Nitrogen management is critical for wine fl avour and style

Page created by Randall Gibbs
 
CONTINUE READING
Nitrogen management is critical for wine fl avour and style
A W R I    R E P O R T

                                            Nitrogen management
                                            is critical for wine
Managing Director,
Sakkie Pretorius.                           flavour and style
Maurizio Ugliano, Paul A. Henschke, Markus J. Herderich, Isak S. Pretorius
The Australian Wine Research Institute, PO Box 197, Glen Osmond (Adelaide), South Australia 5064, Australia

“W              inemaking begins in the vineyard” is a mantra
                that has widespread support amongst
                winemakers. It conveys the concept of vineyard
                                                                              end-products in different amounts (Albers et al. 1998). Some of
                                                                              the end products that have sensory properties can lead to changes
                                                                              in the flavour profile of the wine. H2S formation is an all-too-well
or, in French jargon, terroir as an intrinsic property of grape,              known example relating to nitrogen depletion stress.
and consequently the corresponding wine. There is no doubt                      Clearly, the vineyard environment and intervention by the
that many great wines are associated with great vineyards. So,                viticulturist shape the development of the vine and especially
where do yeast fit in?                                                         the composition of the grape. Because the viticulturist attempts
   The perception that fermentation yeast faithfully transform                to balance a long list of priorities in order to produce fruit to
grape must into wine has been changing in the detail over the                 specification, most attention will focus on those factors that
past decades. Th is is a result of science uncovering the many                cannot be modified once the fruit has been harvested.
roles that yeast perform, and the wider selection of strains                  Therefore, yeast nutrients, especially nitrogen, might not be
available that promote these various attributes. For example,                 optimised for fermentation, largely in the belief that nutrients
whereas most strains produce a relatively similar, generic,                   can be easily corrected in the winery. Given that we estimate
fermentation bouquet only some strains possess a strong                       that up to 500t of diammonium phosphate (DAP) could be
ability to hydrolyse cysteine conjugates responsible for                      used each year to produce Australian wine, is this winemaking
Sauvignon Blanc character, meaning that only selected strains                 input being used effectively?
can enhance varietal expression (Swiegers et al. 2006).                         Our current state of knowledge on the implications of
Winemakers today have many options through fermentation                       controlling vineyard nitrogen as opposed to fermentation
management to enhance the varietal characteristics of their                   nitrogen on fermentation performance and wine composition
wine, or to express further regional attributes. Furthermore,                 has been recently reviewed by Bell and Henschke (2005). In
yeast strongly respond to their environment. It is well known                 this article, we will focus on the role that fermentation nitrogen
that temperature affects the rate of fermentation, that grape                  has in modulating metabolism and some of the changes that
solids enhance survival and that high osmotic stress, as                      this can have on wine flavour. We will first summarise current
imposed by a Botrytis-affected must, leads not only to increased               best practice for managing fermentation nitrogen and then
glycerol production but also to higher volatile acidity. The                  describe the main flavour changes that are affected by nitrogen.
latter example highlights the remarkable ability of yeast to                  Finally, we will consider the flavour implications of nitrogen for
adapt to stressful (i.e. high sugar) environments. However,                   white and red wine fermentations.
there is an accompanying metabolic adaptation which can
have positive or negative flavour implications.                                CURRENT BEST PRACTICE FOR MANAGING
   At the time of inoculation, yeast are subjected to a range of              FERMENTATION NITROGEN
stresses to which the cell must adapt in order to exploit its new             A common practice amongst winemakers is to make a standard
environment. Some of the known stresses are osmotic pressure,                 addition of DAP to the juice or must (100-300mg/L) at
oxidative conditions, sulphite toxicity and temperature shock                 inoculation without measuring the nitrogen concentration. This
(Bauer and Pretorius 2000). Nutrients, whether present in sub- or             article will show that DAP addition has significant flavour
super-optimal concentration, can also induce stress and metabolic             consequences and that measuring the initial nitrogen
responses. The primary response is aimed at protecting the cell               concentration provides the opportunity to adjust DAP addition
from committing to reproduction when key nutrients are lacking                not only to achieve an adequate fermentation rate, but also to
or dealing with potential toxicity when the concentration is                  more reliably guide the flavour profile and style of wine required.
outside the normal range. The metabolic response often involves               This work is still in a conceptual stage based on studies with
a cascade of biochemical reactions, some of which can lead to                 Chardonnay and Shiraz; however, it should stimulate
altered metabolism of nutrients such that the yeast will secrete              winemakers to experiment with these and other varieties.

24                                                    w w w.w i n e b i z . c o m . a u > N O V E M B E R / D E C E M B E R 2 0 0 7 > V O L 2 2 N O 6 > W I N E I N D U S T R Y J O U R N A L
Nitrogen management is critical for wine fl avour and style
A W R I    R E P O R T

1.1 Measuring YAN                                                            YAN (Figure 1). This procedure is used                          In general, in order to achieve an
Grapes contain a variety of nitrogenous                                      by NATA-accredited laboratories such as                      adequate rate of fermentation to dryness,
compounds of which the most important                                        AWRI’s Analytical Service laboratory                         a cellar bright juice containing
are the primary or alpha amino acids,                                        (http://www.awri.com.au/analytical_                           V O L 2 2 N O 6 > N O V E M B E R / D E C E M B E R 2 0 0 7 > w w w.w i n e b i z . c o m . a u                                          25
A W R I    R E P O R T

DAP (equivalent to 360mg/L YAN) if we            butanediol and the organic acids,                                                yeast Vitilevure M05 DAP addition
assume that the juice/must contained no          especially acetic and succinic acids and,                                        increases glycerol production whereas the
phosphate; in practice a lesser amount of        to a lesser extent, the ketoacids, such as                                       reverse is the case for AWRI 796 (Vilanova
DAP can only, therefore, be added.               pyruvic acid and ␣-ketoglutaric acid.                                            et al. 2007). Both yeast, however, produce
   Overuse of DAP can also stimulate             The production of many of these                                                  the lowest concentrations of acetic acid at
overproduction of acetate esters,                primary metabolites of sugar metabolism                                          moderate YAN concentrations (range of
especially ethyl acetate, resulting in the       is modulated by YAN, although the                                                200-250mg/L) while higher concentrations
perception of volatile acidity (VA) and          magnitude of changes has been observed                                           are produced at both lower and higher
suppression of varietal character. As            to depend on the yeast strain under                                              concentrations of YAN. Malic acid
discussed in the following sections, high        consideration. Furthermore, the type of                                          consumption does, however, increase with
YAN (exceeding 450-500mg/L YAN)                  nitrogen source used, DAP or amino                                               increasing DAP concentration, irrespective
can stimulate ethyl acetate production by        acids, aff ects metabolite production                                             of yeast strain. On the contrary and
many yeast strains.                              (Albers et al. 1996). Because low YAN                                            depending on the strain, succinic acid
   When working with very low YAN                juices are typically supplemented with                                           concentration can increase with increasing
juices, we have observed that other              DAP, only the impact of ammonium                                                 DAP addition (Coulter et al. 2004). In
nutrients can similarly be low. Thus, when       ion concentration on the production of                                           general, YAN can affect TA and the
YAN is low and other nutrient deficiencies        yeast metabolites will be discussed in                                           balance of organic acids which can affect
are suspected, it can be useful to add a         this article.                                                                    flavour (Sowalsky and Noble 1998).
proprietary yeast food that contains more          Ethanol is the major product of sugar                                             Sulphur dioxide production during
complex forms of N, as well as vitamins,         fermentation. However, while DAP                                                 fermentation can also be stimulated by
lipids and minerals. Indeed, continued           addition increases yeast growth and the                                          initial YAN concentration, but the
H 2S production after DAP addition               rate of fermentation, it has little to no                                        response seems to be yeast strain
suggests a general vitamin deficiency             practical effect on final ethanol yield.                                           dependent. Experimental work in
(Henschke 1996; Wang et al. 2003),               Theoretically, DAP-grown yeast are                                               synthetic media and wort suggests that
though other causes are also possible.           forced to synthesise amino acids for cell                                        low SO2 is produced in low YAN media
Most yeast suppliers can advise on the use       growth when compared with amino acid                                             but increases when initial YAN
of yeast foods, which are generally              grown yeast. This decreases the                                                  availability is higher (Duan et al. 2004;
produced from inactivated yeast.                 proportion of sugar available for ethanol                                        Osborne and Edwards 2006). SO 2
                                                 production (Albers et al. 1996), but in                                          production contrasts with H 2 S
GENERAL METABOLIC RESPONSES OF                   our experiments this has a minor affect                                           production, which is generally lowered
YEAST TO YAN                                     on ethanol yield.                                                                by increasing YAN. Increased risk of
The principal role of sugar metabolism in          Glycerol and acetic acid, which are                                            MLF inhibition has also been associated
yeast is to generate energy and carbon           important to wine composition and                                                with high YAN addition but this
skeletons for building all the components        flavour, respond relatively strongly to juice                                     inhibition has not been conclusively
of the cell. These metabolic activities result   YAN concentration (Albers et al. 1998;                                           correlated with SO2 production (Osborne
in the accumulation of several by-products,      Torrea et al. 2005; Vilanova et al. 2007).                                       and Edwards 2006). Nevertheless, until
including esters, higher alcohols and            Figure 2 summarises general trends                                               better information is available,
polyols, carbonyls, acids and thiols which       observed in synthetic juice and white wine                                       consideration should be given to limiting
contribute to the aroma and flavour of            fermentations. Both glycerol and acetic                                          high YAN conditions when malolactic
wine. Nitrogen metabolism, which is              acid production depends strongly on the                                          fermentation (MLF) is required.
involved in the assimilation of nitrogen         yeast strain used. For example, when using                                       2.2 Volatile aroma compounds
for the synthesis of protein and nucleic                                                                                          Among the various yeast metabolic
acids, also contributes to the pool of aroma                                                                                      pathways that are influenced by the
and flavour compounds. Because nitrogen                                                                                            nitrogen composition of the juice, those
metabolism is central to cell growth, it                                                                                          leading to volatile compounds are of
regulates other pathways, including sugar                                                                    Glycerol             particular importance due to the primary
and sulphur metabolism. Consequently,                                                                                             role played by fermentation-derived
                                                 Concentration

nitrogen availability can significantly                                                                        Malic
                                                                                                                                  volatiles in the aroma character of wine
                                                                                                              acid
impact on the production of many flavour-                                                                                          (Smyth et al. 2005). Several studies have
                                                                                                             Succinic
active metabolites. The nitrogen status of                                                                     acid
                                                                                                                                  indicated that both the total available
a juice or must, therefore, contributes to                                                                    Acetic              nitrogen and the balance of amino acids
wine flavour as well as affecting yeast                                                                          acid
                                                                                                                                  and ammonia can significantly affect the
growth and the fermentation of sugars.                                                                              SO2
                                                                                                                                  production of different groups of
                                                                 100         200                300                   400
2.1 Major fermentation products                                                         YAN                                       fermentation-derived volatile compounds.
In addition to ethanol and CO2 , other           Figure 2. Effect of yeast assimilable nitrogen                                      From a practical point of view, the
major products of sugar metabolism are           on production or utilisation of major metabolic
                                                 products of sugar fermentation and
                                                                                                                                  problem of juice nitrogen composition is
the polyols, such as glycerol and                sulphur assimilation.                                                            primarily linked to the frequent occurrence

26                                                                 w w w.w i n e b i z . c o m . a u > N O V E M B E R / D E C E M B E R 2 0 0 7 > V O L 2 2 N O 6 > W I N E I N D U S T R Y J O U R N A L
A W R I     R E P O R T

of juices with suboptimal concentrations                                                         that ammonium supplementation can               odours, typically occur in concentrations
of nitrogen, and higher risk of slow or                                                          improve wine sensory quality by lowering        that can be up to 400 times higher than
stuck fermentation. As this problem is                                                           higher alcohols production (Rapp and            ethyl fatty acid esters, characterised by
frequently corrected in the winery through                                                       Versini 1991). However, based on the            fruit-like odours. Nevertheless, relatively
the addition of DAP, several studies have                                                        trend shown in Figure 3, this advice has        small variations in the concentration of
investigated the implications of this                                                            to be taken cautiously as it might apply        ethyl fatty acid esters, such as those
common winery practice on the volatile                                                           only to fermentations with initial YAN          introduced by variations in YAN content,
composition of wine (Ayrapaa 1971, Rapp                                                          in the range included in the descending         are more likely to affect the aroma of wine
and Versini 1991; Carrau 2003; Torrea                                                            part of higher alcohols production              than if proportionally similar variations
and Henschke 2004; Hernandez-Orte                                                                pattern, i.e. YAN >200mg N/L.                   would occur for higher alcohols. This is
et al. 2005, 2006; Vilanova et al. 2007).                                                           The production of fatty acids ethyl          due to the fact that some of the possible
Due to the variety of yeast strains and                                                          esters, as well as of acetate esters,           sensory modifications associated with
fermentation conditions employed, it is                                                          including ethyl acetate, is generally           changes in the concentration of specific
somewhat difficult to extrapolate from the                                                         increased when DAP is added to the juice        aroma compounds depend, among other
literature definitive conclusions concerning                                                      prior to alcoholic fermentation (Figure 3).     factors, on the ability of that aroma
the effect of DAP addition on wine aroma.                                                         This can have interesting implications for      compound to generate an olfactory
Nevertheless, some general trends relating                                                       wine flavour as fatty acids ethyl esters         stimulus at a given concentration.
to DAP supplementation and wine volatile                                                         and acetates are generally responsible for         This complex relationship is often
composition are summarised in Figure 3.                                                          the fruity character of wine (Guth and          simplified by means of the concept of
   Higher alcohols, which are directly                                                           Sies 2002). However, ethyl acetate, one         odour threshold, defined as the minimum
related to amino acid metabolism in the                                                          of the dominant yeast-derived volatile          concentration at which a given compound
cell, exhibit a characteristic behaviour.                                                        metabolites, when present at very high          can be detected by the sense of smell
Therefore, when total nitrogen is                                                                concentrations, can give unwanted               (Guth 1997). This is referred to as the
increased by adding ammonium to a                                                                sensory characteristics, often described        odour activity value (OAV). Some of the
medium containing very low levels of                                                             with terms like nail lacquer/solvent and        fermentation-derived volatile compounds,
YAN, the production of higher alcohols                                                           volatile acidity. Branched chain esters         such as esters, that are generally associated
is initially increased, but then tends to                                                        are, from a quantitative point of view, the     with the fruity character of wine, are
decrease after a peak between                                                                    less abundant volatiles produced during         extremely powerful odourants (i.e. have a
200-300mg/L YAN. This activity                                                                   fermentation. Although their contribution       very low odour threshold) and can,
depends on various factors, including                                                            to wine flavour has still to be clarified,        therefore, impart specific sensory attributes
yeast strain and fermentation conditions.                                                        tentative evidence is available in the          even when present in low concentrations.
Higher alcohols are characterised by                                                             literature for these compounds to be            On the contrary, compounds like higher
fusel-like odours, and are generally                                                             important contributors to the red berry         alcohols possess a much higher odour
thought to contribute to the complexity                                                          fruit character of some red wines (Diaz-        threshold and, therefore, are likely to
of wine fermentation bouquet. However,                                                           Maroto et al. 2005). Their concentration        generate variations in the aroma profile of
when present in very high concentrations                                                         appears to decrease with increased DAP          a wine only when their concentration
they can have a negative impact on wine                                                          additions, however.                             varies to a very large extent. In Figure 4, a
aroma, mainly because they mask fruity                                                              The existence of a variety of different       theoretical relationship between the OAV
characters. Several authors have reported                                                        responses for the various groups of yeast-      of selected volatile compounds, belonging
                                                                                                 derived volatile compounds to DAP               to the chemical classes of Figure 3, and
                                                                                                 supplementation arises from the fact that       DAP supplementation is illustrated. It
                                                                                                 each group of volatiles is derived from a       appears clear then that the range of
                                                                                                 different metabolic pathway, each of which       variations potentially introduced by DAP
Concentration of yeast aroma compounds

                                                                                                 respond        differently     to    DAP
                                                                                                 supplementation. However, from a
                                                                                                                                                                  120
                                         Higher alcohols                                         practical point of view, understanding the                                 Isoamyl alcohol
                                                                                                                                                                            Ethyl octanoate
                                                                                                 potential of DAP supplementation as a tool                       100       Isoamyl acetate
                                                                                                                                                                            Ethyl 3-methylbutanoate
                                                                                                 to modulate wine sensory characteristics                             80    Ethyl acetate
                                                                                                                                               Odour Activity Value

                                         Ethyl acetate
                                                                                                 cannot be based simply on compositional
                                                                                                                                                                      60
                                         Acetate esters                                          data. The various volatiles or groups of
                                                                 Fatty acids
                                                                 ethyl esters
                                                                                                 volatiles illustrated in Figure 3 occur in                           40

                                                                                Branched chain   wine over an extremely broad range of                                20
                                                                                     esters
                                                                                                 concentrations. However, this figure does
                                                                                                                                                                      0
                                              100          200    300           400        500   not represent the actual quantitative                                     100      200        300     400    500
                                                                  YAN
                                                                                                 relationship between different chemical                                                        YAN
Figure 3. Relationship between initial YAN                                                       species. For example, higher alcohols,        Figure 4. Theoretical relationship between initial
concentration and final concentration of                                                                                                       YAN concentration and Odour Activity Values of
volatile compounds after fermentation.                                                           characterised by herbaceous, fusel-like       selected yeast-derived aroma compounds.

W I N E I N D U S T R Y J O U R N A L > V O L 2 2 N O 6 > N O V E M B E R / D E C E M B E R 2 0 0 7 > w w w.w i n e b i z . c o m . a u                                                                        27
A W R I                            R E P O R T

in the concentration of acetates and fatty acid ethyl esters (isoamyl                                                         These results highlight the complexity of predicting wine
acetate and ethyl octanoate are used as reference compounds for                                                             aroma from compositional data. They also underline the
these two classes) can have a dramatic impact on the volatile                                                               importance of measuring YAN and adding the appropriate
character of wine, whereas variations in compounds such as higher                                                           amount of DAP, if necessary, before or during fermentation in
alcohols (isoamyl alcohol), although quantitatively extremely large,                                                        order to reduce the potentially negative effects that inadequate
are likely to have a limited impact. Although it has to be stressed                                                         or excessive DAP supplementation can have on wine aroma.
that OAVs only give a projection of the potential of a given                                                                Particularly, the risk of excessive formation of ethyl acetate has
compound to contribute to the overall aroma of a wine, the trends                                                           to be considered as this ester is relatively stable during wine
shown in Figure 4 provide a good indication of which one of the                                                             ageing, compared with other acetate and ethyl fatty acid esters,
compositional changes associated with DAP supplementation is                                                                which tend to decrease significantly after several months of
likely to have a greater impact on wine aroma.                                                                              bottle storage.
                                                                                                                            3.2 Implications of nitrogen for red wine fermentations
IMPLICATIONS OF NITROGEN FOR WINE FERMENTATIONS
                                                                                                                            More recently, researchers at the AWRI have investigated the
3.1 Implications of nitrogen for white wine fermentations                                                                   effect of DAP supplementation on the volatile composition of
Interestingly, the results obtained in various winemaking trials                                                            Shiraz wine (Ugliano et al. 2007). It is generally believed that
conducted at the AWRI with sub-optimal YAN juices have                                                                      the conditions normally adopted for the production of red wine
indicated that, under typical winemaking conditions, DAP                                                                    (i.e. higher temperatures, aeration of the fermenting must
supplementation is an extremely powerful tool for modulating                                                                during cap management operations, extraction of YAN and
the production of esters which, based on the previous discussion,                                                           other nutrients from skin during maceration) render
are probably the most sensorially-interesting group of                                                                      fermentations less susceptible to slow or stuck fermentations,
compounds generated during fermentation. Figures 5 and 6                                                                    even when YAN concentrations approach the sub-optimal
show the variations in volatile compounds and the sensory                                                                   range. Nevertheless, several surveys have shown that YAN levels
profi le of Chardonnay wines made at different DAP                                                                            in red grapes can be well below optimal (Gockowiak and
concentrations. In good agreement with the trends shown in                                                                  Henschke 1992; Butzke 1998; Nicolini et al. 2004; Ugliano
Figure 3, DAP had a positive effect on ester production, while                                                               and Henschke, unpublished data).
it lowered the formation of higher alcohols. However, the wines                                                                Although during red wine fermentations YAN deficiencies are
obtained with moderate nitrogen supplementation of the juice                                                                likely to have a more moderate effect on fermentation kinetics,
were preferred by panellists compared with those obtained                                                                   they can still negatively affect the formation of important aroma
without or with high DAP addition. This preference might be                                                                 compounds. From the results of a trial which was carried out on
due to a combination of higher acetates, ethyl fatty acid ester                                                             a low YAN Shiraz must (YAN 100mg/L) with S. cerevisiae
concentrations and moderate levels of ethyl acetate, the latter                                                             AWRI 796, it is again clearly evident that DAP supplementation
being associated with unwanted, solvent-like characteristics                                                                is a powerful tool for modulating the volatile composition of red
when present at very high concentrations. DAP addition to low                                                               wine. Th is confirms some of the trends observed during
YAN juices also suppresses the production of H 2 S and                                                                      experiments with model substrates and white grape juices. As
mercaptans by many wine yeasts, which although not quantified                                                                can be seen in Figure 7, DAP supplementation resulted in higher
in this study, no doubt contributed to the preference of the                                                                production of ethyl fatty acid esters and acetate esters, while
moderate YAN wines. The impact of DAP addition on the                                                                       higher alcohols were scarcely affected.
production of fruity thiols, such as 4MMP, 3MH and 3MHA,
still needs to be determined.
                                                                                                                                                                                     Banana
                                                                                                                                                                  Wet cardboard       4           Fruit ester
                     12,000              160mg/L YAN                320mg/L YAN               480mg/L YAN                                                                           3.5
                                                                                                                                                              Sweaty                 3                          Artificial grape
                                                                                                                                                                                    2.5
                     10,000
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      More preferred aromas
                                                                                                                           Less preferred aromas

                                                                                                                                                                                     2
                                                                                                                                                        Cheesy                      1.5                                Musk
                     8000
Concentration µg/L

                                                                                                                                                                                     1
                                                                                                                                                                                    0.5
                     6000                                                                                                                          Acetic                            0                                     Floral

                     4000                                                                                                                          Nail lacquer                                                        Stewed fruit

                     2000
                                                                                                                                                            Stale beer                                          Tropical

                         0                                                                                                                                               Honey                    Citrus
                              Fatty acids ethyl esters   Acetates          Ethyl acetate/10    Higher alcohols/100                                                                Bruised apple
Figure 5. Volatile compounds of wines obtained from a low YAN                                                             Figure 6. Sensory characteristics of wines obtained from a low YAN
(160mg/L) Chardonnay juice supplemented with two increasing                                                               (160mg/L) Chardonnay juice (green line) supplemented with two
concentrations of DAP, to a final YAN of 320mg/L and 480mg/L,                                                             increasing concentrations of DAP, to a final YAN of 320mg/L (red line)
respectively. Fermentations were carried out at 18ºC using S. cerevisiae                                                  and 480mg/L (blue line), respectively. Fermentations were carried out at
AWRI 796.                                                                                                                 18ºC using S. cerevisiae AWRI 796.

28                                                                                                 w w w.w i n e b i z . c o m . a u > N O V E M B E R / D E C E M B E R 2 0 0 7 > V O L 2 2 N O 6 > W I N E I N D U S T R Y J O U R N A L
A W R I      R E P O R T

  Preliminary results also indicated that YAN supplementation                                                       excessively estery wines. Similar effects can be expected in other
of must can have an impact on red wine colour composition.                                                          varieties, excepting for those varieties that depend on thiols, for
Analytical parameters related to colour intensity and hue were                                                      which no information is presently available. Clearly, more wine
indeed found to vary with DAP supplementation (Ugliano et al.                                                       sensory studies need to be undertaken to better understand the
2007). The factors responsible for this effect are currently being                                                   effects of must YAN and amino acid profile on wine flavour.
investigated at the AWRI. The effect might be ascribable to                                                            A red wine trial is currently in progress to understand better
various aspects of yeast metabolism that are known to modulate                                                      the impacts of managing nitrogen in the vineyard compared
wine colour and phenolics composition. Factors include                                                              with that in the winery on wine flavour and quality. This research
variations in the rate of ethanol production, absorption of                                                         can be expected to provide grapegrowers and winemakers with
anthocyanins on yeast cell walls (Morata et al. 2003) or                                                            better information for optimising wine style and quality
reactions with yeast-derived metabolites such as pyruvic acid                                                       according to consumer preferences and other desired outcomes.
and acetaldehyde to form pigmented polymers (Romero and
Bakker 1999).                                                                                                       ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
                                                                                                                    We thank our many colleagues for supporting this project,
CONCLUSION                                                                                                          especially Tracey Siebert and Dimitra Capone for help with
This work shows that the concentration of yeast assimilable                                                         analysis of fermentation volatiles; Mariola Kwiatkowski and
nitrogen is not only important for ensuring that adequate yeast                                                     Meagan Mercurio for analysis of phenolic compounds; Kate
growth and fermentation kinetics are achieved, but also can                                                         Lattey, Belinda Bramley and Dr Leigh Francis for carrying out the
affect the production of the major metabolites arising from                                                          sensory analyses; Industry Development and Support and
sugar fermentation. Whereas ethanol concentration is little                                                         Analytical Service team members for help with chemical analyses;
affected, that of glycerol and various carboxylic acids can be                                                       and Dr Paul Chambers, Dr Cristian Varela and Biosciences team
markedly modulated. These changes are likely to affect wine                                                          members for many helpful discussions. Professor Francisco
flavour. Most importantly, however, is the finding that YAN                                                           Carrau, of Uruguay, and visiting scientists Drs Diego Torrea and
can strongly influence production of some of the volatile                                                            Mar Vilanova, from Spain, have made important contributions to
metabolites, especially the acetate and ethyl esters, which are                                                     this project. We are especially grateful to Mike Farmilo, of Boar’s
known to be positive to wine aroma when in balance. The                                                             Rock winery, for supplying a large number of juice samples and
impact of higher alcohols, which can be negative when present                                                       donating must for the Shiraz fermentation trials, and Russell
in high concentration, can also be modulated by YAN. These                                                          Johnstone and Inca Pearce, of Orlando Wines, and Louisa Rose
various yeast metabolites were also found to vary in red wine                                                       and Simon Dillon of The Yalumba Wine Company, for supplying
fermentations, suggesting that, as in white wines, must YAN                                                         white wine juices. Current work on nitrogen management also
can affect the development of wine flavour. Our preliminary                                                           involves collaboration with Dr Sally-Jean Bell and Marcel Essling.
data suggest that wine colour and phenolics composition can                                                         Rae Blair is thanked for her editorial assistance. This project is
also be influenced by YAN.                                                                                           supported by Australia’s grapegrowers and winemakers through
  Overall, these results suggest that, at least for Chardonnay,                                                     their investment agency, the Grape and Wine Research and
the flavour and style of wine is dramatically modulated by the                                                       Development Corporation, with matching funds from the
initial YAN concentration of the grape juice. Low YAN level                                                         Australian Government. The AWRI is a member of the Wine
juices favour the production of more complex wines with less                                                        Innovation Cluster.
fruity aromas, whereas moderate YAN levels produce cleaner
and fruitier wines. However, high YAN levels can lead to                                                            REFERENCES
                                                                                                                    1 Albers, E.; Larsson, C.; Liden, G.; Niklasson, C. & Gustafsson, L. (1996)
                                                                                                                      Influence of the nitrogen source on Saccharomyces cerevisiae anaerobic
             10,000
                                                                                                                      growth and product formation. Appl. Env. Microbiol. 62: 3187-3195.
                                                                                                                    2 Albers, E.; Lidén, G.; Larsson, C.; Gustafsson, L. (1998) Anaerobic redox
                     9000          100mg/L YAN                250mg/L YAN               400mg/L YAN                   balance and nitrogen metabolism in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Recent Res.
                                                                                                                      Develop. Microbiol. 2: 253-279; 1998.
                     8000
                                                                                                                    3 Äyräpää, T. (1971) Biosynthetic formation of higher alcohols by yeast.
                     7000                                                                                             Dependence on the nitrogenous nutrient level of the medium. J. Inst.
Concentration µg/L

                                                                                                                      Brew. 77: 266-276.
                     6000
                                                                                                                    4 Bauer, F.F.; Pretorius, I.S. (2000). Yeast stress response and fermentation
                     5000                                                                                             efficiency: how to survive the making of wine – A review. S. Afr. J. Enol.
                                                                                                                      Vitic. 21: 27-51.
                     4000                                                                                           5 Bell, S.-J.; Henschke, P.A. (2005) Implications of nitrogen nutrition for
                     3000                                                                                             grapes, fermentation and wine. Aust. J. Grape Wine Res. 11: 242-295.
                                                                                                                    6 Blateyron, L.; Ortiz-Julien, A; Sablayrolles, J.M. (2003) Stuck
                     2000                                                                                             fermentations: oxygen and nitrogen requirements – importance of
                     1000                                                                                             optimising their addition. Aust. N.Z. Grapegrower Winemaker 478: 73-79.
                                                                                                                    7 Butzke, C. (1998). Survey of Yeast Assimilable Nitrogen status in musts
                       0                                                                                              from California, Oregon, and Washington. Am. J. Enol. Vitic. 49: 220-224.
                            Fatty acids ethyl esters   Acetates      Ethyl acetate     Higher alcohols/100          8 Carrau, F.M. (2003) Characterization of yeast in relation to the ability to
                                                                                                                      utilize nitrogen – Studies of aroma compounds. PhD thesis, Universidad
Figure 7. Volatile compounds of wines obtained from low YAN (100mg/L
                                                                                                                      de la Republica, Uruguay.
YAN) Shiraz grapes supplemented with two increasing concentrations of
                                                                                                                    9 Coulter, A.D.; Godden, P.W.; Pretorius, I.S. (2004) Succinic acid-how is it
DAP, to a final YAN of 250mg/L and 400mg/L respectively.                                                              formed, what is its effect on titratable acidity, and what factors influence its
Fermentations were carried out at 22ºC using S. cerevisiae AWRI 796,                                                  concentration in wine? Aust. N.Z. Wine Ind. J. 19: 16-20, 22-25.
with cap plunging three times per day.

W I N E I N D U S T R Y J O U R N A L > V O L 2 2 N O 6 > N O V E M B E R / D E C E M B E R 2 0 0 7 > w w w.w i n e b i z . c o m . a u                                                          29
A W R I      R E P O R T

10 Dambergs, R.G.; Kambouris, B.; Cynkar, W.; Janik, L.J.; Cozzolino, D.;                        Conference, 7-11 October 2001, Adelaide SA. Australian Wine Industry
   Henschke, P.A.; Gishen, M. (2005) A comparison of near infrared and                           Technical Conference Inc., Adelaide SA 128-139.
   mid-infrared spectroscopy for the analysis of yeast-assimilable nitrogen in              20   Henschke, P.A. (1996) Hydrogen sulphide production by yeast during
   grape juice. Blair, R.J.; Williams, P.J.; Pretorius, I.S. (eds.) Proceedings of               fermentation. Proceedings Eleventh international oenological symposium,
   the twelfth Australian wine industry technical conference; 24-29 July                         Sopron, Hungary (International Association for Winery Technology and
   2004; Melbourne, Vic. Australian Wine Industry Technical Conference                           Management: Breisach, Germany) pp. 83-102.
   Inc., Adelaide SA: 334.                                                                  21   Henschke, P.A.; Jiranek, V. (1993) Yeasts – metabolism of nitrogen
11 Diaz-Maroto, M.C.; Schneider, R.; Baumes, R. (2005) Formation                                 compounds. In: Wine Microbiology and Biotechnology. Fleet, G.H. (ed.)
   pathways of ethyl esters of branched short-chain fatty acids during wine                      (Harwood Academic Publishers: Chur, Switzerland) pp. 77-164.
   aging. J. Agric Food Chem., 53, 3503-3509.                                               22   Hernández-Orte, P.; Ibarz, M.J.; Cacho, J.; Ferreira V. (2005) Effect of the
12 Duan, W.; Roddick, F.A.; Higgins, V.J.; Rogers, P.J. (2004) A parallel                        addition of ammonium and amino acids to must of Airen variety on
   analysis of H 2 S and SO2 formation by brewing yeast in response to                           aromatic composition and sensory properties of the obtained wines. Food
   sulphur-containing amino acids and ammonium ions. J. Am. Soc. Brew.                           Chem. 89: 163-174.
   Chem. 62: 35-41.                                                                         23   Hernández-Orte, P.; Bely, M.; Cacho, J.; Ferreira, V. (2006) Impact of
13 Dukes, B.C.; Butzke, C.E. (1998) Rapid determination of primary amino                         ammonium additions on volatile acidity, ethanol, and aromatic compounds
   acids in grape juice using an o-phthaldialdehyde/N-acetyl-L-cysteine                          production by different Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains during fermentation
   spectrophotometric assay. Am. J. Enol. Vitic. 49: 125-134.                                    in controlled synthetic media. Aust. J. Grape. Wine Res. 12: 150-160.
14 Eglinton, J.; Siebert, T.; Kwaitkowski, M.; Francis, L.; Henschke P. (2005)              24   Ingledew, W.M.; Magnus, C.A.; Sosulski, F.W. (1987) Influence of oxygen
   Compositional and sensory implications of practical strategies for ensuring                   on proline utilization during wine fermentation. Am. J. Enol. Vitic. 38:
   complete fermentation with non-conventional yeast. Blair, R.J.; Williams,                     246-248.
   P.J.; Pretorius, I.S.(eds.) Proceedings of the twelfth Australian wine                   25   Morata, A.; Gomez-Cordoves, M.C.; Suberviola, J.; Bartolomé, B.;
   industry technical conference; 24-29 July 2004; Melbourne, Vic.                               Colomo, B.; Suárez, J.A. (2003) Adsorption of anthocyanins by cell walls
   Australian Wine Industry Technical Conference Inc., Adelaide SA: 288.                         during the fermentation of red wines. J. Agric. Food. Chem. 51,
15 Filipe-Ribeiro, L.; Mendes-Faia, A. (2007) Validation and comparison of                       4084-4088.
   analytical methods used to evaluate the nitrogen status of grape juice.                  26   Nicolini, G.; Larcher, R.; Versini, G. (2004) Status of yeast assimilable
   Food Chem. 100: 1272-1277.                                                                    nitrogen in Italian grape musts and effect of variety, ripening and vintage.
16 Gockowiak, H.; Henschke, P.A. (1992) Nitrogen composition of grape                            Vitis, 43: 89-96.
   juice and implications for fermentation: results of a survey made in N-E                 27   Osborne, J.P.; Edwards, C.G. (2006) Inhibition of malolactic fermentation
   Victoria. Aust Grapegrower Winemaker 340: 131, 133-138.                                       by Saccharomyces during alcoholic fermentation under low- and high-
17 Gump, B.H.; Zoecklein, B.W.; Fugelsang, K.C.; Whiton, R.S. (2002)                             nitrogen conditions: a study in synthetic media. Aust. J. Grape Wine Res.
   Comparison of analytical methods for prediction of prefermentation                            12: 69-78.
   nutritional status of grape juice. Am. J. Enol. Vitic. 53: 325-329.                      28   Rapp, A.; Versini, G. (1991). Influence of nitrogen compounds in grapes
18 Guth, H. (1997) Quantitation and sensory studies of character impact                          on aroma compounds of wine. Proceedings of the International
   odorants of different white wines varieties. J. Agric. Food Chem., 45:                         Symposium on Nitrogen in Grapes and Wine. Davis USA: American
   3027-3032.                                                                                    Society for Enology and Viticulture, 156-164.
19 Guth, H.; Sies, A. (2002) Flavour of wines: Towards an understanding by                  29   Ribéreau-Gayon, J.; Dubourdieu, D.; Donéche, B.; Lonvaud, A. (2000)
   reconstitution experiments and an analysis of ethanol’s effect on odour                        Handbook of Enology, Volume 1: The microbiology of wines and
   activity of key compounds. Blair, R.J.; Williams, P.J.; Høj, P.B. (eds.).                     vinification. John Wiley & Sons Ltd: Chichester, UK.: 454.
   Proceedings of the eleventh Australian Wine Industry Technical                           30   Romero C.; Bakker, J. (1999) Interactions between grape anthocyanins and
                                                                                                 pyruvic acid, with effect of pH and acid concentration on anthocyanin
                                                                                                 composition and color in model systems. J. Agric. Food Chem. 47,
                                                                                                 3130-3139.
                                                                                            31   Shively, C.E.; Henick-Kling, T. (2001) Comparison of two procedures for
       GRAPEVINE GRAFTLINGS & ROOTLINGS                                                          assay of free amino nitrogen. Am. J. Enol. Vitic. 52: 400-401.
                                                                                            32   Smyth, H., Cozzolino, D., Herderich, M.J., Sefton, M.A.; Francis, I.L.
                                                                                                 (2005) Relating volatile composition to wine aroma: identification of key
     • Serving Australian Viticulture for over 50 years.                                         aroma compounds in Australian white wines. Blair, R.J.; Williams, P.J.;
                                                                                                 Pretorius, I.S. (eds.) Proceedings of the Twelfth Australian Wine Industry
     • VINA Accredited Nursery.                                                                  Technical Conference, Melbourne, Vic, 24-29 July 2004. Australian Wine
                                                                                                 Industry Technical Conference Inc., Adelaide SA: 31-33.
     • Vine Improvement sourced material.                                                   33   Sowalsky, R.A.; Noble, A.C. (1998) Comparison of the effects of
                                                                                                 concentration, pH and anion species on astringency and sourness of
     • Graftlings and rootlings supplied as dormant                                              organic acids. Chem. Senses 23: 343-349.
       12 month old field grown or 4 month/12 month old                                     34   Swiegers, J.H.; Francis, I.L.; Herderich, M.J.; Pretorius, I.S. (2006)
                                                                                                 Meeting consumer expectations through management in the vineyard and
       container grown in bio-degradable Plant Bands.
                                                                                                 winery: the choice of yeast for fermentation offers great potential to adjust
     • Hot water treated.                                                                        the aroma of Sauvignon Blanc wine. Aust. N.Z. Wine Ind. J. 21: 34-42.
                                                                                            35   Torrea, D.; Henschke P.A. (2004) Ammonium supplementation of grape
     • Trichoderma protected.                                                                    juice – effect on the aroma profi le of a Chardonnay wine. Tech. Rev. 150,
                                                                                                 59-63.
     • Taking orders now for 2008, 2009 and                                                 36   Torrea, D.; Siebert, T.; Liebich, B.; Ancin, C.; Francis, L.; Henschke, P.A.
       2010 requirements.                                                                        (2005) Effect of ammonium supplementation of a Chardonnay must on
                                                                                                 wine aroma. Blair, R.J.; Williams, P.J.; Pretorius, I.S. (eds.) Proceedings of
     • We also stock a full range of container grown                                             the Twelfth Australian Wine Industry Technical Conference, Melbourne,
       OLIVE, CITRUS, AVOCADO & PISTACHIO TREES.                                                 Vic,, 24-29 July 2004. Australian Wine Industry Technical Conference
                                                                                                 Inc., Adelaide, SA: 293.
                                                                                            37   Ugliano, M.; Siebert, T.; Capone, D.; Mercurio, M.; Henschke, P.A.
                                                                                                 (2007) Colour, aroma and fl avour compounds in Shiraz wine as affected by
                     Sunraysia Nurseries                                                         DAP addition before fermentation. Blair, R.J.; Williams, P.J.; Pretorius, I.
                 P.O. Box 45, Sturt Highway, Gol Gol, NSW 2738                                   S. (eds.) Proceedings of the thirteenth Australian Wine Industry Technical
                   Ph (03) 5024 8502 • Fax (03) 5024 8551                                        Conference, Adelaide, SA, 28 July-2 August 2007. Australian Wine
                    E-mail: sales@sunraysianurseries.com.au                                      Industry Technical Conference Inc. Adelaide, SA: in press.
                    Website: www.sunraysianurseries.com.au                                  38   Vilanova, M.; Ugliano, M.; Siebert, T.; Pretorius, I.J.; Henschke, P.A.
                                                                                                 (2007) Assimilable nitrogen utilization and production of volatile and non-
                                                                                                 volatile compounds in chemically defi ned medium by Saccharomyces
                                                                                                 cerevisiae wine strains. App. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 77: 145-157.
                                                                                            39   Wang, X.D.; Bohlscheid, J.C.; Edwards, C.G. (2003) Fermentative activity
                                                                                                 and production of volatile compounds by Saccharomyces grown in synthetic
                                                                                                 grape juice media deficient in assimilable nitrogen and/or pantothenic acid.
                         Growing for You                                                         J. Appl. Microbiol. 94: 349-359.
                               Since 1952

30                                                                  w w w.w i n e b i z . c o m . a u > N O V E M B E R / D E C E M B E R 2 0 0 7 > V O L 2 2 N O 6 > W I N E I N D U S T R Y J O U R N A L
You can also read