OVERVIEW OF THE IMPACT ON SPANISH POWER SECTOR - COVID-19 - PWC

Page created by Roberta Holland
 
CONTINUE READING
OVERVIEW OF THE IMPACT ON SPANISH POWER SECTOR - COVID-19 - PWC
COVID-19
Overview of the impact on
Spanish power sector
OVERVIEW OF THE IMPACT ON SPANISH POWER SECTOR - COVID-19 - PWC
Index

 1.       Context
 2.       Global impact of COVID-19
 3.       Implications for the power sector
 4.       Appendices

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector   April 2020
                                                          2
Context
Our base case scenario considers a -10% 2020 GDP evolution in Spain

                                        Epidemic outbreaks with a similar profile to COVID-19 have caused serious economic disruptions in the past
                                         although in this case a greater impact is expected than in other occasions
     COVID-19
                                             In 2003 SARS infected over 8000 people, while COVID has already affected more than 1 million
    outbreak vs
                                             In China the outbreak was located in a region that represents less than 10% of the population. However
    other similar
                                               the disease has caused a decrease in the industrial production and in the retail activity of 14% and 21%
       crisis                                  respectively in the whole country during Q1.
                                             Major stock markets have decreased by 30% 2020 YTD

                                       Latest economic consensus show GDP growth being hit hard: world GDP could contract by almost 4%, with
                                        European economies falling around 7-11%, depending on the country. The impact will be harder on economies
                                        either highly dependent on external demand, or with high GDP weight of labor-intensive sectors, like is the
     Impact of
                                        case of Spain
    COVID-19 on
                                       We expect a reduction of the Spanish 2020 GDP in the range of 5%-15% depending on the duration of the
    the Spanish
                                        lockdown (-10% in our base case scenario). The base case considers that:
      economy                               Infections peak in late April, and the quarantine is lifted at the end of May
                                            The activity begins to go up in August, partially damaged summer season
                                            Our recovery will be slower than the one observed in China

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                                                            April 2020
                                                                                                                                                                   4
The impact of COVID-19 for the power industry is in the lower-middle
range compared to other activities

       Effect of
                                        In Spain, several large industrial players have announced the temporary closing of their manufacturing plants
     COVID-19 in
                                         while almost all commercial activity has ceased; the impact can already been observed in the 10%-20%
      the power
                                         week-on-week electricity demand drop after the Government declared the state of alarm
     demand and
                                        The combined effects of lower commodity prices and a falling demand is putting a lot of pressure on pool
     pool prices                         prices. The effect has also been exported to the futures market, with the 2021-annual base load product
     during 2020                         currently trading below 40€/MWh from the 45€/MWh levels four weeks ago

                                        The reduction of pool prices and demand also put pressure on power deficit generation. Our initial analysis
                                         suggests that the additional 2020 deficit can be almost managed with the historical surplus of the system.
                                            We expect that the tariff deficit in 2020 will be in the range of €700m-€1000m depending on the
     Impact of                                  duration of the crisis and the policies of the government. Considering that during 2019, €200m-€300m
    COVID-19 on                                 of additional deficit has been generated, it means a total of c.€900m-€1300m for the 2018-20 period;
    tariff deficit                              this amount could be almost managed with existing surplus (c.€1000m).
                                        However there are uncertainties that can significantly worsen the final outcome: (i) higher decrease in TPAs
                                         due to a longer duration of the crisis, and (ii) an increase in bad debt from final consumers that we have not
                                         quantified in our estimation.

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                                                            April 2020
                                                                                                                                                                   5
The paralysis of the administration, and the difficulties in the supply
will also impact the power industry

      Delays of public
                                                    Other negative consequence for the power sector is the paralysis of the public administrations. There are relevant regulatory
     administrations will
                                                     reforms pending approval, and a delay will significantly affect different stakeholders. Some of these include: CHPs allegations on
       affect different
                                                     new parameters update, CCGTs expectation around a new capacity mechanism, new status for energy intensive users etc.
        stakeholders

                                                    Our view is that renewables will continue growing in the Spanish market during 2020 due to the strong fundamentals of the sector
                                                     and its high competitiveness.
                                                    However, the delays in administrative processes and the paralysis of the construction activity will make it difficult for some new
                                                     renewable facilities to achieve COD this year.
      Specific issues for                           In terms of supply, the main issue is the low availability of solar panels due to the lack of activity in China. However we expect that
         renewables                                  the situation will return to normal in Q3-Q4. We also expect difficulties in the supply chain of wind manufacturers, but with a more
                                                     limited outcome.
                                                    For operating renewable projects the difference between the current pool prices and the estimations used by the government to
                                                     update 2020-23 parameters can also put pressure in the working capital of companies, especially those with assets that still have a
                                                     high remuneration for the investment.

                                                    Commercial companies will suffer the rise of the bad debt. Independent retailers with high exposure to the SME and industrial
                                                     segments are the ones most affected.
      Specific issues for
                                                        Large clients have suspended contracts due to the crisis, even if they have fixed volumes committed
          retailers
                                                        The government has ruled forcing utilities to maintain the service during the state of alarm even if the domestic clients do
                                                          not pay their bills

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                                                                                        April 2020
                                                                                                                                                                                               6
Other impacts of COVID-19 include limitations for foreign investors for
M&A, and tougher financing

                                   Foreign direct investments of 10% or more require an administrative authorization in the power
  Administrative
                                    sector
   authorization
                                         The lack of authorization or performing the investment prior to its obtention is considered a
  for M&A in the
                                            serious infraction (with fines that may be as high as the economic content of the transaction
   power sector                             and not less than €30,000 and private or public warnings).

      Financing                         COVID-19’s effects on the financing terms result in an increase in the spreads and the guarantees
     environment                            We are observing some delays in the financial closing, especially for those projects with a
                                              high exposure to merchant.
    for greenfield                          Off-takers are pushing sponsors to obtain lower prices in the PPAs (from 36€/MWh-38
      renewable                               €/MWh to €30 MWh)
        assets                              Lenders are demanding higher guarantees and larger spreads for the debt

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                                               April 2020
                                                                                                                                                      7
Global impact of
COVID-19
Epidemic outbreaks with a similar profile to COVID-19 have caused
serious economic disruptions in the past...

  Major epidemic outbreaks

                                                          Wide-ranging, but
  Severe, but limited in scope                               "harmless"       Wide-ranging and relatively severe
Ebola (2014)                         MERS (2014-15)        N1H1 (2009)        SARS (2003)                Covid-19 (2020)
Number of cases in Europe, the Americas and APAC
...although in this case a greater impact is expected than on other
occasions

  COVID-19 impact on the global economy [Major stock markets YTD performance, Jan-March 2020]

                                     Asia-Pacific                                            USA and Europe

                                                    -10%

                                                             -19%
                                         -23%
                                                                       -25%
                       -29%                                                       -29%
    -30%                                                                                                      -31%
                                                                                           -33%     -32%
                                                                                                                       (1) Measures the evolution of a set of
   Japan               Korea            Taiwan    Shanghai Hong Kong Straits      US S&P   German   France     UK      high-risk bonds
 Nikkei 225            KOSP            Weighted   composite Hang Seng Times of     500     DAX30    CAC40    FTSE100   Source: Bloomberg, NBSC
                                        Index       index     Index   Singapore

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                                                          April 2020
                                                                                                                                                                10
The economic consensus is a general slowdown, with an expected
decreased of 9 p.p. for Spain

  Main forecasts of GDP evolution by region - pre- and post-COVID-19

                                                                                    -8pp                     -9pp
                           -7pp                            -6pp
                5.0%

                                                                                                    1.8%
                                                  1.1%
                                                                           0.5%

                                    -2.0%

                                                                  -5.0%
                                                                                                                    -7.0%
                                                                                           -8.0%
                Pre-                 Post-         Pre-        Post-        Pre-        Post-        Pre-        Post-
              COVID19               COVID19      COVID19      COVID19     COVID19      COVID19     COVID19      COVID19     Source: consensus of estimates from different
                                                                                                                            analysts (Goldman Sachs, Deustche Bank,
                                                                                                                            Oxford Economics, y otras), between 15 and 18
                      China                            USA                     Europe                   Spain
                                                                                                                            March

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                                                                   April 2020
                                                                                                                                                                         11
PwC base case is aligned with market consensus, with a central case that
considers a -10% GDP growth in 2020

    Scenarios of impact on GDP – General considerations

                               “Optimistic”                       Base case                           Crash-case
GDP decrease
[vs 2019]                                        -4%                          -10%                                -15%
1 Duration of      Peak of infections in mid-April,               Peak of infections in late April,   Peak of infections in mid-May,
    the quarantine quarantine is lifted in early May              quarantine is lifted in late May    quarantine lifted in mid-late
                                                                                                      June

    Impact                                                                                                                               Note: the impacts on GDP have been calculated with the
2                                            30-35%                          45-50%                              45-50%                  following methodology. For each sector, its monthly weight
    during the                                                                                                                           within GDP has been estimated based on (a) the sectorial
    worst month                                                                                                                          value added data provided by the INE and (b) monthly
                              We assume a "softer" impact,        We assume a more serious            We assume a more serious           activity indicators provided by the INE and other
                              aligned with the data from China,   impact than in China, according     impact than in China, according    organizations. For each month, starting in April, a series of
                                                                                                                                         "peak" activity reductions have been applied to each of the
                              adjusted to the Spanish             to "early indicators" for Europe    to "early indicators" for Europe   sectors, for each month that there is quarantine. For March
                              economic reality                    and America by sector               and America by sector              we have estimated that the impact will be approximately 50-
                                                                                                                                         70% of the April fall. After the quarantine period, each sector
                                                                                                                                         recovers following a series of "type" curves, according to
                                                                                                                                         their activity profile, socioeconomic characteristics, and
3 Recovery                    The activity begins to go up in     The activity begins to go up in     Activity begins to pick up in      dependence on domestic and foreign demand. Activity

    profiles                  June, although it does not          August, partially damaged           September, but does not            recovers progressively, following these curves, until it
                                                                                                                                         reaches a run-rate growth rate, estimated as the median
                              "recover" until July-August         summer season                       normalize until 2021               monthly growth for the last five years.

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                                                                                                  April 2020
                                                                                                                                                                                                        12
Implications for the
power sector
The impact of COVID-19 for the power sector is in the lower-middle
range...
                                                                                                                                S&P500 Capitalization
  Impact of the COVID-19 on the main sectors of activity                                                                        Erosion (last month)

     Major supply                                  High
                                                                                                                              Sharp drop in demand
     constraints                                                                                  Industry
                                                                                                                             (90% drop in car sales in
   (imports of APIs                                                                               & automobile                China since Lunar New
     and finished
                                                                                                              Retail           Year) and significant
                               Supply limitation

        drugs)
                                                                                                                                supply constraints
                                                                     Healthcare & Pharma                                      (APAC's TIER1 supply)
                                                   Medium

                                                                                           Power &
                                                                 Retail                    utilities
 Impact on sales,                                                           Telco &
                                                   Low or none

derived from lower
                                                                 (food)                                                TTL
                                                                             media                                            Strong restrictions on
    volumes of                                                                          Financial services                     demand (travel bans,
economic activity                                                                                                             restrictions on transport
                                                                     Real
    in general                                                                                                                  from certain areas)
                                                                     Estate
                                                                   Low or none        Medium                 High
                                                                            Slowdown in demand/income

                                                                  Unfavorable market conditions can magnify cash flow stress or excess debt

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                                                            April 2020
                                                                                                                                                                  14
...with the retail and tourism sectors being the most affected ones in
China
  Main activity indicators by sector in China                              - impact after 55 days of quarantine

                      Severely impacted sectors                                                      Moderately impacted sectors

                                           Real estate & Industry &                Telco &           Healthcare        Power &           Financial
      TTL                  Retail          construction automobile                  media            & Pharma          utilities         services
Main activity indicators - growth compared to February 2019
   Traffic of               Retail               Real estate     Industrial                           Pharmaceutical     Electricity        Loans in
 passengers(2)             sales(3)(5)            sales(3)     production(3)     Internet users(1)     production(3)    production(3)      renminbi(3)

    -80%                    -30%                  -35%            -16%              +0.3%                -12%             -10%               -2%
                                                 Completed
     Hotel              Sales of online          residential      Sales of         New phone                               Coal             Shanghai
  occupancy(3)            channel(3)              works(3)     automobiles(3)       users(1)           Drug sales(4)   consumption(2)   interbank rate(2)

    -90%                     +3%                  -23%            -66%               -60%                -0.2%            -24%              -20%

"Forward" activity indicators ("deferred" impact to subsequent months)
                            PMI             Residential                                                                                 Super-short term
       n.a             Non-industrial(2) projects started(3) PMI industrial(2)         n.a                 n.a              n.a           factoring(2)
                                                                                                                                                            (1) Data for January (2) Data for
                            -46%                  -45%            -27%                                                                    +590%             February (3) Data for January and
                                                                                                                                                            February; (4) Includes traditional and
                                                                                                                                                            western medicine (5) Excludes
                                                                                                                                                            automotive, food and pharmaceuticals
Sector weight in China's GDP                                                                                                                                Sources: National Bureau of Statistics,
                                                                                                                                                            Transportation Ministry of China, WIND,
             6%                   10%                  14%             28%                   6%                  7%               4%               8%       China Telecom Corporation Ltd.

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                                                                                              April 2020
                                                                                                                                                                                                    15
COVID-19’s effects on the Spanish power sector are a demand shock of
and falling pool prices…
  Main energy and power variables impacted by COVID-19

  Power demand                                             Commodity prices
  •     The strict measures taken by multiple              •   Gas prices in Europe were already at record low
        countries across Europe to restrain the virus          levels prior to the COVID-19 crisis, limiting the
        spread, including lockdowns, is having a large         downside risk
        impact on the overall electricity demand           •   Carbon allowances prices in Europe (ETS)
        across the continent                                   suffered a price crash following the COVID-19
  •     In Spain, several large industrial players have        crisis, falling to c.15€/ton from 23€/ton levels at the
        announced the temporary closure of their               beginning of March
        manufacturing plants while almost all the
        commercial activity has ceased; the impact can
        already be observed in the 10%-20% week-on-
        week electricity demand drop after the
        Government declared the state of alarm.            Pool prices
                                                           •  The combined effects of lower commodity prices
  •     The fall of electricity demand is also affecting      and a falling demand is putting a lot of pressure on
        the demand / supply balance of other                  pool prices
        commodities, such as natural gas and carbon        •  The effect has also been exported to the futures
        allowances, since CCGTs and other fuel-fired          market, with the 2021-annual BL product currently
        plants are experiencing lower utilization rates       trading below 40 €/MWh from the 45€/MWh levels
                                                              four weeks ago

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                           April 2020
                                                                                                                                 16
…under this scenario, public administrations have limited margin to
implement new actions
  COVID-19 impact on delaying regulatory measures highly demanded in the power sector

Update of the new                                Regulation for energy         Capacity payments                Structure of TPAs
parameters for the 2020-23                       intensive industries                                           •   In this context,
•   CHPs have been largely                       •   The ministry had the      •   The ministry expected            modifications to
    affected by the update                           objective of approving        to start the definition of       promote self
    of the parameters for                            a new regulatory              a new capacity                   consumption through
    the period 2020-23. In                           framework for energy          mechanism coherent               an increase in the
    this context, the claims                         intensive industries in       with the EU legislation.         variable terms seems
    and allegations from the                         Spain.                    •   This action was key for          more difficult due to
    sector will be delayed                       •   The delay in the              the sustainability of the        the impact that this    1) Includes other law 15/2012 taxes; 2)
                                                                                                                                            Includes other TPA tolls (self-supply,
    threatening the                                  approval of a new             CCGTs in Spain,                  measure would have      generation…), capacity revenues…; 3)
    economic sustainability                          mechanisms will               especially in a context          on revenues of the      Includes pre-2013 deficit repayment,
    of many facilities.                              impact a sector highly        of low demand                    system                  capacity payments…; Source: CNMC;
                                                                                                                                            Strategy& analysis
•   CHPs will also suffer                            affected by the
    from the downturn of                             economic downturn
    the industrial activity                          and the restrictions
                                                     decided by the
                                                     government

    The limitation of 10% in investments for foreign investors could reduce M&A activity and the normal operation of the capital markets
                                           in a sector that requires large amounts of investments

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                                                                               April 2020
                                                                                                                                                                                     17
For the renewables segment, ready-to-build or under construction
projects could suffer delays

  COVID-19 impact on the RE industry

Delays for RE projects                           Downward pressure on          Pressure on the working      More uncertainty around
that planned to reach                            PPA prices following          capital of regulated         the potential launch of
COD in 2020                                      pool prices’ decrease         brownfield RE assets         new RE auctions
•   All administrative                           •  The price signal           •   The 2020-2022            •   The Spanish gov’t
    procedures are                                  provided by both pool          remuneration                 announced in February
    expected to suffer                              and futures prices             parameters were              that it planned to hold
    delays, slowing down                            heavily impact on the          calculated using             annual 3-4GW
    the development                                 PPA industry                   “overestimated” pool         renewable auctions
    (permitting) process of                      •  Off-takers use these           prices (c.50-55 €/MWh        from 2021 onwards
    new RE assets                                   price signals to               compared to the          •   However, without the
•   Additionally, RE assets                         calculate the implicit         current c.35€/MWh)           approval of the Climate
    could also suffer                               PPA savings, and           •   These differences will       Change Law it is not
    delays during                                   therefore, in a low pool       be compensated in            possible to call new
    construction                                    price context, they put        2023, but put pressure       auctions, leading to
    (components’ logistic                           downward pressure on           on the assets’ current       potential delays from
    or supply issues)                               the PPA price                  working capital              the original calendar

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                                            April 2020
                                                                                                                                                  18
An increase in bad debt is the main challenge for power retailers

  Actions of the government in the power sector with impact on retailer companies

                                   Expand the scope of the social bonus to employed workers who have lost their employment and self-employed who have ceased their
                                    activity as a result of the coronavirus. For Consumers under social bonus the suspension of supply in the event of non-payment of the
       Domestic                     electricity bill is prohibited.
        clients                    It is prohibited to suspend the supply of electricity to domestic consumers in their habitual household due to non-payment of the
                                    receipt, while the state of alarm in which we find ourselves is in force

                                    Companies they may benefit from the following two easing measures:
                                          • They may temporarily suspend or modify their supply contracts, or extensions of such contracts, to contract another alternative
                                            offer with the marketer that supplies them, in order to adapt their contracts to their new consumption guidelines, without any charge
       SMEs and                             or penalty. It has a large impact in the case of clients with take or pay clauses with committed volumes
       industrial                         • They may modify their contracted power or the access toll, although these conditions would have changed in a period less than the
         clients                            previous twelve months.
                                    As soon as the state of alarm ends, these amounts owed by consumers to the marketers will be regularized in equal parts in the invoices that
                                     are issued during the period of the following six months, prohibiting the change of retailer
                                    As an aid to retailers whose income is reduced as a result of the application of these measures, they will be allowed to request the
                                     guarantees for financing defined in Royal Decree-Law 8/2020.

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                                                                             April 2020
                                                                                                                                                                                   19
Foreign direct investments of 10% or more require an administrative
authorization in the power sector
  Hot topics on energy transactions and COVID-19
                                                                          Impact on project development
   Royal Decree 8/2020, of March 19th, of the health crisis
   situation caused by COVID-19                                           • This suspension subordinates the
                                                                            performance of such investments to
   Suspension of the regime of liberalization of certain foreign direct     obtaining the corresponding administrative
   investments i.e. investments made by non EU investors or UK              authorization based on the provisions
   investors in certain sectors of with stakes of 10% or more or if it      contained in Law 19/2003.
   effectively participates in the investment´s managements.              • The lack of authorization or performing the
   1. Change of the legal regime of capital movements and                   investment prior to its obtention is
       economic transactions abroad which suspends the                      considered a serious infraction (with fines
       liberalization regime of foreign direct investments in Spain         that may be as high as the economic content
       made in sectors affecting public order, public safety and public     of the transaction and not less than €30,000
       health.                                                              and private or public warnings).
   2. This includes among others:                                         • This may negatively impact on the timing of
           • Critical infrastructures, whether physical or virtual          the transactions.
               (including energy), as well as land and real estate that
               are key to the use of such infrastructures;
           • Critical technologies and dual-use items including
               energy storage; and
           • Supply of essential inputs, in particular energy,
               understood as those that are regulated by Law 24/2013
               of 26 December on the electricity sector and Law
               34/1998 of 7 October on the hydrocarbons sector;

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                             April 2020
                                                                                                                                   20
COVID-19’s effects on the financing terms result in an increase in the
spreads and the guarantees
   Impact of the COVID19 on the Project Financing

  Market situation:
  •  It is mainly marked by the uncertainty and volatility of energy prices and financing conditions
  •  There is liquidity in the financial markets, since the Central Banks have injected more resources into the system, lowering the cost of money (partially offsetting the
     spread increase)
  •  The energy auction projects have been financed, so the efforts of the investment community are, primarily, focused on financing projects under PPA and merchant
     risk structures

                                   PPA Scheme                                                           Merchant

    In this environment of uncertainty, with the pool showing low         Projects with merchant risk are experiencing delays in obtaining
    values, there is a downward pressure in the PPA prices.               financing

    •   Before COVID 19, prices were in the range of 36€/MWh-             Some of the entities are waiting for the situation to be regularized
        40€/MWh depending on: the technology, duration of the             in order to participate in new projects
        contract, COD etc.
                                                                          The combination of:
    •   After COVID-19 we expect delays in new financial closings,                                                  Lower Merchant
        and it is still soon to have a view of what will be the price              Higher Spread
                                                                                                                        Prices
    Guarantees for financing are beginning to tighten, especially, if
    the Offtaker does not have an investment grade credit rating

    Additionally, spreads are increasing as a result of the Offtaker's
    exposure to credit risk and the volatility of the financial markets                                             Waiting to
                                                                                        Less gearing
                                                                                                                     Invest

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                                                                       April 2020
                                                                                                                                                                             21
Appendixes
Although figures are skewed, electricity demand in Spain has decreased
c.10% due to lockdown
  Spanish Peninsula electricity demand, 2020 – [MWh]
Weekly-basis                                                                     Weekend-basis

                                                                                                                                Avg.
                                     4,835                            Avg.                            1,247
    4,823                                                                                                               1,234   MWh
                                                              4,804   MWh
                                                                                             1,232
                                                                                   1,225
                     4,754                        -2.4%
                                                                                                              -4.6%
                                                                -9.5%
                                                  4,687                                                                   -7.7%
                                                                                                              1,177

                                                                4,346

                                                                                                                          1,139

      W8              W9              W10           W11          W12                 W8       W9      W10      W11         W12
  (17/2-23/2)      (24/2-1/3)       (2/3-8/3)    (9/3-15/3)   (16/3-22/3)          (22-23)   (29-1)   (7-8)   (14-15)     (21-22)

            First COVID-19 lockdown                                         Full
                            weekend                                         lockdown

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                                         April 2020
                                                                                                                                               23
The slowdown in power demand in Europe has made the CO2 allowance
price decrease by c.40%
  Daily CO2 allowance price, 2020 – [EUR/t CO2e]
26              25.6

25                                  24.5
                                                            24.0      23.9              23.7
24
      24.1
23                                                                                             22.8
                                                   23.3       23.3
22                                                                               22.6

21
                                                                                                       20.6
20
                            -40%
19

18

17                                                                                                             16.4
16

15                                                                                                                      14.5
14
            Week 8                            Week 9                Week 10              Week 11          Week 12          W13
          (17/2 – 21/2)                     (24/2 – 28/2)          (2/3 – 6/3)          (9/3 – 13/3)    (16/3 – 20/3)      (23/3…)

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                                       April 2020
                                                                                                                                             24
After a surge in price at the beginning of the week, Spanish MIBGAS
plummeted to c.8€/MWh
  Daily MIBGAS price and volume , 2020 – [EUR/MWh, MWh]

12
               11.1
11
                                        10.2
                                                                                                                                        10.1
10
                                   10.0                                                                    9.3
       9.5                                                              8.7
9
                                                                                                                                      9.2
                                                                                                                                                      8.6               8.2
                                                                                                     8.8
                                                                               8.4
8
                     98                                                                                                          95                                   7.9
                          86                                  85                                   89 83
7                                                        78                   83                                                      77                         82
           75                  74 71                               76                 76 73                                                                           75
      63        64                               67 65                             67                      62            67 72
                                                                                              59
                                          55
                                                                        48                                       52 56                      55
                                                                                                                                                      49
                                                                                                                                                            56              56
6                                                                                                                                                37

5
               Week 8                               Week 9                            Week 10                      Week 11                          Week 12
             (17/2 – 23/2)                        (24/2 – 1/3)                       (2/3 – 8/3)                  (9/3 – 15/3)                    (16/3 – 22/3)

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                                                                                   April 2020
                                                                                                                                                                                         25
Spanish pool price futures have decreased along with commodities
prices in the past four weeks
  Daily future prices for pool in Q4 2020 , YR 2021 , YR 2022 – [EUR/MWh]
48

47
     46.8
46                                                        45.5
                                                                                              45.0
45

44

43                                                                                             -8.9%
          -19%                                                   -14%
42

41
                                                                                                                         41.0
40
                                                                                       39.1
39
                                                   38.1
38

37
       W8         W9        W10        W11       W12        W8      W9   W10   W11   W12        W8     W9   W10   W11   W12

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                                  April 2020
                                                                                                                                        26
Spot pool price in Spain is volatile although it is following a downward
path in the past weeks…
  Daily spot price, 2020 – [EUR/MWh]

45          42.8
                                    41.6
40                                                                                             38.8

35                                                  33.9
      36.0                     36.5                                                 32.5
                  -19%                                                                            34.0            30.7
30                                       32.8                                                                                    29.0
                                                 30.6          26.1             27.7

25
                                                                                                          26.8

20                                                                          21.4

15
                                                            14.2
10

5

0
            Week 8                             Week 9                  Week 10              Week 11                Week 12          W13
          (17/2 – 23/2)                      (24/2 – 1/3)             (2/3 – 8/3)          (9/3 – 15/3)          (16/3 – 22/3)      (23/3…)

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                                                April 2020
                                                                                                                                                      27
…due to lower power demand, which is being backed up mainly by
renewables, hydro and nuclear
  Hourly spot price for March 17th 2020 and March 18th                                            Operating hourly generation1) by technology March
  2020 – [EUR/MWh]                                                                                17th and 18th 2020 – [GWh]
                                                                                                  March 17th              Coal   March 18th
42                                                                                        30
                                                                  40.4
40                                                                                                 CCGT
                                                                            39.4
38                                                                                        25                    Solar2)

                                                                                                    NG Cogeneration
36
                                                                                          20
34                                                                                                  Hydro3)
                              32.3                                       32.5
32                                                   31.0
                                                                               32.5
                                                                                          15
30                             31.5                             Avg. 30.7€/MWh                      Nuclear

28                                                              Avg. 28.4€/MWh
                                                                                          10                                                          1) Operating hourly program generation. Excluded
                                                                                                                                                      biomass, fossil oil, household and similar wastes, sundry
26                                                                                                                                                    waste, biogas, mining subproducts, geothermal and
                                                                                                                                                      ocean and residual energy (c.+-1.GWh per hour) due to
            23.7
24                                                                                          5
                                                                                                                                                      visualization purposes | 2) Solar PV and Thermal
                                                    24.0                                            Wind4)                                            (adjusted) | 3) UGH, non-UGH and turbine pumping | 4)
                                                                                                                                                      Adjusted
22                          Last Sunday 4th April, a 20% reduction of demand and current overcapacity has caused that
                            during 80% of the hours the prices have been close to zero, and nucleas power plants have
                                                                                                                                                      Source: REE; Strategy& Analysis
            21.8            reduced its power
20                                                          0
      0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24                       0      6    12     18     0      6    12     18
     Last Sunday 4th April, a 20% reduction of demand and current overcapacity caused that during 80% of the hours the prices have been close to zero, and
                                                        nuclear power plants have reduced their power
Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                                                                                                          April 2020
                                                                                                                                                                                                                28
Renewable permitting processes will be delayed due to the
recent COVID-19 outbreak
  Hot topics on project development and COVID-19
                                                                          Impact on project development
       Royal Decree 463/2020, of March 14th, declaring the state of
       alarm for the management of the health crisis situation            • The RDL passed by the Spanish
       caused by COVID-19                                                   Government suspends administrative
                                                                            procedures for the next 15 days (the current
   Third additional provision. Suspension of administrative deadlines       length of the state of alarm), which will
   1. Terms are suspended and deadlines for processing                      generate delays in all permitting processes,
      procedures of public sector entities are interrupted. The             specially for RTB projects
      reckoning of the deadlines will be resumed at the moment            • Construction activity is currently suspended
      when the present RD or, where appropriate, its extensions,            by RDL 11/2020. Therefore, projects with
      loses its validity                                                    expected COD in Q2 – Q3 2020 may be
                                                                            affected by the RDL.
   2. The suspension of terms and the interruption of deadlines will      • The expiration of access and connection to
      apply to the entire public sector defined in Law 39/2015, of          grid on March 31st 2020 that affected
      October 1st, on the Common Administrative Procedure of                renewable projects whose access was
      Public Administrations                                                granted before Electric Sector Law of 2013
   3. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the competent body may agree,          has been modified. Now the new expiration
      by means of a reasoned resolution, the management and                 term would be 2 months from termination of
      instruction measures strictly necessary to avoid serious              state of alarm.
      damage to the rights and interests of the interested party in the   • Without the approval of the Climate Change
      procedure and provided that the latter expresses its                  Law, it is not possible to call new auctions
      agreement, or when the interested party expresses its                 with other methodology than the one used in
      agreement that the term is not suspended                              the 2016 and 2017 auctions, leading to
                                                                            potential delays in new renewable auctions
   4. […]

Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector                                                                             April 2020
                                                                                                                                   29
Contacts
    Carlos Fernández Landa                       Óscar Barrero Gil                    Iñaki Goiriena Basualdu               Ana Rodríguez Cantarero
    Partner, PwC Spain                           Partner, PwC Spain                   Partner, PwC Spain                    Partner, PwC Spain.
    Energy practice leader                       Energy practice. Consulting          Energy practice. Assurance            Energy practice.
    Deals partner                                oscar.barrero.gil@pwc.com            inaki.goiriena@pwc.com                Tax Services
    carlos.fernandez.landa@pwc.com                                                                                          ana.cantarero@pwc.com

                                                 Fernando Calancha Marzana            Helena Lapeyra Lasa                   Juan Manuel Anguita Amate
                                                 Partner, PwC Spain.                  Partner, PwC Spain                    Partner, PwC Spain
                                                 Energy practice.                     Energy practice. Consulting           Energy practice. Assurance
                                                 Legal Services                       helena.lapeyra @pwc.com               juan_manuel.anguita.amate @pwc.com
                                                 fernando.calancha.marzana @pwc.com

                                                                                                                            Alfonso Lacave Martos
                                                 Santiago Otero Sardina               Carlos Sánchez Mercader
                                                                                                                            Partner, PwC Spain
                                                 Partner, PwC Spain. Strategy&        Partner, PwC Spain
                                                                                                                            Deals Energy practise
                                                 Energy practice                      Deals Energy practise
                                                                                                                            alfonso.lacave.martos@pwc.com
                                                 Santiago.otero.sardina@pwc.com       carlos.sanchez.mercader@pwc.com

                                                 David Rodríguez Villanueva           Gerardo Fernández Martín              Iván Sánchez Saugar
                                                 Director, PwC Spain                  Director, PwC Spain                   Director, PwC Spain
                                                 Client Services. Strategy&           Client Services. Strategy&            Deals Energy practise
                                                 david.rodriguez.villanueva@pwc.com   gerardo.fernandez.martin@pwc.com      van.sanchez.sauga @pwc.com

     Antonio Velasco                              Silvia Lucena                        Emilio Rodriguez Blanco
                                                                                                                            Fernando Sanchez Vicente
     Partner, PwC Spain                           Partner, PwC Spain                   Partner, PwC Spain
                                                                                                                            Director, PwC Spain
     Energy practice. Assurance                   Deals practise. M&A Tax              Energy practice.
                                                                                                                            Deals Energy practise
     antonio.velasco.danobeitia@es.pwc.com        silvia.lucena.gosalvez@es.pwc.com    Tax Services
                                                                                                                            fernando.sanchez.vicente@es.pwc.com
                                                                                       emilio.rodriguez.blanco@es.pwc.com

                                                                                                                                                                  Abril 2020
Overview of the impact on Spanish power sector
                                                                                                                                                                         30
pwc.com/es

El presente documento ha sido preparado a efectos de orientación general sobre materias de interés y no constituye asesoramiento profesional alguno. No deben
llevarse a cabo actuaciones en base a la información contenida en este documento, sin obtener el específico asesoramiento profesional. No se efectúa manifestación
ni se presta garantía alguna (de carácter expreso o tácito) respecto de la exactitud o integridad de la información contenida en el mismo y, en la medida legalmente
permitida. PricewaterhouseCoopers Asesores de Negocios, S.L., sus socios, empleados o colaboradores no aceptan ni asumen obligación, responsabilidad o deber de
diligencia alguna respecto de las consecuencias de la actuación u omisión por su parte o de terceros, en base a la información contenida en este documento o
respecto de cualquier decisión fundada en la misma.
© 2020 PricewaterhouseCoopers Asesores de Negocios, S.L. Todos los derechos reservados. "PwC" se refiere a PricewaterhouseCoopers Asesores de Negocios,
S.L, firma miembro de PricewaterhouseCoopers International Limited; cada una de las cuales es una entidad legal separada e independiente.
You can also read