the temperature and polarization anisotropies
with unprecedented resolution and sensitivity
Ø Determine the cosmological parameters with errors of
≤ 1%: ΩΛ, Ωm, Ωb, H0, τ, ns, A
Ø Confirm (or maybe rule out) the concordance model
Ø Determine the inflationary model parameters
Ø Constrain the gravitational wave background
Ø Test the isotropy and Gaussian hypotheses (e.g. search
for topological defects)
Full sky maps of foreground emission
                           after 1 year mission
                           Planck all channels

First	
  cosmological	
  results	
  will	
  be	
  published	
  in	
  early	
  2013	
  (probably	
  March)!	
  
The QUIJOTE CMB experiment

                                                              IP:	
  Rafael	
  Rebolo	
  
Scien-fic	
  goals:	
  

*   FGI and second telescope funded by the project Consolider-Ingenio 2010 “EPI”

 First	
  light	
  of	
  the	
  Instrument	
  I	
  (MFI)	
  on	
  November	
  6th,	
  2012.	
  
 Instrument	
  II	
  (TGI)	
  expected	
  for	
  end	
  2013.	
  
 Instrument	
  III	
  (FGI)	
  expected	
  for	
  mid	
  2014.	
  
The QUIJOTE CMB consortium
                                                  ( http://www.iac.es/project/cmb/quijote )
                                 Ins.tuto	
  de	
  AstroXsica	
  de	
  Canarias	
  
        R.	
  Rebolo	
  (PI),	
  J.A.	
  Rubiño-­‐Marvn	
  (PS),	
  R.	
  Génova-­‐Santos,	
  R.	
  Hoyland	
  (InstS),	
  A.	
  Perez	
  
                (PM),	
  F.	
  Gómez-­‐Reñasco,	
  M.	
  Aguiar,	
  C.	
  López-­‐Caraballo,	
  A.	
  Pelaez,	
  V.	
  Sanchez,	
  A.	
  
                                                                Vega,	
  T.	
  Viera	
  

                                           Ins.tuto	
  de	
  Física	
  de	
  Cantabria	
  
        E.	
  Marvnez-­‐González,	
  P.	
  Vielva,	
  D.	
  Herranz,	
  F.J.	
  Casas,	
  B.	
  Barreiro,	
  R.	
  Fernández-­‐Cobos,	
  M.	
  
                                                      López-­‐Caniego,	
  D.	
  Or-z	
  García	
  

                       Departamento	
  Ingeniería	
  de	
  Comunicaciones	
  
                   E.	
  Artal,	
  B.	
  Aja,	
  J.L.	
  Cano,	
  L.	
  de	
  la	
  Fuente,	
  A.	
  Mediavilla,	
  J.P.	
  Pascual,	
  E.	
  Villa	
  	
  

                                                   Jodrell	
  Bank	
  Observatory	
  
                 L.	
  Piccirillo,	
  B.	
  Maffei,	
  G.	
  Pisano,	
  R.A.	
  Watson,	
  R.	
  Davis,	
  R.	
  Davies,	
  C.	
  Dickinson	
  

                                                    University	
  of	
  Cambridge	
  
               M.	
  Hobson,	
  M.	
  Brown,	
  A.	
  Challinor,	
  K.	
  Grainge,	
  A.	
  Lasenby,	
  R.	
  Saunders,	
  P.	
  ScoZ	
  

                                                                             IDOM	
  
                 G.	
  Murga,	
  C.	
  Gómez,	
  A.Gómez,	
  J.	
  Ariño,	
  R.	
  Sanquirce,	
  J.Pan,	
  A.	
  Vizcargüenaga	
  
Projects	
  in	
  Construc-on,	
  Design	
  &	
  R&D	
  phase	
  
             with	
  Spanish	
  Par-cipa-on	
  
BigBOSS: The Ground-Based Stage IV BAO Experiment

   •      Currently BOSS is covering ~ 6h-3Gpc3
                                                     Spain	
  was	
  invited	
  at	
  the	
  start	
  
          1.5M galaxies                              Of	
  the	
  Project	
  
   •      BigBOSS will cover ~ 50h-3Gpc3
          20M galaxies
     (unprecedented volume & statistics to test for indications of new physics)
   • BigBOSS will cover 14,000 deg2

 32	
  
BigBOSS: Status, Progress, and Plans

  •        Announcement of Opportunity for Large Science Programs Providing New
           Observing Capabilities for the Mayall 4m Telescope on Kitt Peak
           Letters of intent (LoI), March 2010 à 500 nights awarded
  •        CD-0 granted (Successful Review in Dec’11)
            - Science Case
            - Preliminary design
            - R&D
  •        CD-1 is coming soon …
            - Conceptual design report (and review)                        KPNO	
  Mayall	
  4m	
  
            - Complete R&D
            - Complete cost and schedule baseline
            - Construction foreseen for 2014
            - First Light 2018

                     BigBOSS has key international partners:
                         China, Spain [positioners]
                         France [spectrograph]
  33	
                   Spain [focal plate]
                         UK [optics, fibers]
The BigBOSS Dark Energy Survey
        ®¦K^^^‘®›Ä㮥®‘K¹›‘ã®ò›͗W›Ù¥ÊÙÃ^ユ›/sK^֛‘ãÙÊݑÊÖ®‘^çÙò›ù	
  
                           	
   1
                       LEsEL	
                                                                                 LEsEL	
  Ϯ	
                                                    LEsEL	
  ϯ
 	
  
	
  	
  ^‘®›Ä㮥®‘R›Øç®Ù›Ã›ÄãÝ                                                             Dƒãƒ	
  ^›ã	
  R›Øç®Ù›Ã›ÄãÝ                                 IÄÝãÙçÛÄãR›Øç®Ù›Ã›ÄãÝ
                                                                                                                                                         ͻOpĞƌĂƟoŶĂl	
  CoŶƐtƌĂŝŶtƐ
              	
  
 ͻDĞĂƐƵƌĞƚŚĞĚŝƐtĂŶcĞ	
   ƐcĂlĞĞƌƌŽƌ                                                ͻ^ƵƌvĞy	
  AƌĞĂ:	
  1ϰ,ϬϬϬ	
  Ɛq	
  dĞg                            -­‐	
  <	
  ϱϬϬ	
  ŶŝgŚtƐ
 mRͬZtoĨŽƌϬ͘ϱфz	
  фϯ͘Ϭ                                                                                                                      -­‐	
  IŶƐtƌƵmĞŶt	
  compĂƟďlĞ	
  wŝtŚ
 	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  ;ŝŶϲďŝŶƐǁŝƚŚ6ůŶ;ϭнnjͿсϬ͘ϮͿ	
  	
  	
  
                                                                                        ͻRĞdƐŚŝŌƌĂŶŐĞ͗                                                    	
  	
  	
  DĂyĂll	
  tĞlĞƐcopĞ
                                                                                        	
  	
  	
  -­‐	
  LR'ƐϬ͘ϱфzфϭ͘Ϭ                              -­‐	
  PƌĞƐĞƌǀĞƵƐĞof	
  Ĩͬ8	
  ƐĞcoŶdĂƌy
 ͻDĞĂƐƵƌĞ,;njͿƚŽϭ͘ϱйƵƉƚŽnjсϮ͘ϱ                                                    	
  	
  	
  -­‐	
  EL'ƐϬ͘ϱфzфϭ͘ϲ
 	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  ;ŝŶϰďŝŶƐĂƚфnjх	
  с	
  Ϭ͘7,	
  1͘1,	
  1͘ϱ͕Ϯ͘ϱͿ               ͲdƌĂĐĞƌQ^OƐϬ͘ϱфzфϯ͘ϱ                                      -­‐	
  TypŝcĂl	
  ƐĞĞŝŶg,	
  wĞĂtŚĞƌ	
  foƌ
                                                                                        	
  	
  	
  -­‐	
  Ly-­‐_Q^OƐϮ͘Ϯфzфϯ͘ϱ                        	
  	
  	
  ƐŝtĞ	
  ƵƐĞd	
  ŝŶ	
  foƌĞcĂƐtƐ
 ͻŽŶƐƚƌĂŝŶgƌowtŚ,	
  m;njͿ	
  Ĩ;njͿ͕ǁŝƚŚ                                            	
  	
  	
  
 	
  	
  	
  	
  
BigBOSS Collaboration

                                                                                 … and growing!
  US Members:
  Brookhaven National Laboratory, Carnegie Mellon University, Fermi National Accelerator
  Laboratory, Johns Hopkins University, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, National
  Optical Astronomy Observatory, New York University, The Ohio State University, SLAC
  National Accelerator Laboratory, University of California, Berkeley, University of Kansas,
  University of Michigan, University of Pittsburgh, University of Utah, Yale University, Harvard
  International Institutions:
  Ewha Womans University, Korea; French Participation Group; Goettigen Univ., Mexico
  Participation group; Spanish Participation Group; Shanghai Astronomical Observatory, UK
  Participation Group; University of Science and Technology of China.
BigBOSS in Spain
          BigBOSS	
  Spain	
  Par.cipa.on	
  Group	
  (BSPG):	
  
          •	
  Campus	
  de	
  Excelencia	
  Internacional	
  UAM+CSIC	
  
          	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  Contact:	
  F.	
  Prada	
  (BSPG	
  Spokesperson)	
  

          	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  -­‐	
  Ins-tuto	
  de	
  Física	
  Teórica,	
  IFT-­‐UAM/CSIC	
  
          	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  Contact:	
  A.	
  González-­‐Arroyo	
  
          	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  -­‐	
  HCTLab,	
  Escuela	
  Politécnica	
  Superior,	
  EPS-­‐UAM	
  
          	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  Contact:	
  G.	
  Glez.	
  de	
  Ribera	
  
          	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  -­‐	
  Dpto.	
  de	
  Física	
  Teórica,	
  DFT-­‐UAM	
  
          	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  Contact:	
  G.	
  Yepes	
  
          	
  
          •	
  Ins-tuto	
  de	
  AstroGsica	
  de	
  Andalucía,	
  IAA-­‐CSIC	
  
          	
  	
  	
  Contact:	
  J.	
  Sanchez	
  
          •	
  Ins-tuto	
  de	
  AstroGsica	
  de	
  Canarias,	
  IAC	
  
          	
  	
  	
  Contact:	
  C.	
  Allende-­‐Prieto	
  
          •	
  Ins-tut	
  de	
  Ciencies	
  del	
  Cosmos,	
  ICC-­‐UB	
  
          	
  	
  	
  Contact:	
  J.	
  Miralda-­‐Escudé	
  
          •	
  Observatori	
  Astronomic	
  de	
  la	
  Univ.	
  de	
  Valencia,	
  OA-­‐UV	
  
          	
  	
  	
  Contact:	
  V.	
  Marvnez	
  
 36	
  
BigBOSS Focal Plane System (Spanish Contribution)
                                                     Fibers
                                                (pointing down)

                                          Spain	
  

 37	
  
BigBOSS Focal Plate
Current technical approach
                                                                                                               •	
  	
  Dimensional	
  verifica-on	
  
   Highly challenging                              A prototype is needed for                                   (manufacturing	
  feasibility)	
  
   requirements in terms of                        checking the feasibility as                                 •	
  Thermal	
  tes-ng	
  
   manufacturing accuracy                          it is required                                              •	
  Interface	
  with	
  fiber	
  
                                                                                                               posi-oners	
  
              ~	
   900mm	
  

                                                                                          200mm	
  ;	
  241	
  holes!	
  

                                                  Sub-­‐scale	
  Demonstrator	
  Plate	
  (SDP)	
  
                                                              Scale	
  ~1:5	
  in	
  diameter	
  
          	
   Focal	
  Plate	
  
      BigBOSS	
  

           •	
  SOW	
  (Statement	
  of	
  Work)	
  for	
  the	
  produc-on	
  of	
  the	
  SDP	
  has	
  been	
  sent	
  to	
  suppliers	
  
           •	
  Feedback	
  from	
  suppliers	
  on-­‐going	
  …	
  Quota-ons	
  to	
  be	
  received	
  next	
  
           •	
  Produc-on	
  of	
  the	
  SDP	
  (end	
  2012	
  /beginning	
  2013)	
  
           •	
  SDP	
  verified	
  (1st	
  quarter	
  2013)	
  
IAA-AVS θ-θ 12mm pitch actuator for Big BOSS
• The new θ-θ dependent-axis concept simplify
  the R1,R2 positions in the fixed rear part of the
  actuator, then easy heat evacuation, cables no
  rotate inside actuator, electronics very near the
  motor.

• Main characteristics
  Pitch: 12mm
  Patrol area: 13.856 mm diameter
  R1,R2 are 365º and 185º respectively
  Precision estimated: +-5 micron at exterior of
      patrol area, with preloaded springs
IAA-AVS θ-θ 12mm pitch actuator for BigBOSS

• Software compensation for induced steps is
  needed
• Torque programmable
• Sensor to detect lost steps (collisions)
• Low consumption electronics very near to
  the motor, reprogrammable on air, IRQ to
  the HOST capability IF collision is detected
• All wired topology proposal, from actuator
  to the HOST

FIRST TESTS:
Prototype repetitively of 6 micron for R1 and
4 micron for R2, hysteresis minimization
with appropriate movement. Currently,
some minor mechanical improvements
are being done as well as a new electronics is
needed for full performance tests.
DESpec:	
  Dark	
  Energy	
  Spectroscopic	
  
                                                 Survey	
  
Next	
  genera-on	
  spectroscopic	
  survey:	
  Follow	
  up	
  for	
  DES	
  
4000-­‐fibre	
  instrument	
  for	
  the	
  4m	
  Blanco	
  telescope	
  
Using	
  DES	
  op-cs	
  and	
  spare	
  CCDs	
  
Can	
  improve	
  DE	
  FoM	
  by	
  3-­‐6,making	
  it	
  a	
  DETF	
  Stage	
  IV	
  experiment	
  
	
  
Spanish	
  Groups	
  of	
  DES	
  very	
  ac.vely	
  involved:	
  Electronics,	
  	
  Science	
  
	
  
Strong	
  Points	
  of	
  DESpec:	
  
       High	
  Performance,	
  low	
  cost,	
  low	
  risk	
  	
  
           CTIO	
  site	
  
           Uses	
  DECam	
  components	
  and	
  other	
  heritages	
  
       Synergy	
  in	
  Southern	
  hemisphere	
  
            DES,	
  LSST	
  quality	
  targets	
  	
  
            3d	
  map	
  pf	
  sothern	
  hemisphere	
  near	
  start	
  of	
  LSST	
  survey	
  
            Gemini,	
  ESO/VLT,	
  LCO…	
  Followup	
  
            SPT,	
  ACT,	
  SKA:	
  CMB	
  lensing/correla-on	
  
       Strong	
  Team	
  (DES	
  collabora.on	
  and	
  others)	
  
	
  
Massive	
  Spectroscopic	
  Survey	
  	
  in	
  the	
  Southern	
  
                                    Hemisphere	
  

• 8-­‐million	
  Galaxy	
  RedshiX	
  Survey	
  in	
  350	
  nights	
  
   – Uniformly	
  selected	
  from	
  deep,	
  homogeneous	
  DES	
  imaging	
  over	
  
       5000	
  sq.	
  deg.	
  (2018+)	
  
• 23-­‐million	
  Galaxy	
  RedshiX	
  Survey	
  in	
  1000	
  nights	
  
   – Uniformly	
  selected	
  from	
  deep,	
  homogeneous	
  LSST	
  imaging	
  over	
  
       15,000	
  sq.	
  deg.	
  (2021+)	
  
• Deep,	
  uniform	
  mul-band	
  imaging	
  from	
  DES,	
  LSST	
  
   – Enable	
  efficient,	
  well-­‐understood	
  selec-on	
  of	
  spectroscopic	
  
       targets	
  
• Photometric+Spectroscopic	
  Surveys	
  over	
  same	
  Sky	
  
   – Enable	
  powerful	
  new	
  science	
  beyond	
  what	
  either	
  can	
  provide	
  
       alone	
  
• DESpec	
  White	
  Paper	
  released	
  Sept.	
  11	
  
   – arXiv:	
  1209.2451	
  (Abdalla,	
  etal)	
  
Massive	
  Spectroscopy	
  of	
  DES	
  and	
  LSST	
  Targets	
  
                            Enables	
  New	
  and	
  Improved	
  DE	
  Probes	
  
Weak	
  Lensing	
  and	
  Redshic-­‐Space	
  Distor.ons:	
  Powerful	
  
test	
  of	
  Dark	
  Energy	
  vs	
  Modified	
  Gravity	
  
Galaxy	
  Clustering:	
  Radial	
  BAO	
  for	
  H(z)	
  and	
  improved	
  DA(z)	
  
Photometric	
  Redshic	
  Calibra.on:	
  Determine	
  DES	
  and	
  LSST	
  N(z)	
  
from	
  angular	
  correla-on	
                                              Gaztañaga	
  et	
  al.,	
  
                                                                             2011	
  
Galaxy	
  clusters	
  
Dynamical	
  masses	
  from	
  velocity	
  
dispersions,	
  improve	
  halo	
  mass-­‐
observable	
  calibra-on,	
  reduce	
  the	
  
major	
  cluster	
  DE	
  systema-c	
  
Weak	
  Lensing	
  
Reduce	
  systema-cs	
  from	
  intrinsic	
  
alignments	
  
Supernovae	
  
Reduce	
  systema-cs	
  from	
  host-­‐galaxy	
  
typing	
  
PAU@WHT:	
  Physics	
  of	
  the	
  
                       Accelera.ng	
  Universe	
  
• New camera for WHT with 18 2k
x 4k CCDs covering 1 deg ∅ FoV.
• 42 100Å-wide filters covering
4300-8600 Å in 6 movable filter
trays, which also include standard
ugrizY filters.
• As a survey camera, it can cover
~2 deg2 per night in all filters.
• It can provide low-resolution
spectra (Δλ/λ ~ 2%, or R ~ 50) for
>30000 galaxies, 5000 stars,
1000 quasars, 10 galaxy clusters,
per night.
• Expected galaxy redshift
resolution σ(z) ~ 0.003×(1+z)	
  
2.- PAU at the WHT
PI : E. Fernández (UAB/IFAE)

Co-Is: E. Sánchez (CIEMAT), E. Gaztañaga (IEEC/CSIC), R. Miquel (IFAE), J. García-Bellido (IFT/UAM), M. Delfino (PIC)

PAUCam PI: F. Castander                                   PAU	
  at	
  the	
  WHT	
  
Project Manager: C. Padilla; System Engineer: L. Cardiel, DAQ: J. de Vicente; Mechanics: F. Grañena; Control: O. Ballester;
Optics and integration: R. Casas, J. Jiménez.

PAUDm & Science PI: E. Gaztañaga
Simulations: F. Castander; Operation: N. Tonello; Data Reduction: S. Serrano; QA&Validation: I. Sevilla.

The Survey Team:
V. Acín5, D. Alonso4, J. Asorey2, O. Ballester3, A. Bauer2, C. Bonnett2, A. Bueno4, L. Cardiel3, J. Carretero2,
R. Casas2, M. Caubet5, F. Castander2, J. Castilla1, M. Crocce2, M. Delfino5, J.F. de Vicente1, M. Eriksen2, S. Farrens2,
E. Fernández3, J. Flix5, P. Fosalba2, J. García-Bellido4, E. Gaztañaga2, F. Grañena3, A. Izard2, J. Jiménez2, S. Jouvel2, S.
Heinis3, C. Hernández3, K. Hoffman2, C. López2, L. C. López3, F. Madrid2, P. Martí3, G. Martínez1, R. Miquel3, C.
Neissner5, S. Nesseris4, A. Pacheco5, C. Padilla3, C. Pio3, E. Planas5, A. Pujol2, F. J. Rodríguez1, J. Rubio4, E. Sánchez1,
C. Sánchez3, F. J. Sánchez1, D. Sapone4, S. Serrano2, I. Sevilla1, P. Tallada5, N. Tonello5.

             1                                                                                             2

              3                                           4                                                5

                                                    Status	
  –	
  Noviembre	
  2012	
  
PAUCam:	
  The	
  Pau	
  Camera	
  
                                                     Main	
  Characteris.cs	
  
                                                     	
  
                                                     Large	
  Field	
  of	
  View	
  (1	
  degree)	
  
                                                     Narrow+broad	
  band	
  filters	
  
                                                     Good	
  spectral	
  sensi-vity	
  
                                                     Segmented	
  filter	
  trays	
  

The	
  aim	
  is	
  to	
  have	
  a	
  working	
  
instrument	
  ready	
  by	
  the	
  end	
  of	
  
the	
  year	
  2012.	
  
Taken from Cenarro’s Talk at RIA-Valencia
Taken from Cenarro’s Talk at RIA-Valencia
Taken from Benitez’s Talk at RIA-Valencia
LSS	
  in	
  LSST	
  

   Licia	
  Verde	
  
 ICREA	
  &	
  ICC-­‐UB	
  
LSST	
  in	
  numbers	
  
• Effec-ve	
  etendue	
  319	
  m2deg2	
  
• FoV	
  9.9	
  deg2	
  
• Effec-ve	
  aperture	
  6.7m	
  
• Wavelength	
  coverage	
  320-­‐1080	
  nm,	
  filters	
  u	
  g	
  r	
  I	
  z	
  y	
  
• Sky	
  coverage	
  20,000	
  sq	
  deg	
  
• Single	
  visit	
  depth	
  r	
  ~	
  24.5	
  (5	
  σ	
  point	
  source)	
  
• Seeing	
  0.7	
  arcsec	
  in	
  r	
  
• Each	
  patch	
  of	
  the	
  sky	
  observed	
  2000	
  -mes	
  (15s-­‐days)	
  
  1000	
  visits	
  
• Photometric	
  repeatability	
  	
  5-­‐10	
  millimags	
  
• Astrometric	
  precision	
  	
  beZer	
  than	
  10	
  mas	
  (rsm)	
  per	
  visit	
  per	
  coord	
  
    	
  see	
  e.g.,	
  	
  
    LSST	
  science	
  book	
  at	
  hZp://arxiv.org/abs/0912.0201	
  or	
  	
  hZp://www.lsst.org/lsst/scibook	
  	
  	
  

    Licia	
  Verde	
                                                                                    LSS	
  in	
  LSST	
  
Dark	
  energy:	
  theore.cal	
  aspects	
  

• A	
  cosmological	
  constant	
  is	
  a	
  good	
  phenomenological	
  
  descrip-on	
  for	
  cosmic	
  accelera-on,	
  but	
  ….	
  	
  
• Naturalness	
  problem:	
  

	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       	
  natural	
  par-cle	
  physics	
  contribu-ons	
  	
  

• Coincidence	
  problem:	
  	
  

                                                                                                                                	
  if	
  there	
  is	
  no	
  connec-on	
  between	
  Λ	
  and	
  maZer?	
  	
  

• Is	
  there	
  a	
  more	
  fundamental	
  theory	
  for	
  cosmic	
  accelera-on?	
  	
  
Dark	
  energy:	
  theore.cal	
  aspects	
  
                                                                                                                      Alterna-ve	
  theories	
  to	
  ΛCDM	
  

                         Gµν	
  +	
  GµνMG = 8πG (Tµν +Tµν DE)	
  
                                           	
  Modified	
  gravity	
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               	
  Dark	
  energy	
  

• Modified	
  gravity:	
  f(R),	
  brane-­‐worlds,	
  holographic,	
  Pala-ni,	
  …	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  
	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  U	
  	
  AB,	
  
                                                                                                                                                                                                             	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  I	
  CE,	
  
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  I	
  EEC,	
  
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  U	
  	
  CM,	
  
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  U	
  	
  	
  V-­‐IFIC,	
  
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
   UAM-­‐IFT,	
  IFF	
  

• Dark	
  energy:	
  scalar,	
  vector,	
  DBI,	
  galileons,	
  coupled	
  DE-­‐DM,	
  
  disformal	
  …	
  	
                                         	
  UCM,UAM-­‐IFT,UPV	
  

• Inhomogeneous	
  models	
  in	
  GR	
  without	
  Λ:	
  Lemaître-­‐Tolman-­‐
  Bondi	
  	
                                                        	
  UAM-­‐IFT	
  
Dark	
  Mafer	
  &	
  Dark	
  Energy:	
  Simula.ons	
  
                                                            www.multidark.org

  BigMul-Dark	
  suite	
  of	
  
cosmological	
  simula-ons	
  

Large-volume high-res cosmological simulations are
needed. This is a Gran Challenge Project which needs
access to large supercomputers – PRACE in EU – and
databases – VO – to host the simulations products (mock
galaxy catalogues, etc).
SPANISH	
  PARTICIPATION:	
  F.	
  CASTANDER	
  &	
  R.	
  REBOLO	
  
Remark
                   Cosmology is a very active and dynamic field in Spain
                      (considering the relatively small community)
                                BUT, “No podemos estar en todo!”
                                               ANSWER

Massive large-area surveys have been at the forefront of
the tremendous progress that has taken place in
cosmology over the last decade. The success of the
SDSS, which with a modest budget has been one of the
world's largest impact observatories in the last decade
clearly demonstrates the importance for the scientific
community of continuing survey development and
implementation. One of the crucial characteristics of the
scientific impact of these surveys is that their
applicability is extremely broad, the discoveries they
lead to are of key importance, while the nature of these
discoveries is often unexpected at the time when the
surveys are planned.

                                                            Madrid & Macchetto 2009, arXiv:0901.4552
Thanks	
  to:	
  
        Juan Garcia-Bellido (IF- UAM/CSIC),
Licia Verde (ICC-UB), Pilar Ruiz-Lapuente (ICC-UB),
      Rafael Rebolo & J.A. Rubiño-Martin (IAC)
  Enrique Martinez (IFCA), Gustavo Yepes (UAM),
     Antonio Maroto (UCM) and many others …
To be continued …
You can also read