Plasma-Based and Laser Accelerators for High-Energy Physics - Ralph Assmann, DESY and INFN

Page created by Brent Harrison
 
CONTINUE READING
Plasma-Based and Laser Accelerators for High-Energy Physics - Ralph Assmann, DESY and INFN
Plasma-Based and Laser
          Accelerators
    for High-Energy Physics
            Ralph Assmann, DESY and INFN
              Edda Gschwendtner, CERN

EPS-HEP2021, Virtual at Hamburg, DESY, 26 – 30 July 2021

                      30 July 2021
Plasma-Based and Laser Accelerators for High-Energy Physics - Ralph Assmann, DESY and INFN
Follow-Up to European Strategy Particle Physics
Expert Panel “High Gradient: Plasma and Laser                 Mandate:
Accelerators”                                                 •    Develop a long-term roadmap for the next 30 years towards a
Follow-up Panel to Europ. Strategy for Particle Physics            HEP collider or other HEP applications.
Panel proposes roadmap for use in Particle Physcis            •    Develop milestones for the next 10 years taking explicitly into
Panel members:                                                     account the plans and needs in related scientific fields as well as
Chair: Ralph Assmann (DESY/INFN)                                   the capabilities and interests of the stakeholders.
Deputy Chair: Edda Gschwendtner (CERN)                        •    Establish key R&D needs matched to the existing and planned
Kevin Cassou (IN2P3/IJCLab), Sebastien Corde (IP Paris),           R&D facilities.
Laura Corner ( Liverpool), Brigitte Cros (CNRS UPSay),
Massimo Ferarrio (INFN), Simon Hooker (Oxford), Rasmus
                                                              •    Give options and scenarios for European activity level and
Ischebeck (PSI), Andrea Latina (CERN), Olle Lundh (Lund),          investment.
Patric Muggli (MPI Munich), Phi Nghiem (CEA/IRFU), Jens       •    Define deliverables until the next European strategy process in
Osterhoff (DESY), Tor Raubenheimer (SLAC), Arnd Specka             2026, which allow deciding on the continuation of this R&D line
(IN2PR/LLR), Jorge Vieira (IST), Matthew Wing (UCL).               for HEP.
Panel associated members:
Cameron Geddes (LBNL), Mark Hogan (SLAC)), Wei Lu
(Tsinghua U.) , Pietro Musumeci (UCLA)
                                                              Elaborate consultation process with 231 registered
                                                              participants, 3 townhall meetings, > 60 talks and
                                                  k
                             st giving a quick loo            inputs.
                           ju
    to li mited time: Talk
Due
                                                    R. Assmann, E. Gschwendtner                                                    2
Plasma-Based and Laser Accelerators for High-Energy Physics - Ralph Assmann, DESY and INFN
Plasma and Laser Accelerators: New Livingston Curve
                                Nobel prize Physics
                                2013 Englert/Higgs
                                                                  •   Examples of new ideas and solutions: RF,
                                                                      AG focusing, beta squeeze, stochastic
                                                                      cooling, polarized beams, super-
                                                                      conducting magnets/RF, advanced
                                                                      materials for vacuum/collimators, plasma
                                                                      / laser accelerators, …
                                                                  •   Particle physics in the driver seat for
                                                                      most of those developments

                                                 Nobel prize
                                                 Physics 2018

Accelerators are in a continuous technology innovation cycle to
be successful:
                                    R. Assmann, E. Gschwendtner                                            3
Plasma-Based and Laser Accelerators for High-Energy Physics - Ralph Assmann, DESY and INFN
Plasma and Laser Accelerator Principle
                            Damage limits for metallic walls in RF cavities limit accelerating fieldsà replace metal with plasmas or
                            dielectric materials à advance into the many GV/m regime à shorter acc. lengths à reduced cost?

                                                                                                                                   Lasers or THz pulses or e-
Illustration from EuPRAXIA, A. Ferran Pousa et al

                                                                                                                                   beams drive dielectric
                                                                                                                                   structures (e.g. Silicium)
                                                                                                                                   “Accelerator on a Chip” grant Moore
                                                                                                                                   foundation: Stanford, SLAC, University
                                                                                                                                   Erlangen, DESY, University Hamburg, PSI,
                                                                                                                                   EPFL, University Darmstadt, CST, UCLA

                                                                                                                                   AXSIS ERC Synergy Grant: DESY, Arizona SU

                                                                                     Options for driving plasma and dielectric structures (no klystrons at those frequencies):

                                                                                     • Lasers:          Industrially available, steep progress, path to low cost
                                                                                                        Limited energy per drive pulse (up to 50 J)
                                                                                     • e- bunch:        Short bunches (need µm) available, need long RF accelerator
                                                                                                        More energy per drive pulse (up to 500 J)
                                                           Tajima & Dawson 1979      • p+ bunch:        Only long (inefficient) bunches, need very long RF accelerator
                                                                                                        Maximum energy per drive pulse (up to 100,000 J)
                                                                         R. Assmann, E. Gschwendtner                                                                       4
Plasma-Based and Laser Accelerators for High-Energy Physics - Ralph Assmann, DESY and INFN
Shrinking the Size of Particle Physics Facility
                                                                                                             Added value
            RF Accelerators                                             400 m                   new Research Infrastructures due
> 30,000 operational – many serve for Health                                                    to compactness and cost-efficiency
                                                                                                bringing new capabilities to science,
        30 million Volt per meter                                                               institutes, hospitals, universities,
   RF: 90 years of success story for society                                                    industry, developing countries.

                                                                           60* m
         Plasma Accelerators                                                                                            5 GeV
     first user facility to be realized                                                                                example
   100,000 million Volt per meter
                                                                           *realisticdesign including all required
                                                                           infrastructure for powering, shielding, …

Can we shrink the Linear Collider, provide e- and e+ beams in the
  TeV energy regime and produce > 1034 cm-2 s-1 luminosity?
                                          R. Assmann, E. Gschwendtner                                                       5
Plasma-Based and Laser Accelerators for High-Energy Physics - Ralph Assmann, DESY and INFN
Can we shrink the Linear Collider?
         provide e- and e+ beams in the TeV energy regime and produce > 1034 cm-2 s-1 luminosity

                                                 TDR’s
                                                 published

                             FCC
                             Future Circular Collider
                             100 km, e+e-, pp TDR to be
                             Technical design to  be done out
                                               worked

                                                                                              from expert panel interim report
•   No fundamental show-stopper but a lot of R&D still required.
•   There can be very interesting and useful interim steps (non-linear QED, fixed target, dark matter, …)
•   Devil is in the details! Answer requires detailed simulation, calculations, R&D, designs and tests!
•   How and when can we arrive at readiness for for high energy particle physics, e.g. a TeV collider?
                                                                R. Assmann, E. Gschwendtner                                6
Plasma-Based and Laser Accelerators for High-Energy Physics - Ralph Assmann, DESY and INFN
Can we shrink the Linear Collider?
    provide e- and e+ beams in the TeV energy regime and produce > 1034 cm-2 s-1 luminosity

                                                                  from expert panel interim report
How and when can we arrive at readiness for for high
energy particle physics?       R. Assmann, E. Gschwendtner                                           7
Plasma-Based and Laser Accelerators for High-Energy Physics - Ralph Assmann, DESY and INFN
#3
     Input to Expert Panel                                                                Speaker
                                                                                          Paolo Tomassini
                                                                                                             Institute
                                                                                                             CNR-INO
                                                                                                                                   Country
                                                                                                                                   Italy
                                                                                                                                             Title
                                                                                                                                                                                        #2
                                                                                                                                             Ultra-low emittance round beams with multi-pulse
                                                                                                                                                                                                         Speaker
                                                                                                                                                                                                         Edward Snedden
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              Institute
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              STFC Daresbury
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Country
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    UK
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Title
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               High gradient acceleration at the CLARA Test Facility
                                                                                                                                             ionization injection schemes                                Allen Caldwell       MPI for Physics       Germany    Particle Physics possibilities with AWAKE-like
  See https://indico.cern.ch/event/1041900/                                               Markus Büscher     FZJ                   Germany   Polarized particle beams from laser-plasma                                       Munich                           technology
                                                                                                                                             accelerators
  and https://indico.cern.ch/event/1040116/                                               Max LaBerge        University of Texas   USA       Coherent transition radiation-based emittance
                                                                                                                                                                                                         Massimo Ferrario
                                                                                                                                                                                                         Moana Pittman
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              LNF/INFN
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              IJCLab, CNRS
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Italy
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    France
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               High quality beam-driven plasma acceleration and FEL
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               High intensity laser facility for High gradient accelerator
                                                                                                             at Austin                       diagnostics                                                                                                       development

Speaker          Institute        Country    Title
                                                                               #1         Rafal Zgadzaj      University of Texas   USA       Optical probe of energy dissipation from e-beam driven      Robert Rossmanith                          Germany    Preferred machine for testing a laser plasma
                                                                                                             at Austin                       plasma wakes                                                                                                      accelerator at CERN: CERN eSPS
Dave Newbold     STFC             UK         Particle Physics Strategy and Accelerator    Christopher Doss   University of         USA       Strong electron beam focusing with passive,                 Wei Lu               Tsinghua University   China      CEPC high energy plasma injector and PWFA driven
                 Rutherford                  R&D                                                             Colorado Boulder                underdense plasma lenses                                                                                          coherent light source based on SXFEL facility
                                                                                          Tong Zhou          LBNL                  USA       Coherent combination of high-power fiber lasers for         Francois Lemery      DESY                  Germany    SRF-based collinear beam-driven acceleration for a
Ralph            DESY, INFN,      Germany,   Introduction to the Expert Panel on High-
                                                                                                                                             laser-plasma-based collider applications                                                                          future TeV collider
Assmann, Edda    CERN             Italy,     Gradient Acceleration (Plasma/Laser)
Geschwendtner                     CERN                                                    Franck Falcoz      Amplitude             France    Roadmap for high average power ultrashort laser             Florian Burkart      DESY                  Germany    150 MeV S-Band injector linac with high stability and
                                                                                                             Technologies                                                                                                                                      ultra-short electron bunches¶
Andrea Latina    CERN             CERN       Linear Colliders - Plans and Advanced        Andreas Maier      DESY                  Germany   High average power laser-plasma acceleration                Guoxing Xia          University of         UK         Plasma beam dump and its implementation in future
                                             Accelerators Opportunities                                                                                                                                                       Manchester                       colliders
                                                                                          Roman Walczak      University of Oxford UK         MP-LWFA to improve LPA repetition rate and efficiency
                                                                                                                                             / European Network for Novel Acceleraetors                  Fahim Habib          Strathclyde           UK         Plasma photocathode HEP R&D
Frank            CERN             CERN       Circular Collider - Plans and Advanced
                                                                                                                                             (EuroNNAc)                                                                       University
Zimmermann                                   Accelerator Opportunities
                                                                                          Leonida Antonio    CNR-INO               Italy     Towards PW scale laser driver with 100 Hz / Update on       Viacheslav Kubytskyi IJCLab, CNRS          France     Plasma target development for PALLAS project
Matthew Wing     University       UK         First Physics Experiments with Advanced      Gizzi                                              the design of a kHz-KW laser driver for plasma
                                                                                                                                                                                                         Alban Sublet         CERN                  CERN       AWAKE scalable plasma sources R&D at CERN
                 College London              Accelerator Concepts                                                                            acceleration
                                                                                                                                                                                                         Thomas Heinemann     Strathclyde           UK         Hybrid plasma wakefield accelerators as test-beds for
                                                                                          Simon Hooker       University of Oxford UK         Low-loss, metre-scale plasma channels for high-
Beate            DESY             Germany    Electron-Photon Based HEP Experiments -                                                                                                                                          University                       HEP building blocks
                                                                                                                                             repetition rate plasma accelerators
Heinemann                                    Plans and Advanced Accelerator                                                                                                                              Christelle Bruni     IJCLab, CNRS          France     High peak current electron beam transport and
                                             Opportunities                                Wim Leemans        DESY                  Germany   Strategy for enabling plasma-based accelerators to
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               diagnostics
                                                                                                                                             drive first particle-physics applications
Daniel Schulte   CERN             CERN       Target Parameters for Typical HEP Relevant                                                                                                                  Jerome Faure         LOA, CNRS             France     High repetition rate laser-plasma acceleration
                                                                                          Antonio Falone     LNF/INFN              Italy     EuPRAXIA - Proposal for a distributed research facility
                                             Beams                                                                                           towards the realization of a FEL plasma based               Maxence Thevenet     DESY                  Germany    Multi-physics simulations and plasma accelerators
                                                                                                                                             accelerator, organization, current status and outlook       Arnaud Beck          LLR, CNRS             France     The importance of software engineering for PIC
Erik Adli        University of    Norway     Collider Concepts with Plasma: Where to
                                                                                          Claudio Emma       SLAC                  USA       Light-source applications of advanced accelerators                                                                simulations
                 Oslo                        Go and Required Features for e+/e-, gg,
                                             fixed target,...                                                                                                                                            Ricardo Fonseca      IST Lisbon            Portugal   OSIRIS 2030: Strategy for future plasma-based
                                                                                          Sebastien Meuren   SLAC                  USA       Exploring the fully no-perturbative regime of QED at a
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               acceleration modeling
                                                                                                                                             Future Linear Collider
Carl Schroeder   LBNL             USA        Laser-Driven Plasma Wakefield Accelerators                                                                                                                  Jean-Luc Vay         LBNL                  USA        Open-source simulation ecosystem for laptop to
                                                                                          Spencer Gessner    SLAC                  USA       Towards an integrated design study for a Plasma Linear
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Exascale modeling of high-gradient accelerators
Jens Osterhoff   DESY             Germany    Beam-Driven Plasma Wakefied Accelerators                                                        Collider / Positron plasma wakefield acceleration
                                                                                                                                             research at FACET-II                                        Denys Bondar         Kharkiv Institute     Ukraine    Some Aspects of Laser Wakefield Acceleration of Self-
Rasmus           PSI              Switzer-   Dielectrics Accelerators and Other                                                                                                                                               Physics and                      injected Electron Bunch in a Metallic-Density Electron
                                                                                          Mark Hogan         SLAC                  USA       Plasma wakefield acceleration at FACET-II / GARD
Ischebeck                         land       Advanced Concepts                                                                                                                                                                Technology                       Plasma
                                                                                                                                             beam test facilities in the US
                                                                                                                                                                                                         Gianluca Sarri       Queen's University    UK         Plasma-based positron sources R&D: current status and
Jorge Vieira     IST Lisbon       Portugal   Theory and Simulations                       Richard d’Arcy     DESY                  Germany   High-average power beam driven plasma acceleration
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              Belfast                          next steps
                                                                                          Cedric Thaury      LOA, CNRS             France    Increase of the energy gain in a laser-plasma               Giuseppe Torrisi     INFN                  Italy      CW collinear hollow-core scheme for Dielectric Laser
Pietro           UCLA             USA        Snowmass Frontier on Advanced
                                                                                                                                             accelerator stage                                                                                                 Accelerators (DLAs)
Musumeci                                     Accelerators (AF6 Coordinator)
                                                                                          Enrica Chiadroni   LNF/INFN              Italy     High beam quality R&D at SPARC_LAB                          Frank Mayet, Willi   DESY                  Germany    Dielectric Structures as Diagnostics and Beam
                                                                                          Carl Lindstroem    DESY                  Germany   Staging of plasma accelerators for high-energy, stability   Kuropka                                               Manipulation Devices
Panel organized 3 Townhall Meetings                                                                                                          and beam quality                                            Joel England         SLAC                  USA        Structure-Based Laser-Driven Accelerators
                                                                                          Carlo Benedetti    LBNL                  USA       Ion motion, hosing suppression and beam quality             Guillaume Martinet   IPN Orsay             France     Dielectric wave guide for short electron beam
for input on relevant activitiesà 230                                                                                                        preservation in plasma-based accelerators                                                                         acceleration and compression at THz frequencies

participants in consultation process                                                      Phi Nghiem         CEA         R. Assmann,
                                                                                                                             France     E. Gschwendtner
                                                                                                                                    EuPRAXIA solutions and plans for a plasma-based                      Steven Patrick       Lancaster University UK          mm-wave and THz acceleration            8
                                                                                                                                             accelerator with high beam quality                          Jamison
Plasma-Based and Laser Accelerators for High-Energy Physics - Ralph Assmann, DESY and INFN
R. Assmann, E. Gschwendtner   9
Plasma-Based and Laser Accelerators for High-Energy Physics - Ralph Assmann, DESY and INFN
R. Assmann, E. Gschwendtner   10
https://www.esfri.eu/latest-esfri-news/new-ris-roadmap-2021
Press Release ESFRI 30.6.21

  R. Assmann, E. Gschwendtner
Main Challenges for Particle Physics Use Reviewed
Electron beam with collider quality                                    Conceptual design very compact collider
  1-100 GV/m acceleration, 15000 nC/s charge                         with physics case, self-consistent machine parameter set,
  delivered, sub-micron transverse emittances,                        realistic assessment of feasibility issues, performance,
    10-4 rel. energy spread, spin polarization.                                             size and cost.
                                                                                                                  Goal 1
Deliverables: on injectors, numerical simulations,                    Deliverables on a coordinated international design study,
    repetition rate, efficiency, beam loading,                          including beam delivery, luminosity and interaction
 emittance preservation, energy spread control,                                    region design were proposed.
     polarization, staging, … were proposed.

                                                                         Intermediate steps towards a particle
                                                                              physics collider and synergy
 Solution for positron acceleration                                      with progress in photon science and lower energy
  with parameters similar to electron bunches.                                              applications.
                                                                                                                  Goal 2
Deliverables: on numerical simulations, proof-of-                       Deliverables for intermediate implementation steps
      principle experiments were proposed.                                                 were proposed.

                                                  R. Assmann, E. Gschwendtner                                                13
Feasibility, Pre-CDR                            Technical                                                                         Integrat
                                                            High Gradient
        Study                                  Demonstration
                                                    Plasma and Laser Accelerators                                                    Outrea
                                                                            Accelerator R&D Roadmap Pillars
Scope: 1st international, coor-         Scope: Demonstration of critical                                                   Synergy and Integ
dinated study for self-consistent       feasibility
                                         Feasibility, Pre-CDR
                                                                  parameters Technical    for e+e-                         fits for and
                                                                                                                          Integration          &         syner
analysis of novel technologies          collider     Studyand 1st HEP applications Demonstration                           science
                                                                                                                             Outreach fields                (e
                                                st
                                       Scope: 1 international, coor-          Scope: Demonstration of critical      Synergy and Integration: Bene-
and their particle physics reach,       Concept:               Prioritisedfeasibility
                                       dinated study for self-consistent
                                       analysis   of novel technologies            listandparameters
                                                                              collider     1ofHEP R&D
                                                                                             st
                                                                                                              + -
                                                                                                        for e e
                                                                                                   applications
                                                                                                                    fits forbiology,
                                                                                                                             and synergy withmaterials,
                                                                                                                                                 other
                                                                                                                    science fields (e.g. structural
intermediate HEP steps, collider        that can              becollider
                                                                      performed
                                       and their particle physics reach,
                                       intermediate    HEP steps,             that can beat      exist-
                                                                              Concept: Prioritised list of R&D
                                                                                            performed   at exist-
                                                                                                                           and
                                                                                                                    biology,        projects
                                                                                                                             materials, lasers, health) (e.g. E
                                                                                                                    and projects (e.g. EuPRAXIA, …)
feasibility, performance, quanti-       ing,cost-size-benefit
                                       tative     planned             R&D infrastructures
                                       feasibility, performance, quanti-
                                                                 analysis
                                                                              ing, planned R&D infrastructures
                                                                              in national, European, interna-              Access:            Establishin
                                                                                                                    Access: Establishing framework
                                                                                                                    for well-defined  access to  distri-
tative cost-size-benefit analysis       in(mainnational,
                                                  concepts included) European,
                                       Concept: Comparative paper stu-
                                       dy                                     Milestones: interna-
                                                                              tional landscape
                                                                                                  -
                                                                                           HQ e beam by 2026,
                                                                                                                    buted accelerator R&D land-
                                                                                                                    scape for well-defined ac

Concept: Comparative paper stu-        etional        landscape                                                            buted technology accelerato
                                                                                      +
                                                                              HQ e beam by 2032, 15 kHz
                                       Milestones: Report high energy                                               Innovation: Compact accelerator
                                        -        +
                                           and e linac      module case       high eff. beam and power              and laser                 spin-offs
                                       studies, report physics case(s)        sources by 2037 (sustainability)      and synergies with industry
dy (main concepts included)             Milestones: HQ e beam
                                       Deliverable:   Feasibility and  pre- -            byTechnical
                                                                              Deliverable:      2026, readiness            scape
                                                                                                                    Training:  Involvement and edu-
                                       CDR report in 2026 for Euro-           level (TRL) report in 2026 for Eu-    cation of next generation engi-
Milestones: Report high energy          HQnational
                                       pean,       e+ decision
                                                          beam    makers by 2032,           15decision
                                                                              ropean, national      kHz  makers     neers Innovation:
                                                                                                                           and scientists              Compa
e- and e+ linac module case             high eff. beam and power                                                           and laser techno
studies, report physics case(s)         sources by 2037 (sustainability)                                                   and synergies with
Deliverable: Feasibility and pre-       Deliverable: Technical readiness                                                   Training: Involvem
CDR report in 2026 for Euro-            level (TRL) report in 2026 for Eu-                                                 cation of next ge
pean, national decision makers          ropean, national decision makers                                                   neers and scientist
                                    R. Assmann, E. Gschwendtner                                                                              14
2021    2022           2023           2024          2025    2026    2027   2028      2029   2030   2031    2032   2033   2034   2035
Development of programs and computing infrastructure
for high energy S2E simulations (Exascale, …)
Comparative case study: high energy electron linac, high
rep rate limits
Milestone report: Simulation 15 GeV, multi-stage electron                                                                       Pre-CDR / feasibility study, paper work,
                                                                                                 Report
accelerator, cost and footprint                                                                                                 findings listed - no priorisation and no
Very compact collider concepts, IR challenges and                                 Preparation:   Physics                        down-selection of topics yet
                                                                                  physics case
opportunities, polarization, round vs flat                                                        case

                                                                   Preparation:
Comparative case study: high energy positron linac                 theory , sim

Comparative case study: low energy electron linac

Conceptual design low energy HEP facility, intermediate                                          Preparation:
                                                                                                 physics case
test facility
Comparative study beam and laser drivers, efficiency,
transformer ratios
Deliverable: Comparative Feasibility Report for HEP (pre-
                                                                                                                       Report   Decision point
CDR)
Conceptual design study very compact collider, low energy
                                                                                                                                                               CDR
HEP, intermediate facility
Technical design study very compact collider, low energy
HEP, intermediate facility

                                                                                  R. Assmann, E. Gschwendtner                                                                        15
Technical                                       Integration            &
                                                                     High Gradient
    Demonstration                                       Outreach
                                                           Plasma and Laser Accelerators
                                                                Accelerator R&D Roadmap Pillars
Scope: Demonstration of critical         Synergy and Integration: Bene-
feasibility parameters for e+e-          fits      for and
                                          Feasibility,       Pre-CDR   synergy with              other
                                                                                         Technical                       Integration &
collider and 1st HEP applications        science      Studyfields           (e.g.        structural
                                                                                    Demonstration                          Outreach
                                                 st
                                        Scope: 1 international, coor-          Scope: Demonstration of critical     Synergy and Integration: Bene-

Concept: Prioritised list of R&D         biology,
                                        dinated   study for materials,
                                                            self-consistent
                                        analysis of novel technologies
                                                                              lasers,         health)
                                                                               feasibility parameters for e e
                                                                                             st
                                                                               collider and 1 HEP applications
                                                                                                              + -
                                                                                                                    fits for and synergy with other
                                                                                                                    science fields (e.g. structural

that can be performed at exist-          and projects (e.g. EuPRAXIA,
                                        and their particle physics reach,
                                        intermediate HEP steps, collider
                                                                               Concept: Prioritised…) list of R&D
                                                                               that can be performed at exist-
                                                                                                                    biology, materials, lasers, health)
                                                                                                                    and projects (e.g. EuPRAXIA, …)
                                        feasibility, performance, quanti-
ing, planned R&D infrastructures         Access:
                                        tative               Establishing
                                               cost-size-benefit analysis             framework
                                                                               ing, planned R&D infrastructures
                                                                               in national,  European, interna-
                                                                                                                    Access: Establishing framework
                                                                                                                    for well-defined access to distri-
                                                                               tional landscape
in national, European, interna-         Concept: Comparative paper stu-
                                         for
                                        dy (mainwell-defined
                                                   concepts included)       access
                                                                               Milestones: to
                                                                                            HQ edistri-
                                                                                                  -
                                                                                                  beam by 2026,
                                                                                                                    buted accelerator R&D land-
                                                                                                                    scape

tional landscape
                                                                                      +

                                        ebuted
                                            and e linacaccelerator             highR&D eff. beam land-
                                        Milestones: Report high energy         HQ e beam by 2032, 15 kHz            Innovation: Compact accelerator
                                         -        +          module case                             and power      and laser technology spin-offs
                                        studies, report physics case(s)        sources by 2037 (sustainability)     and synergies with industry
Milestones: HQ e- beam by 2026,          scape Feasibility and pre-
                                        Deliverable:                           Deliverable: Technical readiness     Training: Involvement and edu-
                                        CDR report in 2026 for Euro-           level (TRL) report in 2026 for Eu-   cation of next generation engi-
HQ e+ beam by 2032, 15 kHz               Innovation: Compact
                                        pean, national decision makers
                                                                                     accelerator
                                                                               ropean, national decision makers     neers and scientists

high eff. beam and power                 and laser technology spin-offs
sources by 2037 (sustainability)         and synergies with industry
Deliverable: Technical readiness         Training: Involvement and edu-
level (TRL) report in 2026 for Eu-       cation of next generation engi-
ropean, national decision makers         neers and scientists
                                     R. Assmann, E. Gschwendtner                                                                                 16
R&D Area                                              R&D Topic (in random order)                             2021         2022       2023      2024         2025       2026      2027        2028        2029       2030         2031         2032
Sources of electrons, positrons, plasmas, and high
power laser pulses                                    High-quality electron beams from a LWFA injector                     PALLAS, ELI, DESY, EuPRAXIA, Tsinghua, CLF/RAL/EPAC, ...
Address particle physics' unique requirements:
                                                      Advanced plasma photoguns with ultra-low
15kHz repetition rate, nanometer emittance, many                                                                           Strathclyde, FACET-2, ...
                                                      emittance electron beams
MJ stored energy, component efficiency at 30-50%
level, high rigidity of main beam, need for compact
                                                      Compact generation of positron beams up to GeV                       Queens University Belfast, EuPRAXIA, ...
solutions
                                                      High average power, high effciency laser drivers
                                                                                                                           CNR, DESY, STFC, CLF, Oxford, CNRS, EuPRAXIA, industry, Liverpool, LLNL, LBNL, ...
                                                      and schemes
                                                      Hybrid laser-beam driver schemes: demonstration,
                                                                                                                           HZDR, LMU University, Strathclyde, CNRS, CLARA/FEBE, CLF/RAL/EPAC, ...
                                                      stability, efficiency
                                                      Development of plasma sources for high-repetition
                                                                                                                           Oxford, DESY, LNF/INFN, AWAKE, ...
                                                      rate, multi-GeV stages
System tests: high quality electrons                   Dielectric accelerator module with high quality                                                       5 MeV,
R&D often driven by other science fields that will                                                                         Erlangen, STFC, PSI, DESY,         1 pC       CLARA, ...
                                                       beam for first applications
benefit from first, lower energy applications. Results
                                                       Electron-driven plasma accelerator-based Free-         First la-                                      TDR                                         User OP
will of prove collider single bunch quality                                                                                LNF/INFN, DESY, PWFA-FEL                    /CLARA, EuPRAXIA, ...
                                                       Electron Laser in saturation                          sing LNF                                       EuPRAXIA                                     EuPRAXIA

                                                                                                              First la-
                                                      Laser-driven plasma accelerator-based soft-Xray                                                                   TDR                              User OP Satura-
                                                                                                                sing       SOLEIL/CNRS, DESY, ELI, BELLA,                             EuPRAXIA,...
                                                      Free-Electron Laser in saturation                        SIOM
                                                                                                                                                                       EuPRAXIA                          EuPRAXIA     tion
                                                      Electron beam with fixed target beam quality from                                                                                                              AWAKE        --> Ready for Fixed
                                                                                                                           AWAKE                                                                                    Scalability   Target Experiments
                                                      p-PWFA
Collider components                                  Staging of electron plasma accelerators including in-
Demonstrate various collider components or aspects and outcoupling                                                         BELLA, DESY, EuPRAXIA, CLARA/FEBE, CLF/RAL/EPAC, AWAKE, ...
that are of critical importance for particle physics
                                                     Polarized electrons: targetry, polarimetry,                                                            Input to
applications                                                                                                               FZJ, DESY, ...
                                                     polarization conservation                                                                              concepts

                                                      Plasma lens R&D, towards transversely tapered
                                                                                                                           DESY, FACET-2, BELLA, Oslo University, CLARA/FEBE, Liverpool, CLEAR, ...
                                                      designs
                                                      Stable high transformer ratio PWFA with high eff.
                                                                                                                           FACET-2, LNF/INFN, DESY, ...
                                                      and low energy spread

                                                      Positron high energy plasma acceleration module                      FACET-2, ...

                                                                                                                                                                                              10GeV in
                                                                                                                                               e-seeding,
                                                      Proton-driven kJ electron acceleration module                        AWAKE               high grad.
                                                                                                                                                                                              10m, low
                                                                                                                                                                                                emit.

Possible HEP test facility                                                                       R. Assmann,
                                                      Possible construction HEP test facility advanced                    E. Gschwendtner                                                                                                               17
                                                      accelerators (start OP in 2035), if in pre-CDR 2026
Input and findings: 56 proposed milestones and deliverables for R&D until 2037. To be discussed
further and prioritized in next step of the roadmap process.
                                     R. Assmann, E. Gschwendtner                              18
Integration &
                                                                            High Gradient
       Outreach                                                     Plasma and Laser Accelerators
                                                                             Accelerator R&D Roadmap Pillars
Synergy and Integration: Bene-
fits for and synergy with other           Feasibility, Pre-CDR                       Technical                           Integration &
science fields (e.g. structural                  Study                             Demonstration                           Outreach
                                         Scope: 1st international, coor-       Scope: Demonstration of critical     Synergy and Integration: Bene-
biology, materials, lasers, health)      dinated study for self-consistent
                                         analysis of novel technologies
                                                                               feasibility parameters for e+e-
                                                                               collider and 1st HEP applications
                                                                                                                    fits for and synergy with other
                                                                                                                    science fields (e.g. structural
and projects (e.g. EuPRAXIA, …)          and their particle physics reach,
                                         intermediate HEP steps, collider
                                                                               Concept: Prioritised list of R&D
                                                                               that can be performed at exist-
                                                                                                                    biology, materials, lasers, health)
                                                                                                                    and projects (e.g. EuPRAXIA, …)

Access: Establishing framework           feasibility, performance, quanti-
                                         tative cost-size-benefit analysis
                                                                               ing, planned R&D infrastructures
                                                                               in national, European, interna-
                                                                                                                    Access: Establishing framework
                                                                                                                    for well-defined access to distri-

for well-defined access to distri-       Concept: Comparative paper stu-
                                         dy (main concepts included)
                                                                               tional landscape
                                                                               Milestones: HQ e- beam by 2026,
                                                                                                                    buted accelerator R&D land-
                                                                                                                    scape

buted accelerator R&D land-              Milestones: Report high energy
                                         e- and e+ linac module case
                                                                               HQ e+ beam by 2032, 15 kHz
                                                                               high eff. beam and power
                                                                                                                    Innovation: Compact accelerator
                                                                                                                    and laser technology spin-offs
                                         studies, report physics case(s)       sources by 2037 (sustainability)     and synergies with industry
scape                                    Deliverable: Feasibility and pre-     Deliverable: Technical readiness     Training: Involvement and edu-
                                         CDR report in 2026 for Euro-          level (TRL) report in 2026 for Eu-   cation of next generation engi-
Innovation: Compact accelerator          pean, national decision makers        ropean, national decision makers     neers and scientists

and laser technology spin-offs
and synergies with industry
Training: Involvement and edu-
cation of next generation engi-
neers and scientists
                                      R. Assmann, E. Gschwendtner                                                                                19
Conclusion
                                                                                                         • Executive Summary                                          2p
                                                                                                         • Abstract                                                   0,5 p
                                                                                                         • Motivation for a Plasma and Laser Accelerator R&D Program 1 p
                                                                                                         • State of the Art                                           2p
• RF accelerators are drivers of excellence!
• We have a new technology with 1 – 100 GV/m:
                                                                                                                              D  aft
                                                                                                         • Objectives of a Plasma and Laser Accelerator R&D Program

                                                                                                                                r
                                                                                                         • Challenges of Plasma and Laser Accelerators
                                                                                                         • Plasma and Laser Accelerator R&D Program Drivers
                                                                                                                                                                      2p
                                                                                                                                                                      6p
                                                                                                                                                                      2p
    • Establishing compact e- beam research infrastructure in                                            • Proposed Program Structure and Deliverables                12 p

      GeV regime, proposed by 50 institutes, 100’s scientists,                                                                    cus s ion
                                                                                                         • Roadmap, Work Plan and Timeline                            4p

                                                                                                                         de r dis
                                                                                                         • Impact of a Plasma and Laser Accelerator R&D Program       4p
      on ESFRI roadmap (EuPRAXIA) + national projects.                                                                 un
                                                                                                         • Applications to Other Fields and Society                   2p

• Use of this technology for High Energy Physics:                                                        • Scenario of Engagement and Investments                     2p
                                                                                                         • Sustainability                                             1p
   • Many challenges to be solved for very compact colliders
     à not at all easy but no fundamental showstopper.

                                                                   Illustration from EuPRAXIA, A. Ferran Pousa et al
   • Start stringent, coordinated innovation cycle for develo-
     ping new HEP discovery reach (feasibility à interme-
     diate facility à collider) with all its risks and benefits…
• Final roadmap will describe detailed challenges, milestones
  and required support!
                                     R. Assmann, E. Gschwendtner                                                                                               20
                                                                                                                                             Tajima & Dawson 1979
Thank you for your attention!
  Comments and suggestions very welcome and needed to
            prepare the best possible report

                ralph.assmann@desy.de
              edda.gschwendtner@cern.ch

              Or send it to the expert panel:

       expertpanel-plasmalaser-townhall@cern.ch

                   R. Assmann, E. Gschwendtner          21
You can also read