Distribution System Synchronized Measurement Technology Deployment - Industry Roadmap Development - Project team
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Project team
▪ SDG&E
Distribution System Synchronized ▪ ORNL
Measurement Technology Deployment ▪ Quanta Technology
– Industry Roadmap Development
Trademarks are property of their respective owners. All rights reserved. Slide 1
Overall Project Objectives and Approach
▪ Provide high-level guidance for development Roadmap for and Benefits of Deploying Sensor Technology
and investment synchronized measurement for Distribution Network Modernization
technology on distribution circuits, while ▪ Identify and summarize major business drivers and needs.
looking at technical requirements and
▪ Industry outreach, including NASPI.
challenges vs. industry and customer needs.
▪ Revise and update use cases and link them to key business
▪ The roadmap shows the activities required for drivers and needs.
successfully deploying synchronized ▪ Identify system and product requirements and costs.
measurement technology and critical ▪ Develop example budgetary cost estimates for typical
applications on the distribution systems of deployment scenarios .
SDG&E and of other utilities in other regions
▪ Develop example roadmaps to help utilities accelerate the
with different needs. process - Applications, Infrastructure, and Processes.
▪ Helps DOE develop programs that can help the
industry accelerate the grid modernization Pilot programs
process by incorporating synchronized ▪ Identify pilot programs for selected applications.
measurements and systems.
▪ Develop benefit-cost analysis for those pilots.
Trademarks are property of their respective owners. All rights reserved. Slide 2Project Tasks
This is where we are
(NASPI meeting)
Task 1
SDG&E application
list
Task 2 Task 4 Task 5 Task 6 Task 7
Interviews with Task 3
SDG&E
Identification of Detailed Industry Feedback
Interviews with Identify Pilot
applications (App) assessment and (NASPI Distribution Industry Roadmap Final Report
Prioritization ComEd, ConEd and Reprioritization of Programs
and application identification of Task Team)
Literature review Dominion AppGs
groups (AppG) high-priority App
(industry reports, and AppG
papers, articles,
etc.)
Quanta Technology
Subject Matter
Expertise Task 2 Report Task 3 Report
Task 1 Report
Trademarks are property of their respective owners. All rights reserved. Slide 3Proposed Use Case and Application Grouping (1)
Trademarks are property of their respective owners. All rights reserved. Slide 4Proposed Use Case and Application Grouping (2)
Trademarks are property of their respective owners. All rights reserved. Slide 5Proposed Use Case and Application Grouping (3)
Trademarks are property of their respective owners. All rights reserved. Slide 6Prioritization: Benefit – Cost Ratio Calculation
• Relative potential to improve Resiliency &
resiliency and reliability Reliability
• Relative potential to help achieve
Sustainability &
sustainability and/or
decarbonization
decarbonization objectives
Complexity • Relative complexity of implementing program
• Relative potential to help improve
real-time system operation, Real-time
awareness, visualization and operation
control • Relative investment level (CAPEX & OPEX)
Investment
required for implementing program
• Relative potential to enable Advanced
advanced system planning planning
Benefit Cost • Relative risk and impacts of unsuccessful
Risk
Summary Summary program implementation
• Relative potential to improve
Public safety
public safety
• Relative maturity of the concept and
Maturity technology required for implementing
program
• Relative potential to improve Efficiency
overall system efficiency improvement Benefit/Cost • Utility's familiarity with required concepts
Ratio and technologies, and organizational
Readiness
• Relative potential to enable readiness to implement and integrate
adoption of leading industry program in existing processes and activities
Innovation
practices, position utility as an
potential
innovator and/or produce
intellectual property
• Relative potential to help become
Customer
and/or remain a trusted advisor &
engagement &
to create new services and business potential
products
Trademarks are property of their respective owners. All rights reserved. Slide 7Preliminary Prioritization Results
Prioritization results were used along with potential interdependencies among AGs to develop a
proposed timeframe for implementation and overall roadmap
TIMEFRAME FOR IMPLE
APPLICATION BENEFIT-COST BENEFIT-COST
APPLICATION DESCRIPTION PRIORITY NUMBER
NUMBER RATIO RATIO NUMERICAL Yr. 1 Yr. 2 Yr. 3 Y
A11 High-accuracy fault detection and location 1.47 1 X X
A2 Advanced monitoring of distribution grid 1.41 2 X X X
A6 Real-time distribution system operation 1.34 3 X X X
A8 Advanced distribution system planning 1.32 4 X X
A5 DER integration 1.29 5 X X X
A9 Distribution load, DER and EV forecasting 1.21 6 X X X
A4 Wide area visualization 1.21 7 X X
A17 Monitoring and control of electric transportation infrastructure 1.20 8 X X X
A3 Asset management of critical infrastructure 1.17 9 X X X
A7 Enhanced reliability and resilience analysis 1.15 10 X X X
A12 Advanced distribution protection and control 1.14 11 X X X
A14 Improved load shedding schemes 1.13 12 X X
A15 Advanced distribution automation 1.12 13 X X X
A18 Integrated resource, transmission and distribution system planning and analysis 1.11 14 X X X
A13 Advanced microgrid applications and operation 1.08 15 X X X
A10 Improved stability management 1.00 16 X X X
A19 Power quality measurement 0.94 17 X X
A1 Advanced Volt-VAR Control (VVC) 0.91 18 X X X
A16 Technical and commercial loss reduction 0.87 19 X X X
Trademarks are property of their respective owners. All rights reserved. Slide 8Prioritization Results – Application Benefit
9.0
8.03 7.97
8.0 7.79
7.54 7.49
7.18 7.08
6.91
7.0 6.71 6.68
6.44
6.21 6.21 6.17
5.98 5.96
6.0
5.0 4.75
4.44
4.27
4.0
3.0
2.0
1.0
0.0
Real-time DER integration Advanced High-accuracy Advanced Advanced Wide area Advanced Asset Distribution Monitoring and Enhanced Improved Integrated Advanced Improved load Power quality Advanced Volt- Technical and
distribution monitoring of fault detection distribution distribution visualization microgrid management of load, DER and control of reliability and stability resource, distribution shedding measurement VAR Control commercial loss
system distribution grid and location protection and automation applications and critical EV forecasting electric resilience management transmission system planning schemes (VVC) reduction
operation control operation infrastructure transportation analysis and distribution
infrastructure system planning
and analysis
Trademarks are property of their respective owners. All rights reserved. Slide 9Prioritization Results – Application Benefit-Cost Ratio
9
8 6 5
High accuracy fault
2
detection and location
(highest priority AG) 11 12
15
4
7
13
BENEFIT
9 3
17
7 18 10
6 8 14
5
19
Technical and commercial
1
loss reduction (lowest
16
priority AG)
4
4 5 6 7
COST
Trademarks are property of their respective owners. All rights reserved. Slide 10Application Requirements
Minimum
Proposed Minimum Maximum
Application Group Report Rate
Group Number Availability % Latency (ms)
(Hz)
AG1 AVVC 80 2000 1
AG2 Advanced monitoring of distribution grid 95 1000 30
AG3 Asset management of critical infrastructure 80 5000 1
AG4 Wide area monitoring and visualization 95 1000 30
AG5 DER integration 80 2000 1
AG6 Real-time distribution system operation 95 2000 1
AG7 Enhanced reliability and resilience analysis 80 5000 1
AG8 Advanced distribution system planning 95 5000 30
AG9 Distribution load, DER, and EV forecasting 80 5000 1
AG10 Improved stability management 99 500 30
AG11 High-accuracy fault detection and location 99.9 300 30
AG12 Advanced distribution protection and control 99.9 150 30
AG13 Advanced microgrid applications and operation 99 500 30
AG14 Improved load shedding schemes 80 5000 1
AG15 Advanced distribution automation 99 300 30
AG16 Technical and commercial loss reduction 70 5000 1
AG17 Monitoring and control of electric transportation infrastructure 80 5000 1
AG18 Integrated resource, transmission and distribution system planning and analysis 80 5000 1
AG19 PQ assessment and analysis 99.9 5000 120
Trademarks are property of their respective owners. All rights reserved. Slide 11You can also read
