TMS vs TMS Let Battle Commence - n Aspen Pharmacare's Innovative Cash Pool n How to Run a Virtual Treasury - Treasury Management ...

Page created by Eddie Garner
 
CONTINUE READING
TMS vs TMS Let Battle Commence - n Aspen Pharmacare's Innovative Cash Pool n How to Run a Virtual Treasury - Treasury Management ...
TMS vs TMS
                                       Let Battle
Issue 278

                                      Commence

            n A
               spen Pharmacare’s
              Innovative Cash Pool
            n How to Run a Virtual Treasury
TMS vs TMS Let Battle Commence - n Aspen Pharmacare's Innovative Cash Pool n How to Run a Virtual Treasury - Treasury Management ...
FRICTION
    LESS                                                                    is seamless functionality
                                                                            across Europe

                                                                                   Our single European banking platform can take your
                                                                                   business further. Experience streamlined, seamless
                                                                                   banking that can connect you across Europe.

                                                                                   To find out more about how our team can support
                                                                                   you, visit barclayscorporate.com/europe

                                                                                   Connecting you to possibility

Barclays Bank PLC is registered in England (Company No. 1026167) with its registered office at 1 Churchill Place, London E14 5HP. Barclays Bank PLC is authorised by the Prudential Regulation Authority,
and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (Financial Services Register No. 122702) and the Prudential Regulation Authority. Barclays is a trading name and trade mark of Barclays PLC and its
subsidiaries. Barclays Bank Ireland PLC, a public limited company under Irish law, is registered in Ireland (Company No 396330) with its registered office at One Molesworth Street, Dublin 2, Ireland,
D02 RF29. Barclays Bank Ireland PLC is regulated by the Central Bank of Ireland. Item Ref: KE10343-02.
TMS vs TMS Let Battle Commence - n Aspen Pharmacare's Innovative Cash Pool n How to Run a Virtual Treasury - Treasury Management ...
CONTENTS

 COVER STORY                                                                  SPECIAL REPORT
                          TMS vs TMS: Let Battle                                       Smart Treasury – Top Tips                     In a recent TMI podcast, Victor Penna and Olle
     8                                                                        72                                                     Malmgren of Standard Chartered described how
                          Commence                                                     for Future-Proofing Your
                                                                                                                                     treasurers can make the most of smart treasury
                          Eleanor Hill, Editor                                         Department                                    programmes and avoid potential pitfalls.
  Covid-19 has put a severe strain on
  treasury teams and on their technology,
  treasury management systems in
  particular. Here the Editor and senior                                      INSIGHT
  professionals discuss the questions that
  treasurers are pondering – what is the
  best tech for the job in a remote working                                          Cash Management and                                             Future-Proofing Treasury
                                                                             26                                                          52
  environment where instant access to                                                Investment in a Shifting World                                  Management
  ‘decision-ready’ data is critical?                                                 Yera Hagopian and Daniela Eder, Barclays                        Simeone Sperotto, Tecnica and
                                                                                                                                                     Massimiliano Cirelli, UniCredit
                                                                                     Rebuilding for the Digital Age
                                                                             30      Anders la Cour, Banking Circle                      56
                                                                                                                                                     Running a Virtual Treasury:
                                                                                                                                                     Get Yourself Connected
 REGULARS                                                                                                                                            Michael Juen and Michael Bach, BELLIN
                                                                                     Innovation as Usual:
                                                                             34      A New Era in Payments                                           Born Digital
                      Leader                                                         Atul Bhuchar, DBS                                   59          Eduardo Vergara and Chad Wallace,
 2
                      Real-time Multi-Bank Reporting                                                                                                 Goldman Sachs
                      Through Open Banking                                           Speed and Agility: A New
                      David Gomez, J.P. Morgan                               38      Forecasting Regime in Days                                      The Resilient Treasury: Optimising
                                                                                     Britta Baier, Joyson Safety Systems
                                                                                                                                         62          Strategy in the Face of Covid-19
                      My Life in Treasury                                                                                                            Ole Matthiessen, Deutsche Bank
 4                    Richard Cordero, European Association                          Finding a Cure for Cash
                      of Corporate Treasurers (EACT)                         40      Michael Shuttleworth and Crispen                                Lowering the Barrier for Effective
                                                                                                                                         65          Cash Forecasting
                                                                                     Katsukunya, Aspen with Thomas Harden
                                                                                     and Bhairav Mehta, BNP Paribas                                  Nicolas Christiaen, Cashforce
                      People in Focus
 7                    Stephen Randall, Citi
                                                                                                                                                     Accounts Receivable:
                                                                             43
                                                                                     Cash Pooling: Well Worth                            68          A Journey to the Future
                      Executive Interview                                            the Cost of Compliance                                          Bill Weiss, HighRadius
77                    Dynamic Customer Finance:                                      Bas Rebel
                      Supply Chain Support for the                                                                                                   As Easy As KYC: SWIFT and
                      Covid-19 Age                                                   Trade and Supply Chain Finance:                     74          Seamless Corporate Banking
                      Interview with Jan-Martin Nufer,                       48      Rising Above Uncertainty                                        Jimmy Zhang, Pepper Financial
                      Borealis and Colin Sharp, C2FO                                 Aoife Wallace and Daniela Eder, Barclays                        Services Group

  TMI278
                                                              Editor                          CEO & Publisher                   Treasury Management International Ltd,
                                          TMS vs TMS          Eleanor Hill                    Robin Page                        Waney Edge Barn, Foxhill Lane, Playhatch,
                                           Let Battle                                                                           Reading RG4 9QF, UK Tel: +44 (0)118 947 8057
     Issue 278

                                          Commence            Deputy Editor                   Associate Publisher               e-mail: tmi@treasury-management.com
                                                              Tom Alford                      Sam Clarke                        Internet: www.treasury-management.com

                                                              Commissioning Editor            Design & Production               EU Office: Treasury Management International Kft.
                                                              & Operations Manager            Glen Orford                       2161 Csomád, Verebeshegy u. 11., Hungary
                                                              Caroline Karwowska
                                                                                              Digital Design                    TMI TREASURY MANAGEMENT INTERNATIONAL ISSN 0967-523X is
                                                              Copy Editor                     Alex Tierney                      published eight times a year by P4 Publishing Ltd, Waney Edge Barn,
                                                              Elizabeth Hennessy                                                Foxhill Lane, Playhatch, Reading RG4 9QF, UK. The 2020 US annual
                                                                                              Digital Content                   subscription price is $400.00. Airfreight and mailing in the USA by agent
                                                                                                                                named WN Shipp ing USA, 156-15, 146th Avenue, 2nd Floor, Jamaica,
                                                              Columnist                       Executive
                                                                                                                                NY 11434, USA. Periodicals postage paid at Jamaica NY 11431. US
                 ■ Aspen Pharmacare’s
                   Innovative Cash Pool
                                                              Ben Poole                       Will Hollands                     Postmaster: Send address changes to TMI-TREASURY MANAGEMENT
                 ■ How to Run a Virtual Treasury                                                                                INTERNATIONAL, WN Shipping USA, 156-15, 146th Avenue, 2nd Floor,
                                                              Accounts                        Printed in England by             Jamaica, NY 11434, USA Subscription records are maintained at Waney
                                                              Karen Roberts                   Micropress Printers               Edge Barn, Foxhill Lane, Playhatch, Reading RG4 9QF, UK. Air Business
                            All paper used by TMI is from                                                                       Ltd is acting as our mailing agent. While all reasonable care has been
                            sustainably managed forests,                                                                        taken to ensure the accuracy of the publication, the publishers cannot
                            recycled and controlled sources   © 2020 P4 Publishing Ltd ISSN No: 0967-523X - Issue 278           accept responsibility for any errors or omissions.

TMI | ISSUE 278                                                                                                                                                                                             1
TMS vs TMS Let Battle Commence - n Aspen Pharmacare's Innovative Cash Pool n How to Run a Virtual Treasury - Treasury Management ...
LEADER

Real-time
Multi-Bank
Reporting Through
Open Banking
By David Gomez, Executive Director, Wholesale Payments, J.P. Morgan

2                                                                     TMI | ISSUE 278
TMS vs TMS Let Battle Commence - n Aspen Pharmacare's Innovative Cash Pool n How to Run a Virtual Treasury - Treasury Management ...
LEADER

O        pen banking is not just a retail banking phenomenon. This global trend also has
         the potential to significantly improve the working lives of corporate treasurers –
         by enabling aggregated, real-time, multi-bank reporting at the click of a button.
                                                                                                     One of the most
Open banking is taking hold across              of banks to expose data and services.               pressing needs of
the globe. It forms the foundation of           Therefore, with the client’s consent, open         corporate treasury
an ecosystem of new and improved                banking puts in place the necessary
banking services. To date, innovation           framework to present treasurers with an              teams is having
has largely been led by neobanks and            aggregated real-time view of their global          accurate oversight
fintechs implementing new services              financial data. In other words, an API-
and experiences in the retail banking           enabled multi-bank reporting solution                of their globally
sphere. However, open banking could             could facilitate connectivity to third-            scattered balances
also bring great benefits to the corporate      party financial institutions and enable a
banking sector. In fact, treasurers could       treasurer to gather and aggregate precise              in real time.
potentially benefit the most.                   real time ‘as-is’ balances and transactions
   One of the pressing needs of corporate       at the click of a button. This data can be
treasury teams is having accurate oversight     integrated by the corporate with its own
of their globally scattered balances in         systems to fulfil reporting, forecasting and
real time. What’s more they require this        liquidity requirements.
information to be aggregated into a single         Once treasurers have this aggregated
interface to enable more efficient cash/        data in a common repository, data
liquidity management.                           analytics and data visualisation tools –
   Open banking could potentially               ranging from Microsoft Excel to corporate
deliver the solution, thanks to the ease of     enterprise resource planning (ERP) or
integration it enables and the high levels of   treasury management system (TMS)
security and trust involved. As a reminder,     platforms can leverage the data insights
open banking empowers banks to open up          to reduce operational overheads. This can
their application programming interfaces        be achieved through daily reconciliations,
(APIs) and enables permissioned third           improved exception management with
parties to access financial information, in     instant notification of any issues, and
order to create new financial offerings.        managing cash balances based on real-
   Corporate back-end systems                   time data.
are designed and built with an
interconnectivity mindset, also leveraging      Real-time accurate data at scale
APIs. The days of monolithic architectures,
when a single application was developed         Of course, if a corporate chooses to
by adding more and more capabilities,           establish such a multi-bank reporting
have evolved to modest components and           solution, the set-up must change when
open architecture. These components use         new banking relationships are formed and
APIs to interconnect and share processes        when the corporation expands globally.
and data with the rest of the applications      Treasurers will rightly expect data from any
in the corporate ecosystem. APIs and open       new banking partner(s) to be integrated
architecture provide ease of access for         with the existing channel, rather than
applications to aggregate all the corporate     setting up a new integration point.
data in a single place. Also, corporates            As well as integration, open banking
are adopting software-as-a-service (SaaS)       is also about speed and time to market.
solutions where external vendor cloud-          In the new economy, the expectation
based platforms are integrated with the         is for services to be delivered on
corporate ecosystem.                            demand, in real-time. Until high levels
   And corporates’ willingness to share         of automation and standardisation
information with external parties is            are reached among the ecosystem of
increasing thanks to secured internet           financial services providers, connectivity
and encrypted communications with               partners play a critical role in delivering    DAVID GOMEZ
trust certificates. Indeed, the same security   this instant information. And banks and
and trust framework that banks build to         corporates that are ‘open’ to embracing        Executive Director, Wholesale
connect clients to their banking services       open banking and working collaboratively       Payments, J.P. Morgan
via APIs can be leveraged by a network          will surely reap the rewards. n

TMI | ISSUE 278                                                                                                                3
TMS vs TMS Let Battle Commence - n Aspen Pharmacare's Innovative Cash Pool n How to Run a Virtual Treasury - Treasury Management ...
MY LIFE

              My Life in
Treasury
      Richard Cordero,
      Chief Operating
      Officer, European
      Association of
      Corporate Treasurers
      (EACT)

4                            TMI | ISSUE 278
TMS vs TMS Let Battle Commence - n Aspen Pharmacare's Innovative Cash Pool n How to Run a Virtual Treasury - Treasury Management ...
MY LIFE

F      rom a planned career in accountancy to committed treasury professional, via wine tasting and art appreciation, Richard
       Cordero’s life has been full of rich experiences. As he steps into retirement, will he stand still? Absolutely not, there’s far too
       much to see and do.

Eleanor Hill, Editor, TMI (EH): How did        and text related to financial regulation        Summit now enables around 150 leading
you come into treasury and how did your        of banks in France. It was an excellent         treasurers from many different countries
career progress?                               networking opportunity, exposing me to          to network, discuss issues and share ideas.
                                               corporate treasurers, banks and regulators.     Sadly, of course, this year’s event had to be
RC: A life of accountancy beckoned for            In 2010, whilst with AFTE, I was elected     postponed, but all being well it will be back
me after graduating in 1976 from École de      Chairman of the International Group of          next year to continue shaping the future
Hautes Études Commerciales du Nord.            Treasury Associations (IGTA). Then in           of treasury.
Having earned a Master’s degree, in 1978       January 2014, I took up the position of Chief
I moved into the accounting function of        Operating Officer at EACT.                      EH: You’ve witnessed a great deal of
Usinor-Sacilor Group (part of ArcelorMittal                                                    progress in the profession over the years.
Group since 2006). I was on track for a        EH: Why is the EACT so important today,         Do you see a particular line of evolution
long-haul career in accounting, but just       and in what ways do you feel it might it        for treasury and treasurers?
over two years in I had the offer of a role    evolve over the coming years?
in treasury and, seizing the opportunity, I                                                    RC: I see four key areas, or in French,
never looked back.                             RC: Professional advocacy is one of our         ‘savoirs’, developing. First is ‘savoir’ or
   I clocked up more than 18 years as          key roles at the EACT. Political bodies         treasury knowledge. That knowledge has
treasurer at Usinor-Sacilor, both in           and EU representatives, for example, may        then to be implemented; that’s ‘savoir
subsidiaries and at the parent company.        not be fully aware, when setting out to         faire’. You also have to know how to
When I left to join AFTE, the French           implement financial regulation for banks,       manage people – that is ‘savoir être’ – in the
Association of Corporate Treasurers, in        of the potential impact on corporates. It       behavioural sense. From this comes the
1996, it was with the mission to help French   is our essential responsibility to inform       fourth pillar, ‘faire savoir’ where all of this
companies prepare for the introduction of      the relevant bodies of the possible             must be communicated to others.
the euro on 1 January 1999.                    consequences of their actions on                   Today’s treasurer must have a mix of the
   As the new Millennium began, I              corporates and their treasury functions, and    four ‘savoirs’. The balance will be different
further leveraged my industry knowledge        to keep our members up to speed on what         according to the nature and seniority of
and experience, taking up a position           the changes mean.                               their role. However, I can see that treasury
with financial newspaper, L’AGEFI.                During my time with EACT I have              can no longer function in isolation;
As a corporate finance journalist,             witnessed its evolution from a professional     the fourth element of communication,
I played a big part in launching its           advocacy service for members into               especially education of internal
treasury-focused website. Then, in mid-        one that also encompasses diverse               stakeholders – is only going to become more
2002 I rejoined AFTE as an Executive           thought leadership. Jean-Marc Servat,           important.
Officer. In fact, I first encountered the      who has been EACT Chair since 2015, has
EACT in this role, back in 2006, when I was    been instrumental in creating our Journeys      EH: You’ve had a wealth of experiences to
representing AFTE in an observational          to Treasury report series alongside our         call upon. Could you pick a couple of your
capacity.                                      partners BNP Paribas, PwC and SAP,              proudest career moments for us?
   From around 2006 to 2013, I was also        for example. And whereas most national
involved with the Comité consultatif           treasury organisation conferences and           RC: Two in particular come to mind.
de la législation et de la réglementation      events tend naturally towards a domestic        The first was with Usinor-Sacilor, many
financières [CCLRF]. This is the body that     focus, Jean-Marc’s work in steering             years ago, when we negotiated a $200m
is charged with monitoring documentation       the development of the annual EACT              medium-term note with Merrill Lynch.
                                                                                               We spent one week in New York with our
                                                                                               legal partners negotiating the agreement.
                                                                                               It was my first agreement of this kind and I
                                                                                               remember it being a very exciting moment;
                                                                                               a great memory of my work as treasurer.
        During my time with EACT I have witnessed its                                             I’m also extremely proud of the first
        evolution from a professional advocacy service                                         EACT Summit. We didn’t want to simply
                                                                                               replicate existing events, such as the UK or
         for members into one that also encompasses                                            French annual conferences, so we spent
                  diverse thought leadership.                                                  a long time fine-tuning our event, finding
                                                                                               the right location, speakers and guests.
                                                                                               It was a success, and so I would say this was
                                                                                               another fine memory!

TMI | ISSUE 278                                                                                                                              5
TMS vs TMS Let Battle Commence - n Aspen Pharmacare's Innovative Cash Pool n How to Run a Virtual Treasury - Treasury Management ...
MY LIFE

EH: What interests you outside of treasury?     method, whereby you taste the same            I loved going to Kyoto to see the Zen
                                                wine from different years. There is also      gardens and the Miyajima Torii in the
RC: I’m a big fan of Hitchcock films.           ‘horizontal’ tasting, which is wine from      water and its roaming deer population.
They’re all very different. North by            the same ‘appellation’ (its geographical      It’s fascinating. Of course, it’s difficult
Northwest is up there, but so too is Vertigo;   origin, quality, year and style of a wine)    right now, but I’ll try to go there at least
it’s a psychological thriller about how a       but from different producers. My own          once more in my lifetime.
man can lose the woman he loves – twice.        preference, depending on the meal,
It’s possibly my favourite of all time. I       would be Bordeaux for red, and for white      EH: Retirement is on the horizon, what
also enjoy discovering new art galleries        mainly Sancerre with Sauvignon grapes.        plans do you have?
and museums in Paris; this is something         But I have many favourites, not only
I like to do when I travel abroad too.          French wines.                                 RC: In addition to holding my IGTA
Under lockdown restrictions, I do miss                                                        role for one more year as COO, and
not being able to visit them.                   EH: You mentioned travel there. Do you        keeping up my position on the editorial
    I also fancy myself as a bit of a wine      have a favourite destination?                 committee of the AFTE’s magazine, La
connoisseur! I like to try different wines                                                    Lettre du Trésorier, one of my immediate
from France and around the world.               RC: Japan. I’ve been there four times and     aims is to improve my Italian. My parents
In particular I enjoy the ‘vertical’ tasting    it is so different from European countries.   were both born in Italy and I was a fluent
                                                                                              speaker many years ago, but I have lost
                                                                                              the language. I’ve been taking lessons at
                                                                                              the Italian Cultural Institute in Paris and
                                                                                              plan to redouble my efforts there.
                                                                                                  I’ll also focus on travel again, once
          I’m also extremely proud of the first EACT                                          it’s possible. I was supposed to be going
                                                                                              to Taiwan in May of this year; it was
         Summit. We didn’t want to simply replicate                                           to be my first visit – but that has been
       existing events, such as the UK or French annual                                       postponed to April 2021. As well as Japan,
                                                                                              I’d like to return to Vietnam too. It’s been
       conferences, so we spent a long time fine-tuning.                                      about 30 years since I was there so it will
                                                                                              have changed quite a bit. But I’m looking
                                                                                              forward to it all! n

                                                                                              EDITOR’S NOTE

                                                                                               The TMI team would like to thank Richard
                                                                                               for all his support over the years and we
                                                                                               wish him well in his future adventures.

6                                                                                                                           TMI | ISSUE 278
TMS vs TMS Let Battle Commence - n Aspen Pharmacare's Innovative Cash Pool n How to Run a Virtual Treasury - Treasury Management ...
PEOPLE

                                                                                         EACT REPRESENTATIVES
                                                                                         EACT Chair Jean-Marc Servat

                                                                                         EACT Chief Operating Officer Richard Cordero

                                                                                         EACT Head of Public Affairs & Policy Tarek Tranberg

                                                                                         Austria Jan-Martin Nufer
                                                                                         Austrian Corporate Treasury Association

                                                                                         Belgium Karen Van Den Driessche
                                                                                         Association des Trésoriers d’Entreprise en
                                                                                         Belgique (ATEB)

                                                                                         Croatia Mirjana Ostojic
                                                                                         The Croatian Association of Corporate Treasurers
                                                                                         (CACT)

People in Focus
                                                                                         Czech Republic Ivan Haco
                                                                                         Ceska Asociace Treasury (CAT)

                                                                                         Finland Ari-Pekka Latti
                                                                                         Finnish Association of Corporate Treasurers (FACT)

                                                                                         France Jean-Claude Climeau
                                                                                         Association Française des Trésoriers d’Entreprise (AFTE)

                                                                                         Germany Helmut Schnabel
                                                                                         Association of Chief Financial Officers Germany
 STEPHEN RANDALL                                                                         (GEFIU)

                                                                                         Germany Cornelia Hesse
 TTS Global Head of Liquidity                                                            Verband Deutscher Treasurer (VDT)
 Management Services, Citi                                                               Hungary Tamás Onody
                                                                                         Hungarian Treasury Club (HTC)

                                                                                         Ireland John Gilsenan

S
                                                                                         The Irish Association of Corporate Treasurers (IACT)
       tephen Randall has recently                                                       Italy Massimo Battistella
       been appointed Citi’s TTS Global                                                  Associazione Italiana Tesorieri d’ Impresa (AITI)
       Head of Liquidity Management                                                      Luxembourg François Masquelier
Services, and a member of the Global                                                     Association des Trésoriers d Entreprise à Luxembourg
                                                                                         (ATEL)
Executive Committee. In this position
he is responsible for managing more                                                      Netherlands Erwin Bastianen
                                                                                         Dutch Association of Corporate Treasurers (DACT)
than 50% of Citi’s deposit base across all
regions and geographies, covering one                                                    Poland Aleksandra Filipowicz
                                                                                         Polish Corporate Treasurers Association (PCTA)
of the most extensive, multi-currency,
                                                                                         Romania Stefan Frangulea
market leading liquidity product                                                         The Association of Treasurers of Romania
capabilities. This includes physical
                                                                                         Russia Vladimir Kozinets
and notional pooling capabilities,                                                       Russian Association of Corporate Treasurers (RACT)
interest optimisation products and
                                                                                         Slovakia Andrej Revay
overdraft products in TTS. He is                                                         Slovak Association of Finance and Treasury (SAF)
also responsible for the successful          Regional Treasury and was previously
                                                                                         Slovenia Ales Berk Skok
development and execution of the             the Head of Global Liquidity Oversight      Slovenian Corporate Treasury Association (SCTA)
strategy and plans for sustaining the        and Analytics based in New York. He has
                                                                                         Spain Jose Carlos Cuevas de Miguel
growth of the product. As a senior           also been leading the implementation        Asociación Española de Financieros y Tesoreros de
lead and contact for Citi’s key clients,     of the Cluster Treasurer organisation.      Empresa (ASSET)

Stephen is responsible for taking a          In addition, over the past few years        Sweden Ulf Rapp
leadership role in the partnership with      he has continued the development of         Swedish Association for Corporate Treasurers (SACT)

Citi Treasury, both from a balance           the Country and Regional ALCOs to           Switzerland Guillermo de la Fuente
                                                                                         Swiss Treasury Association (ACTSR)
sheet direction, hedging strategy and        drive balance sheet performance and
an integral part of the Balance Sheet        capital repatriation. As Head of Regional   UK Caroline Stockmann
                                                                                         The Association of Corporate Treasurers (ACT)
Costing groups, helping steer the            Treasury he has been involved across
direction of the transfer pricing, capital   the organisation in enhancing Citi’s
and liquidity management of the firm.        capabilities in Interest Rate Risk and
                                             Liquidity Management.
Stephen is a Citi veteran and has held          Stephen is a qualified accountant with
several senior roles in his 24 years at      a BA in Economics and Accountancy from
Citi. Most recently, he was the Head of      the University of Southampton, UK. n

TMI | ISSUE 278                                                                                                                                     7
TMS vs TMS Let Battle Commence - n Aspen Pharmacare's Innovative Cash Pool n How to Run a Virtual Treasury - Treasury Management ...
COVER STORY

TMS vs TMS

By Eleanor Hill,
Editor

Let Battle Commence
I    n many ways, Covid-19 has been the ultimate test for
     treasury teams and their technology. With the spotlight
     firmly on treasury management systems (TMSs), treasurers
are asking whether they have the best tech for the job – in a
remote-working environment where instant access to ‘decision-
                                                                ready’ data is critical. Is there a better TMS out there? Is one
                                                                treasury system still really the optimal solution? Would multiple
                                                                best-of-breed providers offer more functionality at reduced cost?
                                                                And where do enterprise resource planning systems (ERPs) fit in
                                                                a modern treasury? We answer these questions and more.

8                                                                                                                 TMI | ISSUE 278
COVER STORY

  EDITOR’S NOTE
  When reading this article, please feel free to jump from section to section. We also have a functionality matrix on page 19 to help compare TMS
  offerings, although there is much more to choosing a vendor than functionality.

Since they were introduced in the                  cash forecasting skills and systems. This has
1990s, TMSs have come a very long way.             impacted their ability to get quick visibility
Modern TMSs are no longer reserved for the         into cash flows now, when they need it
very largest corporates. Vendors have also         most,” he says. Indeed, a survey conducted
been quick to adopt technologies such as           by Serrala in March and April 2020
                                                                                                              The first and most
cloud computing, application programming           confirms this view, as 42% of respondents                   obvious need for
interfaces (APIs), and artificial intelligence     said that their current cash management
(AI) in a bid to keep pace with treasurers’        tools and processes didn’t meet their
                                                                                                                many treasuries
evolving needs – and their increasingly            needs. “Now that many teams are working                      was the ability
strategic role within the organisation.            remotely, treasurers must make technology
   But with Covid-19, treasury’s technology        improvements quickly and wisely if they
                                                                                                               to access systems
requirements have been ramped up                   want to maintain consistent cash flow,”                    from home, due to
in an extremely short period of time.              advises Riediger.
And TMSs, along with Excel and ERPs, have             Meanwhile, Ashley Pater, Chief Product                   global lockdown.
come under close scrutiny, with certain            Officer, GTreasury, has seen the pandemic
functionalities becoming – quite literally –       increase treasurers’ focus around a
make or break for organisations.                   few key functional areas – and one of
                                                   the most critical has been forecasting.
Rapid response                                     “While forecasting is central to myriad
                                                   treasury processes, for many it’s often a
The first and most obvious need for many           particularly time-consuming task that
treasuries was the ability to access systems       can require multiple tools. Forecasting
from home, due to global lockdown. As              frequency is typically quarterly or monthly.
Simon Shorthose, Managing Director,                However, with the impact of Covid-19 we’re
Kyriba Northern Europe, explains: “We have         seeing treasurers performing weekly – and
seen a growing demand for easy access to           in some cases even daily – forecasting.
systems 24x7. Treasurers have come under           These treasurers need the right strategy, the
more pressure to deliver information,              right tools, and streamlined data access to
often daily to their CFO and board on cash         keep up with these duties,” she notes.
visibility and liquidity. Forecasting, fraud,         Another trend Pater is seeing is a higher
risk management, as well as ‘real-time             dependency on reporting. Again, this
treasury’, are most in demand. This all aligns     is something that’s always been core to
to having greater automation of processes,         treasury processes. However, the ability
deep integration across the treasury               to build specific reports and dashboards
and financial processes and a greater              accurately reflecting key areas of Covid-19
focus on liquidity and future forecasting.         impact monitoring within a business is
Platforms that are agile to deploy and             more essential than ever during times
change, have the breadth of capability and         of uncertainty. “Not just leadership, but
process automation and data insight are            also the corporate boards of directors are
leading the way in terms of delivering value.”     putting tremendous pressure on treasury
   Hans-Gerd Riediger, Director Solution           teams to produce complex reports on a
Success - Treasury & Cash Visibility, Serrala,     much more frequent basis than prior to
agrees that cash visibility has certainly          Covid-19. Now more than ever, treasurers
moved up the treasurer’s agenda again.             require flexible and easy-to-use reporting
                                                                                                         CHRISTIAN MNICH
“With demand, sales and production                 options that enable them to pull from
going down in many industries, it has              comprehensive data sets,” she adds.
become paramount for companies to                     Like Shorthose, Pater notes that                   Vice President, Head of Solution
know their exact current and expected              treasurers have also become more                      Management, Treasury and Working
future cash situation. Before the crisis,          dependent on SaaS solutions.                          Capital Management, LOB Finance,
cash was readily available, so companies           “This has been a trend for some time,                 SAP SE
deprioritised cash management, as well as          but the pandemic and remote work

TMI | ISSUE 278                                                                                                                                     9
COVER STORY

                                                         have solidified the importance of SaaS.               in the cloud. They are looking to be a part
                                                         Another impact is that treasurers now                 of a larger community to learn from best
                                                         require electronic signature capabilities.            practices applied in similar industries
                 Today,                                  Historically, many treasuries have relied             and leverage market insights to make
                                                         on hard signatures, especially in industries          informed decisions.”
            treasurers are                               such as finance. With Covid-19 and remote                The new environment is also calling
           asked to provide                              work, most people don’t have printers                 for more insightful data, says Drew.
                                                         or scanners in their homes, so support                “Today, treasurers are asked to provide
            more detailed                                for electronic signatures has become a                more detailed information on cash and risk
             information                                 must-have.”                                           positions for executive decision-making.”
                                                            Alongside the changing modus operandi              And the way these decisions are made is
              on cash and                                of the treasurer, their role is also evolving         also shifting as a result of Covid-19. Tracy
             risk positions                              more swiftly as a result of Covid-19, says            Kantrowitz, Chief Marketing Officer,
                                                         Jacqui Drew, Head of Sales and Account                TreasuryXpress, comments: “Pre-Covid,
             for executive                               Management, ION Treasury, EMEA.                       a treasurer could sit with their team and
           decision-making.                              “Throughout the pandemic, treasury                    review spreadsheets and data together to
                                                         teams have become even leaner. At the                 come to an understanding of their positions.
                                                         same time, they have a more strategic                 Now, much of this interaction has
                                                         role within the company. That’s why                   disappeared and treasurers must be able to
                                                         treasurers have an increasing desire for              independently and more easily access data
                                                         more automation and integration. They                 that is more ‘decision-ready’. Dynamic data,
                                                         see their TMS not only as a tool to fulfil            via dashboards and automated reports, are
                                                         their core requirements in cash and risk              now vital requirements for treasury teams.”
                                                         management, but as a central hub for all                 Whether a standalone TMS can always
                                                         financial data and strategic insight hosted           provide the right information here seems to

     BOX 1: THE ULTIMATE TMS: A WISH LIST

     To provide more insight into future developments, we asked our experts        experience in the areas of onboarding, integration, bank connectivity
     to offer their views on what the ultimate TMS might look like from a          and access to functional enhancements. “This type of technology
     treasurer’s perspective.                                                      experience is what will make it possible for treasury teams to leverage
         Martin Bellin, CEO, BELLIN, has a clear vision: “The ideal system would   the TMS for more treasury responsibilities such as cash positioning,
     be one that understands the treasurer’s needs, has learned which goals        forecasting, reconciliation, payments, loan and debt management, risk
     they have set and makes, or at least proposes, the respective steps to        management, trade execution, investment decisioning/management,
     get there. Many more tasks in cash management would be automated,             and so forth. At the same time, the ultimate TMS also provides
     including bank transfers around the world, as well as the ability to          the ability to easily integrate and access specialised, best-of-breed
     connect or disconnect banks and bank accounts, just as treasurers would       technology in other non-traditional areas.” The possibilities and
     integrate another email account into Outlook,” he says. “The ultimate         opportunities for treasury teams with an open and frictionless TMS
     TMS would also come with strong payment capabilities, including not           such as this are endless, she believes. (We will touch more on best-of-
     just the ability to transmit payment orders but also the option to send       breed later in this article).
     and receive information connected to the payment. Such an ideal TMS              GTreasury’s Pater agrees that treasurers seek a TMS that has an open
     would act as an intermediary between the financial industry and the           architecture and offers a broad ecosystem of tools – as well as one that’s
     corporate treasury.”                                                          ready to expand and serve key functional areas that might initially
         Wiley also foresees more integrated, user-friendly, capabilities          be missing. Additionally, treasurers value ease of use in a TMS, she says.
     being key. “The TMS of the past was judged strictly on depth of               “The easier it is to use, the easier it is to adopt, implement, and scale”.
     functionality, which has led to considerations such as deployment                As for Riediger, he says the ultimate TMS should go beyond just the
     and ease of use being left behind. The TMS of the future will be able         basics of treasury management and provide the treasurer with a truly
     to do more than simply improve and automate treasury operations               global perspective of the cash situation. “It should provide transparency
     - it will accelerate and improve decision-making capabilities at the          into cash across the entire company, while at the same time enable
     CFO and Treasurer level. It will also be much easier to implement and         treasurers to dig into the details of a particular transaction,” he says.
     maintain. Technology providers that can provide integrated solutions          “Imagine an eagle. An eagle’s eye perspective is very broad, it captures a
     across receivables, treasury, and payables ecosystems will be especially      wide panorama and looks far ahead. But an eagle can also quickly pick
     sought after.”                                                                out prey from thousands of feet away. It is the eagle’s ability to have a
         Treasury Xpress’ Kantrowitz, meanwhile, believes the ultimate             broad and sweeping view of information or zoom into the tiniest detail
     TMS of today and tomorrow should deliver an open and frictionless             that treasurers need from the ultimate TMS.”

10                                                                                                                                              TMI | ISSUE 278
COVER STORY

be up for debate, however. Christian Mnich,        integrations through APIs, leveraging AI        A new dawn
Vice President, Head of Solution                   or machine learning to handle version
Management, Treasury and Working                   updates. Of course, where human                 It appears, then, that Covid-19 is already
Capital Management, LOB Finance, SAP               intervention cannot be eliminated, such         driving positive changes in the TMS world.
SE, comments: “Almost all treasurers have          as the project management aspect of the         But will this be enough for treasurers to be
identified the fact that they need more            implementation process, digital project         satisfied with their tech, or is there a storm
operational data from the business to              management tools must be invested in.”          brewing in the future of TMSs?
identify a liquidity gap. This includes data          Imad Ben Mariem, President, DataLog             Answering this question, François
from accounts payable [AP] and accounts            Finance, agrees on the increasing need          Masquelier, CEO, SimplyTREASURY,
receivable [AR], sales, procurement,               for immediate online support. He has also       describes TMSs as “the vital tools we love
expense management etc. Many of our                seen “mobile workflows and payments             to hate”. He believes that, although TMSs
clients see the value of an ERP system, not        capabilities being used more frequently         have now been around for a long time,
an isolated TMS in these times.”                   in the working-from-home environment”.          many treasurers are not entirely happy with
   Having a TMS that can easily integrate          And it is likely that more vendors will be      what they have. “Often there is a frustrating
with other systems will therefore                  upgrading their mobile offerings in the         chasm between what is expected from a
be more important going forward.                   months ahead. ION Treasury’s Drew               solution and what it actually offers.”
Further influencing TMS requirements,              confirms this: “Treasurers need access             Moreover, Masquelier feels that a
says Kantrowitz, is the need to minimise           to key financial information anytime,           certain technological level in treasury
‘human’ or physical services and leverage          anywhere, on any device. As they often          systems has been reached. “We are in an
more digital services provided by the TMS          need to act fast, they need to be able to see   innovation lull – probably because today’s
provider to support implementation,                cash positions, approve payments, and           systems are almost all cloud-based in
upgrades and enhancements, and also                run reports on the go. At ION, we offer and     the form of SaaS solutions. Today’s TMS
solution consulting services.                      continuously invest in our cloud TMS and        providers seem to have chosen to produce
   “In-person consulting and project               mobile applications.”                           a standardised system with a limited
management has seen a significant
decline as treasury teams require more
support remotely. If they have not done so
already, TMS providers will need to invest
in upgrading their platforms to be more
‘digitally native’,” she says. To be a digitally
native software, it needs to be inherently
                                                                   In-person consulting and project
built to remove human intervention from                      management has seen a significant decline as
the client onboarding and implementation
processes. “In-software or in-app
                                                            treasury teams require more support remotely.
examples of this would be more options
for automated bank connectivity and ERP

  FRANÇOIS MASQUELIER                               MARTIN BELLIN                                   ASHLEY PATER

  CEO, SimplyTREASURY                                CEO, BELLIN                                     Chief Product Officer, GTreasury

TMI | ISSUE 278                                                                                                                               11
COVER STORY

                                                         range of functionalities, since too many          be done to bring TMSs up to speed. “Most
                                                         functionalities cannibalise other products,       TMS vendors are consolidating cash/
                                                         and are expensive in terms of development         treasury data without owning the business
           The cash forecast                             and maintenance,” he notes. (See the matrix       transactions behind the cash flows. This set-
                                                         on page 19 to compare TMS offerings               up leads to limitations. Integrated systems
             is an area ripe                             by functionality – although, as stated,           can provide advantages around that. This is
                for greater                              functionality is not the be-all and end-all).     not limited to systems, it includes processes
                                                            Bellin could not agree more. “Many             like Record to Report, Invoice to Cash and
           standardisation                               systems are stuck in the past, built on           Procure to Pay.”
            in best practice                             outdated technology or still following               Also on the same page as Mnich
                                                         outdated concepts. The biggest                    regarding the need for more functional
          through improved                               technological challenge is keeping up with        TMSs, Serrala’s Riediger outlines three key
               technology.                               the speed of change we experience around          areas for improvement to current offerings:
                                                         us,” he says. “We have moved away from
              Preventative                               on-site and fat-client technology to cloud-       1. User experience. “Thankfully, TMSs
              and detective                              based systems. Community knowledge and               are modernising, but there is still room
                                                         experience are powerful data pools and               for improvement,” he says. To improve
           security will also                            can influence decisions. They should be              user experience, they need a central
           be strengthened                               made available within a TMS. The general
                                                         philosophy behind technology needs
                                                                                                              view of information and dashboards that
                                                                                                              are easy to read and that display all key
               through AI.                               to change. Instead of simply providing a             performance indicators [KPIs] and status
                                                         system, vendors have to focus on results and         updates graphically, he believes. Guided
                                                         providing answers through a combination              process flows, either graphical or voice
                                                         of the required technology, knowledge and            assisted, help support faster decision-
                                                         service level. The customer pays for the             making, and the ability to drill down into
                                                         value created, not for the software installed.”      deepest transactional details ensures
                                                            SAP’s Mnich agrees that there is more to          decisions are based on accurate data.
                                                                                                              “With these improvements, treasurers
                                                                                                              will be able to complete their tasks
                                                                                                              quickly and accelerate decision-making,”
     BOX 2: WHAT DOES BEST-OF-BREED LOOK LIKE?
                                                                                                              Riediger notes. This echoes the points
                                                                                                              made earlier by Kantrowitz.
     In the context of the evolving financial solutions ecosystem, Jörg Wiemer, Co-Founder and Chief       2. Easy integration with the ERP system.
     Strategy Officer at TIS, believes that there are two important dimensions to ‘best-of-breed’.            Riediger is pragmatic: “Treasurers do
     First, the solution itself has to be the best at solving the problems of its target customers.           not want to examine all of the details
     Second, the solution must be capable of working well with other solutions in the ecosystem via           available in an ERP system, but the
     data interoperability.                                                                                   data from these types of systems is
        But what defines ‘being the best’ in this context? According to Wiemer:                               extremely useful to them,” he explains.
                                                                                                              “By connecting the TMS to accounting,
     l   The solution has a clearly defined scope. It is not meant to solve problems for every                controlling, HR etc., treasurers can save a
         stakeholder or be a ‘generalist’ or all-in-one solution.                                             lot of time and hassle phoning different
     l   The vendor has a strong track record of customer experience excellence and is a leader in            departments or entities to get the data
         its domain.                                                                                          they need. Whether this data resides
     l   The solution is cloud-based with a multi-tenant architecture thus is scalable with strong            in a cloud or an on-premise system,
         community effect.                                                                                    it is possible to use a hybrid system
     l   The solution is offered as SaaS, enabling the whole customer journey, including onboarding,          approach to overcome any silos and
         to be fast and knowledge-rich.                                                                       bring it together in a centralised view in
                                                                                                              the TMS.” Integrating this information
     As for what defines ‘working well with others’, Wiemer believes it is important that:                    will enable treasurers to simply click on
                                                                                                              a button to obtain details from AR/AP as
     l   The vendor embraces a mindset of open innovation and technology collaboration and has a              well as planning and budgeting data so
         track record of partnerships with other system providers, beyond sales and marketing.                it can be automatically included in their
     l   The vendor has a clearly defined API-based connectivity and data strategy, with a strong focus       treasury views and reporting.
         on building an infrastructure to support the strategy.                                            3. Intelligent automation. The tasks of
     l   The vendor offers flexibility in terms of contractual and service framework, either as the           a treasurer are complex to automate
         leading system or as a partner system provider. The main purpose is to serve the best interest       and while many repetitive jobs,
         of the customer, together with the relevant partners                                                 such as reconciliation, have been
                                                                                                              automated, there are many that are

12                                                                                                                                      TMI | ISSUE 278
COVER STORY

   not. Increasing automation in treasury            But what might this ‘next level’ that       users more self-sufficient and confident
   using machine learning and AI should            Wiley mentions look like? What tangible       when using technology,” she notes.
   be a focal point for any TMS vendor,            innovations do vendors have in the            For TreasuryXpress, this has been a
   says Riediger.                                  pipeline for the next couple of years – and   founding strategic focus and one that
                                                   how will treasurers benefit?                  they will continue to build upon over the
Elsewhere, DataLog Finance’s Ben                                                                 coming months: “Even with our current
Mariem sees a need for vendors to                  TMSs in 2021                                  user-friendly approach, we are continuing
adapt their solution to the treasurer’s                                                          to advance our workflows and processes
organisation, rather than the other                Over the next 12 to 24 months,                to be more wizard-driven, simplified
way round. “Customisation without                  TreasuryXpress’ Kantrowitz believes there     workflows that do not require a lot of
any further specific development is key            will be a tremendous amount of innovation     physical support. Our goal is to extend
to that,” he says. “With proper training,          in incorporating more AI and machine          personal technology experiences to the
the treasurer and their team can be                learning into solutions. And of course, API   business user.”
autonomous enough to implement at least            development will continue to be a focus,         Like Kantrowitz and Riediger, FIS’ Wiley
a significant part of this customisation           she says. Riediger agrees, adding that        also expects to see stronger offerings
themselves.” This is likely to be an               machine learning and AI will enable TMSs      in the area of AI. He also highlights
increasing trend over the months ahead.            to understand historical data and propose     developments in robotics and real-
   Looking further into the future, Steve          different simulations and new scenarios       time treasury, strengthening the full
Wiley, Vice President, Treasury Solutions,         that will power well-founded predictive       spectrum of functional capabilities from
FIS, believes: “Next generation technology,        analytics in the future.                      basic cash management to complex risk
such as artificial intelligence, API, and             Kantrowitz also believes we will see a     management. “The cash forecast is an area
robotic process automation, will enable            complete transformation in actual user        ripe for greater standardisation in best
treasury systems to move to the next level.        experiences (UXs), which she informally       practice through improved technology.
TMS vendors will continue simplifying              calls ‘Covid-driven’ UX transformation.       Preventative and detective security will
platform delivery and maintenance to help          Here, she refers back to the point made       also be strengthened through AI,” he
companies further reduce IT footprints             earlier about treasury and finance            says. In addition, Wiley believes the Open
and leverage hard dollar cost savings. We          professionals working more independently      Banking revolution will accelerate the
believe there will be huge opportunities           from home – without the on-site support       opportunity for real-time treasury through
for treasury departments as a result of            of colleagues or consultants. Because of      improved connectivity models such as API
recent innovation from providers like FIS.         this, TMS providers will need to rethink      and SWIFT gpi.
The vendor ecosystem – e.g. does a vendor          their UX, and focus on more self-service         Pater agrees with the importance of
‘just’ provide niche technology or can a           workflows to make it easier for users to      incorporating machine learning and AI
vendor partner with a corporate treasury on        navigate and manage the solution.             solutions, and notes that AI-driven cash
a larger scale – will play an even bigger role.”      “By simplifying the UX, we can make        forecasting was released in the GTreasury

  TRACY KANTROWITZ                                  JACQUI DREW                                   SIMON SHORTHOSE

  Chief Marketing Officer,                           Head of Sales and Account                     General Manager, Kyriba Northern
  TreasuryXpress                                     Management, ION Treasury, EMEA                Europe

TMI | ISSUE 278                                                                                                                           13
COVER STORY

                                                           TMS earlier this year. “We have a solid             detection, and machine learning, TMS
                                                           roadmap in place to continue to innovate            providers also need to be on top of
                                                           and expand our AI capabilities in our TMS           regulatory change. “The transition away
                                                           to meet our customers’ requirements,”               from the inter-bank offered rate [IBOR]
                                                           she says. As for SWIFT gpi, Pater notes             to alternative risk-free rates impacts
                                                           that treasurers have a particularly keen            corporates significantly and a lot more
                                                           demand for faster payments processes.               than many companies think. At ION, we
                                                           That demand, she says, is accelerating              build our solutions to cater to the complex
                                                           development of real-time payments                   and evolving IBOR requirements and guide
                                                           – an emerging but undoubtedly high-                 our customers through their transition
                                                           potential technology. “I believe we can             journey,” she notes.
                                                           expect meaningful advances in real-                    Equally important, says Kyriba’s
                                                           time payments as soon as this year,”                Shorthose, is adapting systems to the
                                                           Pater predicts.                                     changing role of the treasurer – towards
                                                               Riediger also believes that payments is         becoming the Chief Liquidity Officer.
                                                           one area where TMS offerings will evolve            With the right tools, treasury can become a
                                                           in the near future. “Digitising payments            more strategic function going well beyond
 IMAD BEN MARIEM
                                                           processes not only makes them faster, but it        the previous mandate of the treasurer, he
                                                           also makes it easier to improve them using          says, into an area he calls ‘Active Liquidity
 President, DataLog Finance                                new capabilities available to treasurers.”          Management’. This, he says, can be thought
                                                               He explains that fraud detection                of as a remit to actively identify and
                                                           and compliance tasks, for example,                  orchestrate all sources of liquidity in the
                                                           can be intelligently automated, so that             business, while protecting the lifeblood of
                                                           payments are more secure and controlled.            the organisation – cash – in good times and
                                                           Adding payment service providers (PSPs)             in crises.
                                                           is also an option. “For customers, PSPs                To assist in this endeavour, Shorthose
                                                           are fast, convenient payment options.               believes treasurers will need tech tools,
                                                           For treasurers, PSPs ensure that payments           automated processes and data insight
                                                           are received as quickly as possible, incur          that offer “precise forecasting of inflows
                                                           lower transaction fees and are much                 and payments from inbound customers,
                                                           easier to apply to the correct customer,”           identification and mitigation of risks,
                                                           he comments.                                        improved controls and fraud prevention
                                                               It is easy to get caught up in the              across the enterprise – as well as innovative
                                                           excitement of new TMS developments, but             ways to preserve operating cash flow”.
                                                           it’s important to also remember the reality         Performance should be optimised through
                                                           of the treasurer’s operating environment.           connectivity, APIs and 24-hour availability,
                                                           Drew points out that in addition to                 he says, and managed globally, with a 360°
                                                           connectivity, mobile technology, fraud              perspective on liquidity. But he cautions
                                                                                                               that as well as innovative technology,
                                                                                                               “treasury is moving to be part of the heart
     BOX 3: PREPARING PEOPLE FOR NEW TECHNOLOGY                                                                of finance and will add increasing value to
                                                                                                               the broader financial decision making.”
                                                                                                                  Such a fundamental shift will take time
     The pressure on treasurers to deliver more, or better-packaged, information is growing. There is          to achieve, given the mindset changes
     also more pressure in terms of equipment cost, so strategies are having to change and solutions           required by treasurers and their wider
     may follow suit to fulfil requirements around reports and regulatory compliance. “In order                organisation, but it is an interesting
     to boost productivity and quality, it is vital to make use of IT developments, but that requires          concept nonetheless – and certainly one
     creativity and talent within treasuries,” says Masquelier.                                                to watch. Meanwhile, Ben Mariem points
        To make the most of any new system, or combination of systems, therefore, treasurers need to           to a more near-term foundational shift
     think about recruiting differently in the future, he advises. “Technology should be regarded as an        in the TMS market. “A major trend we
     opportunity to review the treasurer’s role and its likely future, but the difficulty lies in adequately   are seeing is connecting TMS offerings
     assessing the technology and maximising existing resources.”                                              to external web services/APIs, whether
        Masquelier also believes that to revolutionise the treasury function, it is vital to have a            it be market data providers, execution
     clear treasury IT strategy that must take account of cyber-attacks, fraud, tighter regulation,            platforms, or fintech services. A TMS that is
     reinforcement of internal controls, greater centralisation and a disrupted economic environment.          connected with external solutions, as well
     Treasurers are going to have to become ‘data consumers’ – which means data analytics skills will          as with other internal software solutions,
     be more and more sought after in treasury recruitment.                                                    will bring a more seamless and useful
                                                                                                               experience to the treasurer,” he says.

14                                                                                                                                          TMI | ISSUE 278
COVER STORY

   On this note, Kantrowitz believes we will   this new best-of-breed ecosystem                        looking to get powerful integrated systems
continue to see collaborative innovation       depends on the respective offering, the                 throughout their entire value chain,” he
with fintech players that can complement       architecture of the system and the mindset              says. “They realise that, to benefit from
TMS functionality and enhance treasury’s       of the company, says Bellin. “If there is               new technologies like artificial intelligence
position within the organisation. “We are      an advantage to using multiple systems                  or predictive analytics, they need data
seeing more and more treasury teams            and if the value is higher than using just              to be easily accessible, centralised and
reverting back to ‘best-of-breed’ solutions    one single system, I would go for multiple              harmonised. Using multiple systems makes
and developing digital treasury strategies     systems,” he adds.                                      it much harder for them to reach the level of
that enable them to create a user- and            Not everyone agrees. According to                    automation and prediction they need to be
budget-friendly ecosystem to handle            Ben Mariem, “All treasurers look for a                  effective in their decision-making.”
their unique requirements.” The TMS will       unique embedded TMS. Treasurers                            Additionally, Riediger points out
become the centre of the ecosystem, she        are really tired of different systems with              that while multiple specialised systems
says, and systems will be integrated easily    interfaces that never work. A unique                    can provide organisations with
and frictionlessly via APIs.                   system is really the solution for the future.”          bespoke features, they can also add
   This is an extremely important trend –      Mnich also has reservations. “We talk to                a lot of complexity. “They have to be
and one that could leave treasurers asking     a lot of CFOs who are driving a holistic                maintained and updated regularly by
whether an all-in-one TMS is actually          transformation of their organisation or even            the IT department; you have to manage
the best solution for their needs. So how      are part of a larger company-wide digital               the different system licensing and
does best-of-breed work and what might         transformation. In these cases, they are                support contracts and terms; you also
this new treasury technology ecosystem
look like?

The new best-of-breed approach

Kantrowitz explains that the concept of
                                                            Technology should be regarded as an
‘all-in-one’ TMS is “appealing, but born              opportunity to review the treasurer’s role and its
out of generational necessity”. In the early
2000s and 2010s, the trend in the market
                                                      likely future, but the difficulty lies in adequately
was for an ‘all-in-one’ TMS because                  assessing the technology and maximising existing
integration with best-of-breed solutions
was costly and technologically resource
                                                                           resources.
consuming, she explains. TMS vendors
attempted to satisfy this need at the time
and invested heavily in all-in-one platforms
that were intended to cover the breadth
of the treasury function. However, while         BOX 4: EIGHT TMS MARKET TRENDS TO WATCH
core treasury responsibilities remain
unchanged, the expanse and structure             While it is difficult to clearly predict the future of TMSs, Masquelier foresees:
of the treasury function has evolved
exponentially. As a result, all-in-one’ TMSs     (1) Consolidation of the market through acquisitions, although there will still be a wide spectrum
are simply not scalable and cannot react             of niche solutions and fragmentation with fintech newcomers.
nimbly to changing needs, she believes.          (2) The demise of the TMS in mini-ERP mode, with ‘horizontal acquisitions’, such as the BELLIN
   “While aspirational, in today’s                   and Coupa tie-up, covering future additional tasks of the treasurer.
environment, it is just not necessary            (3) A stabilisation phase with few new products but an opening up towards other solutions to
or economic to think that a single                   help the optimisation of offerings with greater digital adoption post-Covid.
financial system can do everything,”             (4) An off-the-shelf range of products that are easy to use but less flexible in terms of their
she continues. “Technology overall is                implementation. TMS solutions may become more generic and less open to specific
more open and economic, and it is no                 developments required by users.
longer cost-prohibitive to build a best-of-      (5) Focus on AI and reporting/dashboarding, together with the use of robots becoming common
breed ecosystem. The treasury function,              practice for all. Everything will also be in the cloud meaning SaaS for all and no more licensed
particularly in today’s environment, is              software.
extremely dynamic and any ‘all-in-one’           (6) A search for maximum IT security, which is and will remain a major focus for corporate
TMS just becomes so complex and                      treasurers.
expensive to manage that enhancing these         (7) New functionalities for predictive analysis, decision-making and dashboarding, primarily via
platforms is nearly impossible, resulting in         add-ons that can be grafted onto the solution as complements.
a static and stagnant solution that cannot       (8) Modern TMSs will cover other areas and functionalities such as bank connectivity for B2B
keep pace with treasury needs.”                      payments, procurement synergies and so on, enabling treasury scope enlargement.
   Whether or not treasurers embrace

TMI | ISSUE 278                                                                                                                                         15
COVER STORY

     BOX 5: THE RIGHT TMS: SELECTION AND IMPLEMENTATION

     For those treasurers still looking for an all-in-one TMS, or those wanting    a TMS provider that has proven to be sustainable – and that pursues
     a TMS to sit at the centre of a best-of-breed ecosystem, our experts offer    “constant development and innovation to ensure that the solutions
     sound advice around choosing and implementing the right TMS.                  will remain relevant and cutting edge in the years to come”. As for the
        Pater believes it is critical to understand your current needs and         solution itself, he recommends opting for a tool that “enables you to
     your future needs. “You want a TMS you’ll grow into, not out of.              play smarter, not harder”. He advises looking for easy integration with
     Consider your company needs and the core drivers for selecting a              your other systems to ensure smooth processes, high-quality data,
     TMS to begin with. Outline your key objectives, which might include           transparency and a single log-in. Flexibility and scalability to meet your
     automation, real-time payments, optimising liquidity, improved                changing requirements are also key, as are innovative features to help
     funding access, etc. Be aware of the fact that your team might need           you get ahead in terms of digitisation and automation.
     to go through a treasury transformation process as part of your TMS               Mnich keeps it brief, saying: “Look to your business operations
     implementation project. Be sure to include those who will use the             and the units you are servicing with your team. This will allow you to
     system daily as part of the evaluation process – their buy-in is critical.”   think about the best fitting system.” Ben Mariem is equally succinct:
        And when it comes to selecting a TMS vendor, she advises making            “Watch carefully for run and build: both are key to success in a TMS
     sure it’s a stable company with a strong track record within the              transformation project!” While Bellin adds: “If you feel that the
     industry. Also, verify that their focus and strategies align with yours,      provider understands your needs and has answers to your challenges,
     and that they’re making the right service and product investments.            you’re in the right place. But don’t lose sight of the overall picture. It is
     “Look at the existing user community your business would fit into,            technology, vision, service and know-how that need to come together
     and confirm that the provider is responsive to those clients’ needs.          to ensure that your decision is still the right one five years from now.”
     Confirm that the technology stack is stable and scalable. Most                    Drew, meanwhile, recommends investing time in a workshop on
     importantly, make sure the provider is equipped to help not only with         your use cases instead of preparing pages and pages of request-for-
     day-to-day operational and tactical needs but also with strategic             proposal (RFP) questions. “Spending time with a provider helps you
     alignment and growth,” she adds.                                              understand their deployment and support model. It helps you gain
        Wiley also highlights the need to consider vendor stability,               certainty on project scope, implementation timeline, deployment
     experience, and security profile. “We often see corporates hyper-             teams, and costs,” she says. Giving consideration to the desired end
     focused on minor product aspects or bells and whistles, while not             state of your treasury organisation and finding out how the provider
     considering the long-term viability and financial stability of the partner.   can support you on your journey is also critical. “Think even further out
     With the globally uncertain market conditions, corporates should weigh        into the future. Look for a long-term partner that is able to keep you up
     non-functional areas such as vendor stability and counterparty risk           to date with new market and regulatory requirements and wants your
     much higher.”                                                                 business to succeed,” she says.
        Shorthose takes this one step further: “Do not look for a system               Look for multi-tenanted solutions, is the advice of Masquelier.
     but for a partner who can support you to achieve your evolving goals          “The single-tenant solution has allowed the specific configuration and
     now and in the future, and deliver long term scalability, partnership         development of the most suitable solution for each client, but this is
     and time to value.” He also advises building a vision of where you want       starting to disappear in favour of multi-tenant solutions preconfigured
     to get to, rather than a point-solution, and ensuring you do not get          in terms of functionalities and hosted and maintained on the vendor’s
     caught in the customisation trap which reduces agility and ability to         cloud, where each client uses the same version of the software.
     meet the changes in your business. “In the short term, do invest in SaaS      Prices and deployment time will be lower as a result, but treasurers will
     systems and intelligent forecasts which are key for business survival.        have to adapt to this instead of adapting the system according to their
     In the medium term, pay attention to data management and business             individual ways of working.”
     intelligence so you can make more informed future decisions and                   The final word here goes to Kantrowitz, who counsels:
     select a solution that will enable you to evolve towards a complete and       “Whether you already have a system or are implementing one, it
     dynamic view on your liquidities and deliver information to your C-suite      is important that you take advantage of the innovations available
     in times of crises and beyond,” he adds.                                      to you. As such, remember to adapt your TMS once it is chosen and
        Still focusing on the vendor, Riediger highlights the need to choose       implemented – do not neglect it.”

16                                                                                                                                               TMI | ISSUE 278
You can also read