The power of digital transformation - Part of the Orange group - Sofrecom

Page created by Roberto Mack
 
CONTINUE READING
The power of digital transformation - Part of the Orange group - Sofrecom
The power
      of digital
transformation

              Part of the Orange group
The power of digital transformation - Part of the Orange group - Sofrecom
T H E P OWE R OF DIGI TAL TRANS FORMATIO N

                                  OUR LOC AT IONS

EUROPE                                       MIDDLE EAST

Sofrecom S.A.                                Sofrecom Dubai & Qatar
24, avenue du Petit Parc                     Dubai Internet City
94307 Vincennes Cedex                        Building 3, Office 103
France                                       P.O. Box 500425
 T + 33 1 57 36 45 00                        Dubai
ldcontact.sofrecom@sofrecom.com              United Arab Emirates
                                              T + 971 4 446 4792

Sofrecom Poland                              abdelkader.dali@sofrecom.com
Grojecka, 5
02-019 Warszawa                              Sofrecom Jordan
Poland                                       Office Orange Jordan
T + 48 22 543 46 00                          City Centre
dominique.foucher@sofrecom.com               Jabal Amman 1st circle
                                             Post Office Box 1689
                                             11118 Amman
MAGHREB                                      Jordan
                                              T + 962 775 22 09 99

Sofrecom Algeria                             abdelkader.dali@sofrecom.com
6, rue des frères Kadri - Hydra
Alger
Algeria                                      ASIA
 T + 213 21 60 70 67

abderrahmane.arfa@sofrecom.com               Sofrecom Indonesia
                                             Graha Aktiva, 4th floor
Sofrecom Services Maroc                      JI. HR. Rasuna Said
Technopolis                                  Blok X-I Kav.3
Bâtiment BO - 2ème étage                     Jakarta 12950
11100 Sala Aljadida                          Indonesia
Morocco                                       T + 62 21 52920350

 T + 212 5 37 27 99 00                       thierry.dubois@sofrecom.com
driss.katif@sofrecom.com
                                             Sofrecom Thailand
Sofrecom Tunisia                             Zuellig House, 5th Floor
Immeuble Matrix                              1-7 Silom Road, Silom, Bang Rak
Rue du Lac Constance                         Bangkok 10500
Les Berges du Lac                            Thailand
Tunis                                         T + 66 2 784 7999

Tunisia                                      herve.cortada@orange.com
 T + 216 71 162 800

siwar.farhat@sofrecom.com
                                             AMERICA

                                             Sofrecom Argentina
                                             Reconquista 609 - C1003ABM
                                             Buenos Aires
                                             Argentina
                                              T + 5411 45 15 90 00

                                             adrian.hettema@sofrecom.com

                                             Sofrecom in the Silicon Valley
                                             Pascale Vieljeuf
                                             T + 33 1 57 36 45 00

                                             pascale.vieljeuf@sofrecom.com

2   Sofrecom, The Know-How Network
The power of digital transformation - Part of the Orange group - Sofrecom
E DITO

                                        T
                                                	oday digital is omnipresent! It is obliging operators to seek
                                                  new agile models far removed from their traditional silo-type
                                                  organizations and to rethink their business in a market in
                                                  constant movement.

                                        Their battle cry is “innovate and adapt", accepting that risks must be
                                        taken in an open ecosystem based on collaborative working and in
                                        which all ideas might turn out to be good ones.

                                        Operators face numerous challenges. They must adapt to changes in
                                        consumer behavior in order to personalize the customer relationship.
                                        They must find new value proposals by rapidly seizing opportunities
           SU MMA RY
                                        to develop new activities, often disruptive to their traditional core
                                        business. And last but not least, they must insufflate digital into the
                                        very heart of their organizations, for the digital wave also creates new
                4›5
                                        internal dynamism and spurs new working modes. It also transforms
          2014 highlights
                                        the managerial approach through increased collaboration and
                6›9                     transversality.
           2014 in figures
                                        All this requires proactive market intelligence, always bearing in mind
                 10                     two key questions: “What will this change for my customers?” and “How
          Metanetworks:                 will this grow my business and activities ?"
     a new challenge for telcos
                                        Our latest publication “The Power of Digital Transformation” spotlights
                 11
                                        recent operator trends and initiatives whose purpose is evidently to
Self-optimization (SON) is the future
        of cellular networks            increase differentiation and to counter increasingly troublesome OTTs
                                        and start-ups.
                 12
 Network Functions Virtualization:      Operators are diversifying into new segments such as B2B to meet
   a new network service model          enterprise digitization needs. They are launching new consumer
                 13                     services such as m-banking and “smart home”. And they are adapting
   Bringing digital into the heart      their partnership strategies as they perceive the advantages of open
       of our organizations             innovation.
               14 › 16                  Today the “Customer Experience” is all. This is why operators are
      Innovation seen from…             making their broadband networks more powerful, improving their
  Asia, Silicon Valley, Middle East
                                        connectivity, simplifying their infrastructures and virtualizing their
                 17                     principal functions in order to improve the quality actually perceived
Even in the digital world, the human    by end-users.
 remains THE differentiating factor
                                        Combining excellent customer experience with economic performance:
                 18
                                        that’s what the digital transformation is all about!
             Digital B2B
   frees up corporate innovation!

                 19                     Enjoy your reading.
4G: the fine line between innovation
           and profitability

               20 › 21
       Fresh impetus for
     mobile financial services                                                              Jacques Moulin,
                                                                                                      CEO

                                                                                 Sofrecom, The Know-How Network   3
The power of digital transformation - Part of the Orange group - Sofrecom
T H E P OWE R OF DIGI TAL TRANS FORMATIO N

                                 2014 highlights
            JANUARY
    16    >	South Korea launches a project costing 1.600 Bn wons
             (€1.1 Bn) to develop 5G. Operators and national equipment
             makers will be involved.                                          JUNE
    30    >	Chinese company Lenovo, the world’s leading PC maker,       16   >	The European Commission signs an agreement
             announces the acquisition of Motorola Mobility from                 with the Korean government to reinforce their
             Google for $2.9 Bn, including $660 M in cash. Lenovo                cooperation on 5G development. Research work will
             instantly becomes the third biggest smartphone maker                be shared in order to move forward faster in defining
             behind Samsung and Apple, with a 6% world market share.             new standards.
             The deal was finalized in October. (Strategy Analytics)
                                                                         25   >	Google unveils its Android One initiative whose
                                                                                 goal is to make smartphones costing no more than
                                                                                 $100 universally available in emerging countries.
                                                                                 The first three models were released in India on 15th
                                                                                 September.

            FEBRUARY                                                           MAY
    14    >	Auctions for 900/1800 MHz frequencies in India rake in a    05   >	Nokia, which had just finalized the spin-off of its
             record 611 Bn rupees (€7.8 Bn), enormously more than the            handsets business to Microsoft, announces that it is
             110 Bn rupees initially expected.                                   investing $100 M in a fund dedicated to “connected cars”.

    19    >	Facebook pays $19 Bn to buy WhatsApp as its own 10th        18   >	AT&T reacts to the merger of Comcast with Time
             birthday present, its biggest acquisition since Instagram           Warner by merging with the leading satellite TV
             in April 2012 ($800 M). Two days earlier, the Japanese              operator Direct TV at a cost of $48.5 Bn in shares and
             Rakuten had shelled out $900 M to buy its rival Viber.              cash ($67.1 Bn if debts are included). The deal will be
                                                                                 finalized in 2015.
    23    >	Mozilla Foundation and Chinese chip maker Spreadtrum
             announce the launch of a Firefox Phone at $25 (€20) to      28   >	Apple pays over the odds for headphone maker Beats
             be sold in emerging markets. The first two models were              Electronics in order to get its hands on its music
             released in India in early September at under $40.                  streaming platform ($3 Bn).

            MARCH
    17    >	Vodafone signs an agreement to buy the Spanish cableco            APRIL
             ONO for about €7.2 Bn.
                                                                         02   >	Microsoft announces that Windows is now free for
    18    >	Zain, Bharti Airtel, Orange, Vodafone, Etisalat, MTN, STC           smartphones and tablets smaller than 9 inches (it
             and Ooredoo agree under the aegis of the GSMA to share              formerly cost $5 to $15 per unit).
             their networks in Africa and the Middle East in order to
             develop mobile communication.                               03   >	The European Parliament votes in favor of removing
                                                                                 roaming fees by the end of 2015 for phone calls, SMS
    23    >	Facebook announces that one billion active users per                and mobile Internet in other European countries.
             month access its site using a cellphone.                            The decision still requires the European Council’s
                                                                                 approval.
    31    >	Vodafone launches its M-PESA m-banking service for the
             first time in Europe (in Romania).                          11   >	Orange announces its “Orange Alliance”
                                                                                 international partnership program and launches its
                                                                                 first services with operators in French Polynesia and
                                                                                 Portugal. Six days later the Group announces that
                                                                                 10 million people now use its Orange Money service
                                                                                 available in 13 countries.

4        Sofrecom, The Know-How Network
The power of digital transformation - Part of the Orange group - Sofrecom
FA B RICE DU R A N D p a g e s 4 t o 9

                                                                                        DECEMBER
                                                                                 08   >	The Brazilian Oi resells Portugal Telecom to Altice
       JULY                                                                              Group for €7.4 Bn.

1er   >	New tariff ceilings become applicable for                               15   >	IHS Holding, a pan-African leader in towers for
         international calls between European countries.                                 mobile telephony, buys 1,100 towers in Zambia
         The maximum price drops from 24 to 19 euro cents/                               and Rwanda from Airtel, bringing its total to
         minute for phone calls, from 8 to 6 cents for SMS                               more than 21,000 in 5 African countries.
         messages, and from 45 to 20 cents/MB for mobile                              >	BT starts exclusive negotiations with Orange and
         Internet.                                                                       Deutsche Telekom to buy their joint stake in the
                                                                                         mobile operator EE UK for £12.5 Bn (€15.7 Bn).
15    >	Apple and IBM team up to attack the enterprise
         segment and announce the creation of a hundred
         iPhone/iPad apps for specific activities. The first ten
         were unveiled on 10th December.

                                                                                        NOVEMBER
                                                                                 10   >	Messenger, Facebook’s instant messaging, now
                                                                                         has 500 million regular active users.
                                                                                      >	China Mobile now has 70 million subs using its
                                                                                         TD-LTE 4G network launched at the beginning of
       AUGUST                                                                            the year. The operator ended 2014 with 90 million
                                                                                         LTE subs.
04    >	Telefónica makes overtures to Vivendi to get its hands
         on its Brazilian telecoms arm GVT. After surmounting                    27   >	Altice Group finalizes its buyout of France’s
         several obstacles, the operator Spanish finally got its way                      number 2 cellco SFR at a cost of €13.4 Bn and also
         on 18th September with its final offer of €7.45 Bn. The deal                     gets the green light from France’s Competition
         will be finalized before mid-2015.                                               Authority to buy the MVNO Virgin Mobile.
      >	WhatsApp reaches 600 million active users per month.

       SEPTEMBER
09    >	Apple unveils its smartwatch to be launched next spring
         with a series of healthcare and well-being applications. It                    OCTOBER
         also showcases the new iPhone 6 smartphone and the 6
         PLUS (its first phablet) both of which have the new Apple               13   >	Iliad finally abandons it attempt to take control of
         Pay contactless payment feature. Sales topped 10 million                        T-Mobile US, the fourth biggest American cellco.
         on the opening weekend.
                                                                                 16   >	Apple presents its new iPad Air 2 and iPad Mini 3
16    >	Orange confirms its takeover bid for Jazztel valued at                          whose 4G versions incorporate for the first time a
         €3.4 Bn. This purchase, Orange’s biggest since 10 years,                        soft SIM card. This initiative is a potential threat
         would make it Spain’s second biggest wireline operator                          to part of telecom operators’ business.
         after Telefónica and the third biggest cellco after
         Vodafone-Ono. Finalization is expected in 2015.                         26   >	Microsoft announces its abandon of the Nokia
                                                                                         brand for its Lumia smartphones (although it will
                                                                                         still be used for its entry-level models).

                                                                                                     Sofrecom, The Know-How Network         5
The power of digital transformation - Part of the Orange group - Sofrecom
T H E P OWE R OF DIGI TAL TRANS FORMATIO N

                    1 Mobile connections

230 M
                                                                                                       Seven billion SIM cards in 2014

                                                                                                       Informa estimates that there were 7.26 billion mobiles worldwide at
                                                                                                       the end of 2014, or a global penetration of around 100%. However, the
                                                                                                       real number of users (excluding multi-SIM) is probably closer to 4.7
                                                                                                       billion, which means that two thirds of all the people on our planet
Mobile machine-to-machine (M2M) connections                                                            now have a cellphone (Strategy Analytics).
worldwide at the end of 2014. This could rise
to an estimated 800 million by 2020. (Ericsson                                                         Growth in 2014 was relatively solid at over 7%, as in 2013 (6.1%). The
Mobility Report, Nov. 14)                                                                              trends of 2013 continued into 2014 as well, with 90% of new users
                                                                                                       living in emerging economies, notably in India and China which
                                                                                                       together totaled 220 million net connections and remain the world’s
                                                                                                       two biggest mobile markets with 1 and 1.3 billion users, respectively.
                                                                                                       We note however a slowdown of growth in some emerging countries
                                                                                                       as they approach saturation (Brazil, China) and due to hardening
                                                                                                       of legislation on SIM-card registration in U.A.E., Pakistan, Nigeria,
                                                                                                       Indonesia and soon China.
A third of mobiles worldwide now
broadband                                                                                              Net adds in developed countries are improving again with user bases
                                                                                                       starting to increase in parts of Europe after two consecutive years of
It is no great surprise that falling smartphone                                                        decline. The North American base grew by about 30 million in 2014
prices associated with new services and                                                                thanks to tablets (8 million post-paid activations) and connected
innovative price plans (shared data, video, music                                                      objects (AT&T was providing connectivity for nearly 2 million US
plans, etc.) boosted the mobile broadband base                                                         connected cars at the end of September 2014).
in 2014 by 25-30%, bringing the total to about
3 billion by the year-end (Ericsson, Informa), or                                                       WORLD: MOBILE SUBS AND PENETRATION AT THE END OF 2014
40% of the global mobile base.                                                                          (BN, EXCLUDING M2M)

                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Source: Sofrecom (January 2015) 1
Although 3G still dominates, the 4G user base                                                                                                                                  Region        Subs       Subs ▲
                                                                                                                      Penetration Dec. 2014
doubled to exceed 400 million in 2014 (Ericsson,                                                                                                                                             Dec 2014   ▲2014
Informa). The year was marked by 96 new                                                                                pe                                                      ● Asia-       3.799      +8.7%
launches, half of them in emerging markets.                                                                          ro
                                                                                                                Eu                         Midd
                                                                                                                                                le
                                                                                                                                                                               Pacific
Network rollouts accelerated in Europe as                                                                                                   Afri East
                                                                                                           rn

                                                                                                                                                 ca                            ● Africa/     1.238      +8.4%
                                                                                                        s te

operators continue to race to very high speed                                                                         159%                                                     Middle East
                                                                                                      Ea

                                                                                                                                                        As

broadband (LTE-A launched in 31 countries). We                                                                                              85%
                                                                                                                                                           ia

                                                                                                                                                                               ● North       0.415      +8.6%
also saw some innovative pricing and the first
                                                                                                                                                            Paci

                                                                                                                                                     93%                       America
signs of VoLTE. China’s 4G base zoomed from
                                                                                                                                                                 fic

                                                                                                                                        World
zero to 85 million, instantly making the country                                                                                                                               ● Western     0.538      +2.1%
                                                                                                                                        99.7%
                                                                                                      Europe

                                                                                                                                                                               Europe
the world’s second biggest 4G market after the
                                                                                                                                                                     e r ica

                                                                                                                   128%
United States (155M), well ahead of Japan (67M).                                                                                                     115%                      ● Latin       0.725      +1.5%
                                                                                                                                                                               America
                                                                                                        rn

                                                                                                                                                                    Am
                                                                                                              te

                                                                                                                                        116%
                                                                                                           es

                                                                                                                                                                               ● Eastern     0.546      +9.2%
                                                                                                                                                            th
                                                                                                          W

                                                                                                                                                                r
WORLD: EVOLUTION OF THE MOBILE                                                                                                                             No                  Europe
BROADBAND USER BASE BY TECHNOLOGY (BN)                                                                                      La
                                                                                                                                 ti n                                          World         7.262      +7.4%
                                                                                                                                        A m e rica

                                                                                                        13% 2.7 Bn
2000
                                                    Source: Informa WCIS, Sofrecom (January 2015) 2

                3G WCDMA
                3G EV-DO
                3G TD-SCDMA
1500
                4G LTE

1000
                                                                                                        Proportion of enterprise                                    Smartphone users at the end of
                                                                                                        customers in the world                                      2014, or 38% of the global base
    500                                                                                                 mobile base at the end of                                   (Ericsson, Nov. 14). If we include
                                                                                                        2014 (this figure is 20%                                    multi-equipment, this figure falls to
                                                                                                        in Western Europe and                                       1.64 Bn. (eMarketer, Dec. 14)
     0                                                                                                  North America). (Strategy
          Dec.-10 Dec.-11 Dec.-12 Dec.-13 Dec.-14
                                                                                                        Analytics, July 14)

6     Sofrecom, The Know-How Network
The power of digital transformation - Part of the Orange group - Sofrecom
2 Mobile revenues

                                                                                                               40%
Global mobile service revenues up 1.2% in 2014

Pressure on operators’ voice revenues attenuated a little
compared to 2013 (-3.1% vs. -4.5%), while that on messaging
remains strong, resulting in an average decline of 5.3% over the
last two years (Analysys Mason) due to competition on prices and
from OTT services such as WhatsApp, Facebook (Messenger) and                                                   of all mobile revenues comes from data (Analysys
WeChat whose user bases each exceeded 500 million this year.                                                   Mason, Dec. 14).
Asian markets are the most exposed due to exploding sales of
low-price smartphones.

In this context, data is once again the savior, and with a certain                                             Slight improvement in Europe against
success. This segment which has grown 9% annually over                                                         a backdrop of consolidation
the last two years now brings in 40% of all mobile revenues
(excluding SMS). In developed countries such as Europe and                                                     Although new growth is taking its time coming
South Korea operators having launched 4G are increasingly                                                      in Europe at least the former decline in revenues
staking their hopes on video, music and TV content packs and                                                   is slowing: 5.6% in 2014, down from 8.4% in 2013.
on natural growth of data usages to create value. American                                                     This is mainly due to regulatory relaxation (the cut
operators systematically propose 4G shared data plans and they                                                 in roaming tariffs in Europe starting 1st July was
are seeing a take-off of connections to new objects (8 million                                                 anticipated), to some improvement in the economic
tablets activated in 2014, 2 million cars connected by AT&T in                                                 situation at least in the northern countries, and to fast
September 2014).                                                                                               expansion of 4G customers (data monetization via
                                                                                                               content packs, as at Vodafone).
In emerging countries smartphone penetration is finally taking
off as operators strive to create demand. They propose free                                                    Competitive pressure has also eased somewhat as new
access to social networks (“Free Facebook” from Globe in the                                                   entrants approaching their critical mass now strive
Philippines and Bharti in India) and/or attractively priced data                                               to win subscriber loyalty to the detriment of margins
plans or special offers to enable users to discover their services                                             (in France). The year saw several consolidation
and hopefully generate income later (“Jumbo Plans” from True                                                   deals and we can expect more in 2015. Notable
in Thailand, WeChat SIM Card from China Unicom, Free Internet                                                  examples include Vodafone’s buyout of Ono in Spain,
from PLDT in the Philippines, etc.).                                                                           Altice’s buyout of SFR in France, and the mergers
                                                                                                               of Telefónica O2/e-plus in Germany and Telenor/
The year was marked by price wars notably in the United States,                                                Telia in Denmark. These movements will lead to a
the world’s biggest market in revenue. Sprint and T-Mobile,                                                    multiplication of new fixed-mobile offers that look set
ranked 3rd and 4th respectively, continued to shake up the market                                              to become the norm in Europe, despite their negative
with commitment-free offers and unsubsidized bundles, not to                                                   medium-term impact on revenues (source: Analysys
mention their promise to cut by half the mobile bill of Verizon                                                Mason).
and AT&T subs switching to their networks. These attacks
obliged the latter two leaders to react and sacrifice some of their
margin.                                                                                                        WESTERN EUROPE: ANNUAL EVOLUTION
                                                                                                               OF MOBILE SERVICE REVENUES (%)

WORLD: EVOLUTION OF MOBILE SERVICE REVENUES (€ BN)
                                                                                                                                                                        Source: Strategy Analytics, Analysys Mason, Crédit Suisse (2014)

                                                                                                                4%
                                                                                                                                            Crédit Suisse
                                                                                                                                            consensus
900                                                                                                             2%
                                                                                                                                            Strategy Analytics
                                                                      Source: Analysys Mason (December 2014)

                                                % evolution in 2014                                                                         Analysys Mason
                                                                                                                0%
                                                + 9%   data
600
                                                                                                               -2%
                                                - 5%   SMS/MMS/
                                                        messaging
                                                                                                               -4%
300                                             - 3%   voice
                                                                                                               -6%

                                                                                                               -8%
  0
       ‘11     ‘12     ‘13     ‘14F    ‘15F
                                                                                                               -10%
                                                                                                                      ‘07 ‘08 ‘09 ‘10 ‘11 ‘12 ‘13 ‘14F ‘15F ‘16F ‘17F

                                                                                                                                      Sofrecom, The Know-How Network                     7
T H E P OWE R OF DIGI TAL TRANS FORMATIO N

                          3 Mobile handsets

                                                                                            25% 83%
A two-speed smartphone market

With more than one billion units shipped over
one year, for the very first time, the smartphone is
clearly the locomotive driving the mobile market.
Handset sales are showing signs of weakness in
developed markets now approaching saturation,                                               A quarter of smartphones               Market share of the Android OS
but this is compensated by booming sales (at                                                shipments worldwide in                 in smartphones in 2014, thanks
lower prices) in emerging countries, in particular                                          2015 will be priced below              to strong smartphone sales in
China and India which together saw more than                                                $100 (€80), and this will rise         emerging countries. Android
500 million shipments in 2014.                                                              to 40% by 2020. (Strategy              also runs 75% of all tablets.
                                                                                            Analytics, 2014)                       (Strategy Analytics, 2014)
The vast choice of models at under $200 notably
from Asia has driven down the average selling
price from $319 in 2012 to $263 in 2014 (Strategy
Analytics). This decline will continue as phone                                             Low-cost changing the rules of the game in favor of Chinese
makers go after low-income consumers, as                                                    manufacturers
confirmed in 2014 by new initiatives from Google
and Mozilla with the launch in India of the first                                           The multiplication of entry-level offers along with other factors has
Android One models at less than $80 and Firefox                                             enabled Chinese players (Xiaomi, Lenovo) to advance very quickly
OS ones at less than $30!                                                                   in their home market, which happens to be the world’s largest, with
                                                                                            handsets costing half the price of Samsung, Sony and Apple models
At the top end of the market sales are progressing                                          yet of comparable quality.
more slowly (400 M, +12%), but at higher
prices made acceptable by the relatively weak                                               Now facing a slowdown in domestic sales, these phone makers
competition (Apple and Samsung dominate) and                                                logically speeded their internationalization in 2014. Lenovo bought
the success of “phablets” which carry a higher                                              out Motorola Mobility and Huawei is leveraging its Honor and
price tag (11% of all smartphone sales in 2014, 18%                                         Ascend brands to attack the middle and high-end segments. New
in 2015, IDC). However, this top-end segment                                                players such as Xiaomi and OnePlus have emulated the approach
looks certain to be buffeted by the very aggressive                                         that has worked so well in China: marketing almost exclusively via
incursion of Chinese manufacturers.                                                         social networks, exclusively online sales to limit overheads, phones
                                                                                            with good components but selling at half the price of big-name
WORLD: MOBILE HANDSET DELIVERIES (M)                                                        brands. The result has been stunning growth making Xiaomi in just
AND PROPORTION OF SMARTPHONES (%)                                                           four years the world’s third biggest smartphone vendor on a par
                                                                                            with Huawei, just behind Samsung and Apple.

2000                                             80%                                        This amazing success is now upsetting the sector’s industrial
          smartphones     featurephones
                                                       Source : Strategy Analytics (2014)

          % smartphones                                                                     balance, in the way that we saw in the worldwide PC market a
                                                                                            decade ago. It has also spotlighted a number of strategic errors by
1500                                             60%                                        some players who are now obliged to review their business plan.
                                                                                            Samsung has already announced that it will reduce its range of
                                                                                            phones by a third in 2015 and will start sharing components to cut
1000                                             40%                                        costs and be able to introduce more affordable models. And this
                                                                                            battle is only just beginning: Strategy Analytics predicts that we are
                                                                                            entering “a Chinese decade”.
    500                                          20%
                                                                                            WORLD: SMARTPHONE MAKERS’ MARKET SHARES (BN)
                                                                                                                                                                Source: Strategy Analytics, Sofrecom (January 2015)

     0                                           0%
          ‘11   ‘12       ‘13   ‘14F      ‘15F
                                                                                             40%                                    Samsung

112 M
                                                                                                                                    Apple
                                                                                             30%
                                                                                                                                    Xiaomi

                                                                                                                                    Lenovo
                                                                                             20%
                                                                                                                                    Nokia, RIM, Sony, HTC
                                                                                             10%                                    Chinese manufacturers
                                                                                                                                    (Huawei, Xiaomi, Lenovo…)
Worldwide sales of connected watches in 2018, up                                              0%
from 28 million in 2015, the year of the takeoff. (IDC)                                            ‘11   ‘12   ‘13   ‘14F   ‘15F

8     Sofrecom, The Know-How Network
4 Mobile usage

520 M
                                                                                                       Half of YouTube traffic now comes from
                                                                                                       mobiles

                                                                                                       The year 2014 was marked by the craze for selfie
                                                                                                       images, and videos via mobile are becoming very
                                                                                                       popular as well. A survey in August revealed that
The number of Chinese smartphone users (which passed 500 million                                       more than 40% of American internet users said
in 2014), or one third of the global smartphone user base. (eMarketer,                                 they shoot videos with their smartphones several
December 2014)                                                                                         times a week.

                                                                                                       Smartphones can now film in high resolution and
                                                                                                       video sharing is common. This explains the success
                                                                                                       of Twitter’s “Vine” video service used to send short
The rise of mobile OTT applications                                                                    videos (less than 6 seconds) and which attracted
                                                                                                       40 million users within a year of its launch (Wall
In 2014, WeChat, Line, Whatsapp and Snapchat saw their                                                 Street Journal). The German app “Dubsmash” is
worldwide user base grow by more than 15% per quarter (BI                                              another service riding the wave of this trend. It
Intelligence). WeChat in China had 300 million active users                                            is used to easily create selfie videos dubbed using
by the year-end. Encouraged by their vast audiences, mobile                                            sound extracted from movies or songs (choose the
communication apps are improving and becoming a central feature                                        sound then film yourself over it), and then send
of all smartphones. They are diversifying with new functions                                           them to friends. It was one of the most popular app
such as photo and video transfer, games and purchase of digital                                        downloads during the end-of-year festivities.
and physical goods. This trend creates opportunities to build
new business models around such applications. Some big groups                                          Use of mobile video is encouraged by 4G and the
obviously aware of this are showing a keen interest in their owners,                                   promotion of video content by social networks
as evidenced by Facebook’s buyout of WhatsApp in February and                                          such as Facebook. In January 2015, Twitter
the acquisition of Viber by the Japanese e-commerce giant Rakuten.                                     announced a new video service that allows you to
                                                                                                       film, edit and post videos – all on the smartphone!
All these applications face increasingly strong competition. The
latest example is the launch in December 2014 by one of Skype’s
cofounders of the “Wire” application which allows audio, video                                         WORLD: PROPORTION OF YOUTUBE
and text communication, web content sharing and which plays                                            TRAFFIC GENERATED BY MOBILES
heavily on the aesthetics of its platform. There is also competition
from anonymized communication applications which respond to
increasing user demand for better protection of their private online                                   50%

                                                                                                                                                         Source: Techrunch, Reelseo (January 2015)
life. These include the “Whisper” and “Secret” apps with which
users can express themselves anonymously (these companies raised
                                                                                                       40%
$60M and $37M respectively of venture capital in mid-2014).

                                                                                                       30%
WORLD: USER BASES (MILLIONS) OF LEADING OTT VOICE AND
MESSAGING APPS                                                                                         20%

                                                                                                       10%
800
                                                                   Source: Sofrecom (January 2015) 1

            WhatsApp
                                                                                                        0%
            WeChat                                                                                             2011      2012       2013      2014
600
            LINE

            facebook Messenger
400

                                                                                                       86%
            Viber                                                                                                                  The proportion of
                                                                                                                                   smartphone usage time
            Snapchat
                                                                                                                                   spent on apps in the USA.
200
                                                                                                                                   Smartphones were used
                                                                                                                                   for an average 2.7 hours
                                                                                                                                   per day in 2014, four
  0
                                                                                                                                   minutes more than in
      Dec.-11 June-12 Dec.-12 June-13 Dec.-13 June-14 Dec.-14
                                                                                                                                   2013. (Flurry, April 2014)

                                                                                                                        Sofrecom, The Know-How Network                        9
T H E P OWE R OF DIGI TAL TRANS FORMATIO N

                                             C A RLOS JO R DA N & PAT R ICK L AV I E L L E

                                     Metanetworks:
                                a new challenge for telcos

          To improve access to services and ensure a differentiating
     customer experience, operators – and multiplay ones in particular –
         must transform and optimize the rollout and management of
                             a mix of networks.

A metanetwork for a mega                        Global governance                            Deep network transformation
experience
                                                The operator must adapt his                  To manage the metanetwork optimally
In theory, telecom operators cover              governance to the realities of his           three actions are essential:
almost the entire national territory,           new metanetwork and create
but in practice users sometimes                 an investment metaplan that                  -	Migrate to all-IP and adopt APIs to
suffer connectivity problems, for               encompasses all its parts. This                 facilitate interoperability between
example in public transport or                  explains why some European                      different network bricks.
inside buildings, due to coverage               operators have reduced their
holes, slow data speeds or network              geographic ambitions in order to give        -	Choose an efficient, flexible cloud-
saturation. The challenge of total              themselves the means of consolidating           type architecture.
coverage is now changing as the                 their multiplay positioning. Vodafone
focus shifts to service continuity and          is one example: after spinning off           -	Employ data analysis techniques
an exemplary customer experience.               its business in the United States it            to monitor QoS, adapt the network
This is only possible if operators put          bought out some European cable                  configuration and improve
together and manage in a unified                operators in order to focus on fixed-           performance.
manner a kind of “metanetwork”                  line services, notably in Germany and
composed of numerous interconnected             Spain. Telefónica, Orange and BT have        The challenge for operators is to make
technological bricks: landlines (PSTN,          adopted the same logic.                      these transformations simultaneously
DSL, FTTx), wireless (WiFi hotspots,                                                         while maintaining current activities,
shared WiFi, WiMAX, etc.), cellular             Optimal use of resources                     ensuring customer confidentiality
(2G, 3G, 4G) and satellite links. All this                                                   and data security and respecting the
requires heavy investments at a time            Operators have several ways of               obligations imposed by their license.
when traditional revenues are under             rationalizing the investments
intense pressure.                               needed to optimize the creation and
                                                management of a mix of networks:
Unified management of this “jigsaw”
network with the aim of providing               -	Network sharing to reduce both
continuity of service and an                       CAPEX and OPEX.
enchanting customer experience is far
from simple.                                    -	Techniques to optimize fixed and
                                                   mobile traffic transport (off-load,
                                                   femtocell, etc.) can help decongest
                                                   the network and improve QoS.

                                                -	Standards such as LTE-Advanced
                                                   can optimize spectral efficiency.

                                                -	Network virtualization enables
                                                   dynamic network configuration and
                                                   brings down operating overheads.

                                                -	Platform standardization
                                                   and sharing simplifies the
                                                   interoperability of applications.

10    Sofrecom, The Know-How Network
I N T E RV I E W

                 Self-optimization (SON) is the future
                         of cellular networks

                                            “The Self-Organizing Network (SON) solution
                                            boosts network management efficiency and
                                            the quality of customer service.”

                                            More precisely, what can these three         access, QoS, coverage and energy
         Arnaud Vamparys                    functions do and how are they used?          consumption.
   VP, Radio Access Networks and
        Microwaves, Orange                  A. V. In practical terms, self-              In Tunisia and France, we
                                            configuration is a very important when       have observed user bandwidth
                                            deploying new sites or frequencies; it       improvements of around 20% and a 50%
                                            speeds the commissioning operations.         reduction in call drops due to lack of
Mobile operators are planning to                                                         handover areas2.
switch from semi-automatic network          Similarly, self-regeneration
optimization to full self-optimization.     considerably reduces the time needed         SON can also be configured to adapt the
Why?                                        to deal with sites subject to incidents.     energy consumption (day/night, special
                                            It even helps compensate the coverage        events, etc.). These tests are repeated on
A. V. The heterogeneity of cellular         “holes” that appear when such sites are      all our different networks.
networks makes them increasingly            inoperative.
complex to manage. Operators have                                                        What is Orange Group’s position as
to deal with a multitude of equipment       Self-optimization is useful in many          regards SON?
vendors, network components,                situations. For example it can
technologies and frequencies. They          simplify the network challenge of            A. V. SON is still not fully mature. We
have to manage different types of           major sporting events such as the            are still testing it in several countries
network simultaneously (2G, 3G, 4G,         Tour de France cycle race, since the         where we operate.
WiFi) and to aggregate as many as five      network adapts automatically to
spectrum bands (for 4G).                    the “displacements” of traffic as the        Deployments will run from 2015 to
                                            competitors move ahead. After the            2017. Not all our countries need all
And customers insist on tailor-made         event, the technical crews recover the       functions, it depends on their context.
services and uninterrupted availability!    network in its original state.               We are in the process of referencing the
                                                                                         network parts that could benefit from
The SON solution provides a                 What are the main benefits of this           SON automation.
global, unified view of the network         new technology for the operator?
configuration, real-time access to                                                       Europe and Africa will be given
complete and accurate data, remote          A. V. The most important gains are in        priority, in zones where we already
intervention functions, and automated       terms of Quality of Service (QoS) and        have a good 3G network and where we
use of available tools. Its three           accessibility: less voice break-up, better   are rolling out 4G.
principal automatic functions are self-     data rate adaptation, better coverage,
configuration, self-optimization and        and so on. Achieving excellent QoS
self-healing.                               without SON technology requires a lot
                                            of manual effort in exchanges and in
These make operational network              the field. SON technology can reduce
management substantially more               operating overheads by almost a third!1
efficient, resulting in a higher level of
customer service and satisfaction.          To verify the reality of the cost
                                            savings, each function is tested on a                         Read the full article on
The system exploits the native features     zone previously configured to serve                           tinyurl.com/sof-SON2
of recent network equipment or other        as a reference. We measure the
software used parallel to the network.      improvements in terms of network

                                                                                              Sofrecom, The Know-How Network         11
T H E P OWE R OF DIGI TAL TRANS FORMATIO N

                                                       DI DIE R L E L IÈ V R E

                   Network Functions Virtualization:
                     a new network service model

     NFV is a solution that brings flexibility and cost savings, enabling
       network infrastructures to absorb traffic growth and adapt
                     dynamically to service evolutions.

Simplify infrastructures to cut              A pragmatic approach                       Do technological innovation and
costs and improve quality of                                                            operational performance always
service                                      The network transformation has             go hand in hand?
                                             several facets:
The complexity associated with a                                                        We are now verifying that
multitude of different networks (2G,         -	Migration to all-IP: this is in         virtualization innovations actually
3G, 4G and later 5G) and the extension          progress and consists in replacing      generate savings by simplifying
of the radio spectrum used oblige               old equipment by IP equipment.          operation, cutting energy costs and
operators to rationalize and simplify                                                   shortening time to market. The first
both core network and access network         -	Virtualization: this has started        feedback from service platforms and
infrastructures. This simplification,           in the information systems and          network core elements is encouraging
referred to as Network Functions                service platforms and will be           and several operational trials have
Virtualization (NFV), consists in               extended to all network functions       been conducted in Europe with
separating hardware infrastructures             from the core network to the            good results. The easiest functions
from software applications and                  access network.                         to virtualize -─ security, firewalls,
functions.                                                                              customer authentication, gateways -─
                                             This virtualization is in fact             will be treated first, progressively as
In short, we will be able to “run”           associated with the arrival of LTE         equipment is renewed. Purchases will
software on standardized hardware            and LTE-A, so it will focus only on        be made in “virtualized mode” rather
in a so-called cloud mode on “Virtual        these new technologies; 3G and 3G+         than traditional mode.
Machines”. This changes the network          infrastructures will remain with the
topology (datacenters, points of             current technology.
presence,…) in wireline and cellular
networks. Operators will then be able        NFV can also reduce operating
to deliver more services over their          expenses. Energy consumption in
networks, and very efficiently since         particular: virtualization allows
the network will reconfigure itself          network consumption to be managed
dynamically in the event of faults. The      dynamically. It can direct customers
operator can guarantee availability          to available technologies in 2G,
rates higher than today.                     3G, 4G… zones, switch off parts of
                                             the network at night, and allocate
                                             software resources to user groups
                                             dynamically as their needs change. If
                                             all this is done correctly, networks can
                                             be more energy-efficient and deliver
                                             better quality of service by supplying
                                             capacity to users on demand.

                                                                                                         Read the full article on
                                                                                                         tinyurl.com/sof-NFV2

12   Sofrecom, The Know-How Network
I N T E RV I E W

Bringing digital into the heart of our organizations

                                                                                         “To support change our
                                                                                         approach is to count
                                                                                         on individual initiative
                                                                                         and motivation,
                                                                                         collective intelligence
                                                                                         and adaptability.”
          Pascale Vieljeuf                             Régina Sneifer
        Marketing and Digital                  Change Management & Capacity
         Strategy Director                       Building Program Director

Does digital impose structural               What are the fundamentals of                How should talent be organized
changes on enterprises?                      the digital-driven transformation?          in the Enterprise 2.0?

R. S. Digital technologies are radically     R. S. Digital tools facilitate remote and   R. S. Many companies are betting
changing our lives and engendering a         networked collaboration; they improve       on big data and digital technologies
societal phenomenon that finds its way       transversality, develop groupworking        to transmute into an Enterprises
into the workplace too. Whether small,       and allow close interaction with players    2.0. Our approach to supporting this
mid-size or large, all companies are now     outside the enterprise in increasingly      transformation goes well beyond
impacted and their traditional bases         complex ecosystems. These new tools         the actual digital tools: we work
are called into question: hierarchy,         can even underpin innovations able          to efficiently organize talent; we
management, organization and working         to enrich the customer experience.          encourage individual initiative and
methods. Enterprises are constrained         Having said that, and without               motivation, collective intelligence and
to follow the movement driven by             denying their importance, digital           adaptability. The role of the enterprise
customers and their own staff. It’s          services are of secondary importance        is to create the conditions that allow
change or die! But how? The answers          in the groundswell of change. The           this individual initiative and creativity
are not yet written in stone, but one        fundamentals remain unchanged, even         to express themselves and lead to
thing is certain: they cannot avoid          unchangeable: adhesion to a common          innovations. This is where the keys to
rethinking their organization.               project, sharing of common values,          change lie.
                                             full commitment of the personnel,
How can enterprises adapt?                   careful distribution of resources, and      P. V. It will be interesting of see how
                                             the ability to control complex, dynamic     the “digital natives” of the 1980s, or
P. V. Digital obliges enterprises to be      environments.                               the even younger “generation Z” of
more attentive to their environment                                                      the 1990s, will overturn, in a positive
and to adapt unceasingly. Their              P. V. The cohesion of participants          way, our ways of working. No doubt
operating modes are the most                 also requires active and open               by focusing on enterprise projects
important aspect, even more than             communication to ensure that everyone       and stronger cooperation. Enterprises
their market vision and action plans.        supports the enterprise project and         must find ways of seducing them, then
It is rather like the training of a top-     the way it is to be implemented. This       holding them by creating attractive and
notch athlete: he works to create the        is particularly true when working in        dynamic working and technological
conditions for success, the ability to       extended enterprise mode: greater           environments.
react with strength and clear judgment.      opening to adjacent ecosystems and
Digital necessitates greater reactivity in   partners, occasional use of external
a fast-moving ecosystem; uncertainty         experts, and virtual collaboration
must be exploited as an ally; agile mode     through think tanks.
operation is vital to be able to pivot
with this ecosystem. The right to make
mistakes must be recognized in order to
ensure continuous progress and not to
discourage initiative.

                                                                                             Sofrecom, The Know-How Network      13
T H E P OWE R OF DIGI TAL TRANS FORMATIO N

 Innovation seen from…                                                                     …Asia

                                                 Smart Home verticalization
                                               strategies for ASEAN operators
                                               connected homes and help property        offer that is centralized, tested and
                                               developers to propose added value        standardized. Orange has made
                                               in their buildings. They can manage      this choice and launched its “Smart
                                               projects on behalf of owners. The        Home” service in Poland in 2013 and
               Thierry Dubois                  partnerships with other economic         in France in 2014. This innovative
        Director, Sofrecom’s Asia Hub          players induced by this positioning      service has strengthened the loyalty
                                               create the impetus needed to conquer     of Orange’s customers and boosted its
                                               new territories and build new            brand image.
                                               revenue streams.
      What attracts operators to smart                                                  A third emerging model, B2B2C
      home services?                           In the B2C model, the smart home         this time, could also be considered:
                                               tends to become an integral part         teaming up with a telesurveillance
      T. D. The countries belonging to         of the multiplay value proposal: it      company or an energy supplier
      the Association of Southeast Asian       becomes an additional functionality      makes the operator’s smart home
      Nations (ASEAN) can be divided into      alongside telephony, TV and web          solution appear relevant and credible.
      two broad groups: first, markets with    access. It adds value to the household   Similarly, selling services through an
      well equipped, tech-savvy consumers      Internet access and stimulates           alternative distribution channel such
      very receptive to new home               sales. Two scenarios are possible        as do-it-yourself stores is a way of
      monitoring and smart metering            according to the maturity of the         reaching new customers.
      services, then others experiencing       market. In the first case, residential
      fast urban expansion and intense         broadband access is widely deployed      Why should operators invest in
      building activity for which smart        and competition is fierce (Singapore,    smart home services?
      home services need to be studied at      Malaysia), so smart home services
                                               enrich an existing convergent offer.     T. D. Innovations in intelligent
                                               In the second, broadband access is       devices help to boost brand
                                               still being deployed according to a      recognition and user fidelity.
“The smart home                                national master plan, in which case
                                               a smart home offer is differentiating    In parallel with the emerging
is the first step to a                         because it is an innovative value-       connected home concept, a much
whole new world of                             added service.                           vaster trend driven by the “Internet
                                                                                        of Things” and its corollary “Big
intelligent services.”                         The operator’s ability to make simple
                                               what is in fact rather complex gives
                                                                                        Data” and “Machine-to-Machine” is
                                                                                        gaining momentum. We find more
                                               him the key role of guaranteeing a       and more communicating devices in
                                               unique, impeccable, rich end-to-end      operators’ product catalogs, and as
      an early stage as a real opportunity.    customer experience. Service quality     they become more intelligent they
      In both cases the profusion of           necessitates excellent network           need to be managed, monitored and
      equipment and technologies imposes       management and supervision.              supervised. Doing this also enhances
      good organization, standardization       Grouped offers reduce the cost for the   the operator’s global value proposal.
      and coherence.                           user of access to smart home services
                                               of which the most popular are today      In view of operators’ core business
      How can these operators position         telesurveillance (e.g. monitoring of     and today’s unstoppable digital
      on the smart home value chain?           domestic personnel activity) and         transformation, the smart home
                                               energy budget control (e.g. air-         appears as a first step towards a
      T. D. In the B2B model, ASEAN            conditioning spending).                  whole new world of intelligent
      operators position as service                                                     services ranging from management
      aggregators on vertical markets          Another possible B2C positioning on      of a single building to transportation
      such as smart home, e-health or          a fragmented smart home market           and energy and smart cities.
      smart grid. Exploiting their business    is as a solutions integrator (devices,
      expertise in datacenters, connectivity   gateway, platform, applications) to
      or device management, they design        guarantee a genuinely integrated

 14   Sofrecom, The Know-How Network
…Silicon Valley

Digital innovation: a state of mind
  served by an agile ecosystem
What characterizes innovation             the “Fab Force” initiative.
today?
                                          How do we train our personnel or
G. N. Digital innovation is stimulated    recruit the right people?
by the falling cost of market entry.                                                      Georges Nahon
New entrants can immediately              G. N. One way of rapidly acquiring          Corporate Vice President
exploit the powerful datacenters          specific talents is to buy other                North America
initially created to meet the needs       companies. All companies become
of the Internet giants. Innovation is     platforms for data exchange and
also driven by a new generation of        cloud-mode digital transactions with
entrepreneurs, former employees           APIs for everyone.                      How can a telco innovate?
of these Internet companies or from
top American universities. Venture        How can telcos position to counter      G. N. Operators continue to offer
capital to finance digital services is    OTTs?                                   their customers new products and
not hard to find: there are numerous                                              services derived from their own
speculative investment funds and          G. N. It was telcos that created the    innovation or commercial and
participative financing schemes. And      foundations of wireline and mobile      technical partnerships. They must
the application in the USA in 2015 of     Internet. In doing so they have         invest in breakthrough technological
the “JOBS Act” Title III (Jumpstart       allowed OTTs (who have the big          projects, even in the absence of
Our Business Startups) should free        advantage of instant global reach)      identified synergies. This is perhaps
up a lot of investment cash from          to launch compelling services. OTTs     where tomorrow’s Next Big Things
individuals.                              have a startup culture, agile and       will be found, in areas just adjacent

Can we anticipate disruptive
technologies?
                                               “The sheer speed of digital change makes
G. N. Startups are agile and ready
to adapt their business models; big            it difficult to anticipate disruptive
companies are more ponderous.
The danger for operators lies                  technologies.”
with entrepreneurs creating new
categories of services on the fringes
of their existing businesses. These
so-called “full stack” startups develop   without complexes, and access to        to the core business. “Good ideas
everything from A to Z in-house.          multiple financing sources. Their       often look like bad ones at the
Uber and Airbnb are good examples.        innovations can have devastating        start,” remarks Ben Horowitz of
                                          impact on established businesses, as    the successful capital investment
Can we foster a startup ecosystem?        we have witnessed with Voice over IP    company a16z1 in the Silicon Valley.
                                          challenging traditional telephone and
G. N. This is precisely what Orange       WhatsApp replacing SMS.
is doing with its “Orange Fab”
accelerators in the USA, France,          Operators will counterattack by
Poland, South Korea, Ivory Coast,         giving priority to the infrastructure
Japan, and soon Israel.                   development that will make their
                                          networks as powerful as possible.
In the Silicon Valley, we are already     They can also develop new OTT
in our fourth campaign in two years       services themselves with the goal of
and we have opened our model to           worldwide coverage from the start.                      Read the full article on
big companies such as VISA, Hilton,                                                               tinyurl.com/sof-innov2
AXA, Leroy Merlin, FNAC, Moët
Hennessy and Safran-Morpho: this is

                                                                                       Sofrecom, The Know-How Network        15
T H E P OWE R OF DIGI TAL TRANS FORMATIO N

 Innovation seen from…                                                               …Middle East

                                                        CXM: tools to anticipate
                                                       and resolve causes of user
                                                            dissatisfaction

                                                 After a hectic period of high-speed        What solutions do operators need
             Abdelkader Dali                     broadband rollout and acquisition of       to meet this challenge?
            Managing Director,                   new customers, operators are now
           Sofrecom Middle East                  focusing on earning customer fidelity      A. D. We need new analysis
                                                 through excellent service quality.         techniques to exploit in more detail
                                                 To succeed they must imperatively          the data generated by networks.
                                                 find new ways of measuring network         Measurements will be made
      In the Middle East’s hyper-                quality. This is a vital challenge in a    using mobile devices equipped
      competitive markets, does network          market dominated by prepaid.               with software that emulate user
      quality always guarantee a                                                            behavior to verify that coverage
      satisfactory customer experience?          How can you get a more accurate            and bandwidth are at the expected
                                                 vision of what customers feel and          level. The same tests will be done
      A. D. Users today are permanently          switch from QoS to QoE?                    on competitors’ networks to see
      connected to the Internet and expect                                                  if there is room for improvement.
      continuity of service in all situations.   A. D. It is important to “put yourself     In a predictive approach we will
      However, operators often find              in the customer’s shoes”, to simulate      also analyze repetitive network
      themselves in a paradoxical situation:     in real time his behavior, usages and      congestions, zones exposed to risks,
      the reports from network technicians       interactions with the operator in          and the methods of planning the
      show excellent quality indicators,         order to determine precisely which         bandwidth increases needed to adapt
                                                 part of the network is degrading           the architecture to new services.
                                                 the perceived quality. The causes          Optimizing the perceived quality also
                                                 can then be found and eliminated.          means optimizing the configuration
                                                 In a sense, emotional criteria are         in terms of the traffic capacity of
“The prime network                               becoming as important as rational          network equipment and monitoring
                                                 ones.                                      the quality of networks.
quality criterion is
now the customer’s                               The paradigms are changing.
                                                 Welcome to the age of Customer
perception of service.”                          Experience Management (CXM)! The
                                                 prime network quality criterion is
                                                 now the customer’s perception of
                                                 service, so operators need ways of
                                                 acquiring a 360° vision of it. All large
      yet customers in some zones                regional operators now appear to
      complain that service is far from          agree on the necessity of rethinking
      perfect: sluggish downloads, less-         their metrics and satisfaction
      than-perfect voice quality, irregular      indicators. They have created specific
      Internet access and streaming. In          CXM departments which now face
      short, variable and unsatisfactory         two questions: how to proactively
      service and an increasing gap              detect and clear incidents, and how
      between the operator’s quality             to correlate network performance
      metrics and the quality actually           with service delivery performance.
      experienced by end-users. Why?             And of course how to train their
      Simply because today’s quality             employees for this new approach.
      indicators do not correspond to the
      real customer experience.

 16   Sofrecom, The Know-How Network
VA L É R IE CH A P U I S

    Even in the digital world, the human remains
             THE differentiating factor

           “Digital” has become a powerful lever for differentiating
          and industrializing customer service. Yet it remains clear
       that customer enchantment requires a savvy mix of automated
                           and human interactions.

Digital: a paradoxical godsend            A smartphone can engender a                 available and in which carriages on
                                          “phygital” (physical-digital) experience    a given route. The information is
In today’s ATAWADAC world – Any           by providing the link between the           updated in real time using the SNCF’s
Time, Any Where, Any Device, Any          physical space and the virtual space.       open data (among others) in addition
Content – businesses face a kind          iBeacon indoor positioning technology       to feeds from rail passengers who
of paradox: there is a multitude of       is a popular choice: the American           provide good quality real-time data
inexpensive digital ways of interacting   retailers Eagle and Macy’s use it to        free of charge. The SNCF can then
with consumers, yet as their digital      provide a personalized customer             analyze passengers behaviors and help
abilities grow their brand loyalty        welcome and improve service through         them improve their experience.
declines.                                 recommendations, specific geolocated
                                          offers, recording of loyalty points, easy   Video chat, or “someone by my
A digital relationship, but a human       information searching, and more.            side”
experience
                                          Mobile apps and Big Data for a              The use of video in guidance services
Digital services are definitely “must     tailor-made service                         helps increase confidence and
have”, yet what keeps subscribers                                                     proximity. This is the promise of
loyal is still human contact. Recent      Although often criticized, the              Mayday, Amazon’s 24/7 video chat
studies confirm that a large majority     telephone is still the most-used            tech support service available with
of consumers see humans as the            communication means, in particular          the company’s Kindle Fire HDX
key factor in a satisfactory brand        to resolve problems. To optimize            mini-tablet and Fire smartphone. In a
relationship (although the contact        it Movistar employs personalizing           click a user can connect to an expert
may be via digital channels). The         synergies: its Mi Movistar app enables      able to take remote control and help
systematic provision of gateways to       people to call customer service, but        resolve his problems. Boasting an
real-life advisors reassures consumers,   first it informs the teleadvisor of their   average connection delay of less than
which in turn drives sales. This is       recent activity, which obviously helps      10 seconds, Mayday now handles 75%
illustrated by the e-commerce sites       to provide an adapted response.             of customer questions. However, this
which have doubled their turnover by                                                  system also illustrates the limitations
introducing human channels: click-        In French stores, the geolocated            of a purely digital relationship: how
to-call improves site performance         application Critizr encourages a            does a user get help when the video is
(average basket value) by as much         horizontal conception of the customer       not working?
as 20 to 30%, and click-to-chat           relationship enabling consumers to
substantially increases the conversion    report their problems and remarks in        In the end, digital will be seen as a
rate.                                     real time directly to the right person.     plus if it simplifies direct contact with
                                          This person can then reply and even         an enterprise, but not if it appears
Smartphones driving “phygital”            take corrective action directly.            as a hindrance spoiling the user’s
                                                                                      experience. Much of the time human
In bricks-and-mortar stores where 50      Finally, predictive analysis opens the      assistance is necessary to guide,
to 75% of purchase decisions are still    way to co-creation of an impeccable         facilitate and pacify.
taken, human and digital interactions     customer experience. France’s
are different: here digital means are     national railroad operator SNCF
employed to complement human              provides a good example with its
assistance.                               free Tranquilien “onboard comfort
                                          assistant” app which is able to show
                                          which trains have the most seats

                                                                                          Sofrecom, The Know-How Network      17
T H E P OWE R OF DIGI TAL TRANS FORMATIO N

                                                          IN T E RV I E W

                                    Digital B2B
                          frees up corporate innovation!

                                             “The transformation of working modes is
                                             also an essential growth lever.”

           Virginie Jacquet
          Consulting Director

How can enterprises position to              What role can telecom operators play       How can operators implement these
benefit from the growth of digital           in this transformation?                    new solutions?
usages? What are the best strategies?
                                             V. J. Enterprises can find new growth      V. J. Operators who have anticipated
V. J. Consumer usages and expectations       paths by working closely with an           fixed-mobile convergence and very
are changing. And this trend is              operator to develop innovative solutions   high speed broadband can now develop
accentuated by services invented by          specific to their activities.              cloud-based offers.
disruptive players which can overturn
the business models in many sectors,         Among the digital innovations derived      Leaving aside the technical aspects,
for example banking, commerce and            from such partnerships we might            operators must be able to comprehend
automobile.                                  mention the auto insurance sector          customers’ real needs and aggregate
                                             which now offers premiums based on         telecoms and IT services. This means
Digital innovation is a good response to     real mileage as measured by a mobile       federating their traditional partners as
market turbulence because it enables         app.                                       well as new digital players within an
enterprises to propose new services and                                                 open, agile ecosystem.
increase their efficiency.                   Operators can also assist enterprises
                                             transforming their working modes.          The more imaginative operators are
The transformation of working modes                                                     already exploiting these new tools to
is also an essential growth lever. Digital   Indeed, IT “consumerization",              “digitize” their sales force and optimize
services can enable staff mobility while     ubiquitous mobile communication and        customer relationship management.
encouraging collaborative working as a       new collaborative usages all impact
means of increasing market reactivity.       enterprises which must adapt to this       Some go even further. The operator
                                             technological and cultural revolution.     Singtel offers its myBusiness portal
                                                                                        as a digital marketplace that notably
                                             For example, nomadic workers               provides intermediation services
                                             can be equipped with business              between its 375,000 cloud solution
                                             apps for collaboration and unified         users.
                                             communication. They will be able to
                                             securely access the company’s IS, any
                                             time, any place, and using any device.

18   Sofrecom, The Know-How Network
P HI LI P P E LOIS O N & S Y LVA IN M A RT Y

                4G: the fine line between innovation
                           and profitability

Monetizing 4G mobile is a challenge. Operators need to find a strategy
 based on more than just price: they must exploit 4G through service
    convergence and differentiation on key segments such as B2B.

4G increases the risk of                  This approach appears to be paying           to many compelling services,
de-intermediation by OTTs                 off today in terms of ARPU in the            including horizontal solutions such as
                                          most advanced markets1, but not              videoconference, online collaboration
Operators face increasing competition     necessarily everywhere. Europe’s data        and digitized workstations2 and
notably from new “Over The Top” (OTT)     consumption trends are similar, but          vertical solutions to support new
players who are securing a durable        the impact on revenues is much more          usages such as telemetry, retailing and
place in the market thanks to the         modest. In France in particular, price       healthcare.
explosion of smartphone usage and the     competition from low-cost offers has
migration of cellular networks to IP.     prevented operators from monetizing          Helping the development
                                          expanding data usages as they had            of emerging economies
In a repetition of what we saw with       hoped.
the Internet, applications such as                                                     Finally, 4G launches in regions
WhatsApp and Viber are making             Building durable revenues means              without landline networks offer great
consumers believe they are entitled       making users pay for access                  potential for operators.
to “all free and unlimited”. Many
smartphone users now consider this to     Operators seeking long-term growth           On the African B2B market3 for
be the norm.                              strategies must understand that the          example, the development of fixed-
                                          veritable opportunity of 4G lies in the      mobile substitution solutions around
As high 4G bandwidth is likely to         convergence of wireline and mobile           cloud services may revolutionize
engender more apps like these,            services. They should position as            working modes in the coming years.
operators find themselves obliged to      providers of reliable access to an open
count on data service revenues, to        ecosystem offering users seamless
reinvent their business model and to      enjoyment of rich content and
find new growth paths.                    services.

Increasing usage does not always          The big winners will be operators who
mean increasing revenues                  have wisely invested in high-quality
                                          fixed and cellular networks and
Operators inventing new usages            developed service partnerships.
are getting the best return on their
network investments, not the ones         Cloud, storage and streaming solutions
who simply apply premium charges to       are examples of ways of making
their “unlimited” bundles.                users pay for access; they enable the
                                          operator to distinguish himself clearly
Multi-SIM offers allowing the same        from low-cost rivals and to build user
data bundle to be shared between          fidelity.
several devices are one good way
of spurring users to consume more         Exploiting 4G to aid business
data. Operators apply price-bands to      “digitization”
monetize this multi-SIM data traffic:
usage restrictions kick in once the       To date the enterprise market has
data allowance has been used up,          been the best segment on which to
encouraging users to move up to the       monetize 4G mobile’s advantages.
next price band.                          High bandwidth opens the way

                                                                                           Sofrecom, The Know-How Network     19
You can also read