THE INNATE IMMUNE SYSTEM IN VENOUS THROMBOSIS - ZACHARY ZIMMERMAN MD PHD 7/13/2012

Page created by Eugene Phillips
 
CONTINUE READING
THE INNATE IMMUNE SYSTEM IN VENOUS THROMBOSIS - ZACHARY ZIMMERMAN MD PHD 7/13/2012
The Innate Immune System
  in Venous Thrombosis

 ‘Monocytes, neutrophils, and platelets cooperate to initiate and
propagate venous thrombosis in mice in vivo.Von Bruhl ML, et al. J
             Exp Med 2012 Apr 9;209(4):819-35

                Zachary Zimmerman           MD PhD

                            7/13/2012
THE INNATE IMMUNE SYSTEM IN VENOUS THROMBOSIS - ZACHARY ZIMMERMAN MD PHD 7/13/2012
Venous Thrombosis: A Serious and
               Common Problem

Venous thrombosis is a major cause of morbidity and
mortality.

        VTE Incidence ~300,000-2,000,000/year in the
        US.

Though common, relatively little is understood about
the cellular and molecular events which initiate the
acute phase of venous clot formation.
THE INNATE IMMUNE SYSTEM IN VENOUS THROMBOSIS - ZACHARY ZIMMERMAN MD PHD 7/13/2012
Risk Factors for Venous Thrombosis

Virchow’s Triad (1856)

  • Endothelial Injury

  • Venous Stasis

  • Hypercoagulable state

    Pregnancy, Malignancy, Surgery, Trauma, Age,
    Drugs, Obesity, Smoking, Hereditary
    Thrombophilias, Smoking, Inflammation.
THE INNATE IMMUNE SYSTEM IN VENOUS THROMBOSIS - ZACHARY ZIMMERMAN MD PHD 7/13/2012
Inflammation and VTE:
       Increased Risk of VTE in autoimmune disease.

VTE Is a well-described complication of Crohn’s Disease and
Ulcerative Colitis

       Recent study of 13,756 patients with IBD, risk of VTE was
       increased compared to controls (HR 3.4, CI 2.7-4.3). The risk
       was amplified at time of disease flare (HR 8.4, CI 5.5-12.8).
       Lancet. 2010;375(9715):657.

Many studies have demonstrated a higher incidence of VTE in
patients with other systemic autoimmune diseases.


Patients with connective tissue diseases had an increased
incidence of VTE (IRR 2.3%) within 1 year post diagnosis compared
to controls. Risks were highest with SLE and JRA. J Thromb Haemost. 2012
May;10(5):815-21
THE INNATE IMMUNE SYSTEM IN VENOUS THROMBOSIS - ZACHARY ZIMMERMAN MD PHD 7/13/2012
Inflammation and VTE:
               Risk of VTE and Acute Infection


Smeeth et al examined cases of first DVT (n= 7278) or first PE (n=3755)
for association with URI or UTI in patients from the UK Health Improvement
Network. Risk of VTE was increased proximal to both infections (IR= 2.1%
and 1.9% for UTI and URI respectively). Lancet. 2006 Apr 1;367(9516):1075-9

     Data from the Danish National Registry of Patients supported an
increased risk of VTE in patients recently diagnosed with an infection in both
        834 Tichelaar et al. Inflammatory diseases, infections and venous thrombosis
community of hospital settings. Respiratory tract, urinary tract, skin, intra-
abdominal and bacteremia were associated with at least two fold increased
VTE risk. J InternTable 2: Summary
                   Med. 2012          of risks of venous thrombosis.
                             Jun;271(6):608-18.

                             Discussion
                                                   Relative risk   Absolute risk 1
                                                                                       There is now convincin


              Inflammatory bowel disease          1.5 – 8.4     2.6 – 9.0           clinical epidemiologica
                 ANCA-associated vasculitis          n/a           43 – 70             thrombosis are related.


     Human immunodeficiency virus        1.2 – 1.4     1.3 – 5.8           when time between the
                 Pneumonia                           1.9 – 2.7     n/a                 when the inflammatory
                                                                                       cently or, more specific


     Urinary tract infections            1.8 – 2.1     n/a
                                                                                       disease was active (flare
                 Infections NOS                      1.7 – 2.5     n/a
                                                                                       of the range of the relati


              1 Cases per 1,000 person-years
                                                                                       which convincing evide
                                              Thromb Haemost. 2012 May 2;107(5):827-37.

bosis was found in this
Inflammation and VTE:
                Biomarkers of Inflammation

•
                                                                                                                             JOURNAL OF VASCULAR SURGERY
                              702 Roumen-Klappe et al                                                                                             April 2002

      VTEs are often
      associated with                                         A
      elevated levels acute                                                              IL-6

      phase reactants such
      as C reactive
      protein.

•     Other inflammatory
      biomarkers have         B                                                                  C

      been associated with                           IL-8

                                                            CRP

      VTE including IL-6,
      IL-8, MCP-1, and
      TNF- .


                                                           J Vasc Surg. 2002 Apr;35(4):701-6.

                              Fig 1. Plasma levels in control subjects and patients with deep vein thrombosis (DVT) of (A) interleukin-6 (IL-6), (B) interleukin-
Inflammation, Leukocyte Adhesion, and Thrombosis


Early endothelial inflammation is associated with the release of
   Weibel-Palade bodies which contain vWF and P-selectin.


P-Selectin is required for venous clot formation in numerous
   animal models.


P-selctin mediates leukocyte rolling through interaction with P-
   selectin glycoprotein ligand 1
Clinical, epidemiologic, pathologic, and experimental
evidence suggests a role for inflammation and innate
immune cells early in venous thrombosis.

Endothelial injury is rarely demonstrable in VTE (except
post-surgical).


What role does inflammation and the innate immune
system play in the initiation and propagation of venous
thrombosis in the absence of endothelial injury?
Inflammation

              ?
Stasis

            Hypoxia

    Venous Thrombosis
Published March 26, 2012

                                                                                                                                                          Article

                           Monocytes, neutrophils, and platelets
                           cooperate to initiate and propagate venous
                           thrombosis in mice in vivo
                           Marie-Luise von Brühl,1,4 Konstantin Stark,1,4 Alexander Steinhart,1,4
                           Sue Chandraratne,1,4 Ildiko Konrad,1,4 Michael Lorenz,1,4
                           Alexander Khandoga,1,4 Anca Tirniceriu,1,4 Raffaele Coletti,1,4
                           Maria Köllnberger,1,4 Robert A. Byrne,1,4 Iina Laitinen,2 Axel Walch,5
                           Alexander Brill,6 Susanne Pfeiler,7 Davit Manukyan,7 Siegmund Braun,1
                           Philipp Lange,8 Julia Riegger,1,4 Jerry Ware,9 Annekathrin Eckart,1,4
                           Selgai Haidari,1,4 Martina Rudelius,3 Christian Schulz,1,4,10
                           Katrin Echtler,1,4 Volker Brinkmann,11 Markus Schwaiger,2
                           Klaus T. Preissner,12 Denisa D. Wagner,6 Nigel Mackman,13

                                                                                                                                                                        Downloaded from jem.rupre
                           Bernd Engelmann,7 and Steffen Massberg1,4
                           1Deutsches Herzzentrum and I. Medizinische Klinik, 2Nuklearmedizinische Klinik und Poliklinik, Klinikum rechts der Isar, and 3Institut für

                            Allgemeine Pathologie und Pathologische Anatomie, Technische Universität München (TUM), 80333 Munich, Germany
                           4Munich   Heart Alliance, Munich, Germany
                           5Helmholtz Zentrum München, Deutsches Forschungszentrum für Umwelt und Gesundheit, Institut für Pathologie,

                            85764 Neuherberg, Germany
                           6Immune Disease Institute, Program in Cellular and Molecular Medicine, Children’s Hospital, Boston,

                            and Department of Pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA 02115
                           7Institut für Klinische Chemie and 8Medizinische Klinik I, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität, 81377 Munich, Germany
                           9
Study Objectives


1)
      Develop a clinically relevant mouse model to
establish venous thrombosis resulting from ‘low flow’
state in the absence of endothelial damage.

II) Use model to investigate role of innate immune
response and inflammation early in thrombus
formation.
Study Model

Mice undergo ‘atraumatic’ laparotomy
with placement of a permanent narrowing
ligature on the IVC below left renal vein.
Post-procedure, blood flow velocity is
reduced ~80%.

Genetic mouse models were used in
conjunction with intravital 2 photon
microscopy to interrogate cellular and
molecular events in early clot formation.
Fig 1: Model induces DVTs similar to those from
human patients

                                                  Figure 1. A
                                                  model of DV
                                                  images of the
                                                  (baseline) and
                                                  illustrate the
                                                  without endo
                                                  a representat
                                                  ment of blood
                                                  ligation (n = 1
                                                  ments; lines s
                                                  (C) Evaluation
                                                  tomography (
                                                  IVC (also see
                                                  sagittal proje
                                                  Right: animal
                                                  The dotted lin
                                                  cavity. Arrow
                                                  agent, indicat
                                                  animal with s
                                                  contrast fillin
                                                  of n = 3 expe
                                                  harvested IVC
                                                  C57BL/6 (n =
                                                  enoxaparin tr
                                                  vidual experim
                                                  group. (E) Ma
e
v
g
o
C
t
(
a
(
e
1
n
o
a
d
s
s
c
i
(
i

fl
p
t
e
c
t
fl
                   Fig 2: Leukocytes are recruited early to                                                                                                ph
                                                                                                                                                           th

                   endothelial surface

Published March 26, 2012
                                                                                                                                                           20
                                                                                                                                                           n

                                                                                                                                                           an
                                                                                                                                                           C
                                               Figure 2. Leukocytes are recruited during the early                                                         c
                                               phase of venous thrombosis to the intact endothelial sur-                                                   m
                                               face. (A) Leukocyte accumulation in DVT induced by 48 h of                                                  cy
                                               flow restriction. vG (top left) and immunohistochemical stain-                                              th
                                               ings (middle and right, top and bottom) for Ly6G+ MPO+ neu-                                                 c
                                               trophils and F4/80+ monocytes. Nuclei are counterstained with                                               ac
                                               DAPI. Bars, 50 µm. The bottom left shows the quantification of
                                                                                                                                                           D
                                               neutrophils and monocytes. Results are mean ± SEM (n = 3).
                                               (B) Scanning electron microscopic images taken directly after
                                               partial IVC ligation showing the intact endothelium. After 6 h,                                              L
                                               a carpet composed of cell aggregates and fibrin can be visual-                                               o
                                               ized on the endothelial surface. Bars, 5 µm. (C) TEM images of                                               S
                                               venous vessels showing the anticoagulant endothelial cell                                                    n
                                               lining (pseudocolored in yellow). Bar, 5 µm. Detail is shown in                                              in
                                               the right image. (D) Histological analyses of the IVC 6 h after                                              u
                                               flow reduction examining leukocyte recruitment in the early
                                                                                                                                                            tr
                                               phase of venous thrombus formation. Histological sections in
                                               three different stainings (HE, vG, and MSB). Bars: (top row)                                                 C
                                               20 µm; (bottom row) 10 µm. Data are representative of                                                        th
                                                                                                                                                            P

                                                                                                                  Downloaded from jem.rupress.o
                                               n = 3 experiments per group.
                                                                                                                                                            h
                                                                                                                                                            b
                                               and Video 4). We then examined heterozygous                                                                  ce
                                               CX3CR1-eGFP mice to specifically define mono-                                                                m
                                               cyte recruitment. This revealed that CX3CR1+                                                                 re
                                               monocytes constitute Y15% of the recruited leuko-                                                            re
                                               cytes  (Fig. the
                                                To dissect   3, D   and F; subsets
                                                                 leukocyte   and Video   5). Together,
                                                                                    recruited  in response to                                     adopts a pr
                                               these findings
                                            depressed           indicate
                                                        blood flow,   we that
                                                                           nextneutrophils
                                                                                induced flowandrestriction
                                                                                                 mono- in                                         endothelial
                                               cytes are the
                                            LysM-eGFP           predominant
                                                           reporter  mice. Weleukocyte     subsets
                                                                                 observed that   >80%thatof all                                   We then fo
                                               actively
                                            cells        accumulate
                                                  recruited during theatfirst
                                                                          the6 vascular surface
                                                                               h were eGFP        during
                                                                                             hi (Fig. 3 D). In                                    P-selectin–
                                               DVT development.
What are the kinetics of leukocyte
   recruitment by cell subset?

                              IVC Ligature

                                                     Imaging by

                                                2 photon microscopy

Acradine orange (Leukocytes)

LysM-eGFP (Neutophils)

CX3CR1-eGFP (Monocytes)
Fig 3: Neutrophils and Monocytes are the main
 Published March 26, 2012

     leukocyte subsets which accumulate early after DVT
Published March 26, 2012

     induction.

                                                        Figure 3. Neutroph
                                                        are the
                                                    Figure     3. main        leukocy
                                                                      Neutrophils
                                                    arelating
                                                          the main during      the ini
                                                                          leukocyte
                                                        (A) Neutrophils
                                                    lating    during the (green  initiat
                                                    (A) vessel    wall (red)
                                                         Neutrophils              of the
                                                                            (green)    cr
                                                        induction
                                                    vessel   wall (red) visualized
                                                                             of the IVb
                                                        copy. Tracks
                                                    induction               of individ
                                                                   visualized      by tw
                                                        shown
                                                    copy.   Tracks in of
                                                                       white   (also se
                                                                           individual
                                                        Shown
                                                    shown           is a representa
                                                              in white     (also see V
                                                        ments.
                                                    Shown      is a(B)  Time course
                                                                     representative
                                                        endothelial
                                                    ments.     (B) Timeinteractio
                                                                            course of
                                                        flow restriction
                                                    endothelial       interactionas eva w
                                                    flowmicroscopy
                                                           restrictioninasWT         anim
                                                                                evalua
                                                        orange (WT
                                                    microscopy        in WT+ acr    oran
                                                                               animal
                                                        were(WT
                                                    orange       taken    before
                                                                      + acr   orange)liga
                                                    wereweretakenused    to evaluate
                                                                     before     ligation
                                                    wereCXused
                                                            3CR1-eGFP         mice neu
                                                                    to evaluate        we
                                                    CX3ate   monocytes.
                                                         CR1-eGFP        mice Bars,
                                                                                  were 1
                                                    aterepresentative
                                                         monocytes. Bars,      of n100 =
                                                        (C) Dynamics
                                                    representative        ofofn=  the5 ex
                                                                                        re
                                                    (C) subsets
                                                         Dynamics    of of   the recru
                                                                         innate    imm
                                                    subsets     of innate
                                                        initiation            immune
                                                                       determined        i
                                                    initiation    determined
                                                        copy. Rolling        and in    vi
                                                                                    firm
                                                    copy.   Rolling
                                                        kocytes      areand   firmasadn
                                                                           given
                                                    kocytes     are given
                                                        millimeter.           as num
                                                                          Results     are
                                                    millimeter.
                                                        SEM (n =Results          are sh
                                                                       5 per group)
microscopy     in WTbefo
                                                                                           were taken      an
                                                                                     orangewere(WTused
                                                                                                    + acr
                                                                                                        toora
                                                                                                           ev
                                                                                     wereCX taken  before lig
                                                                                               3CR1-eGFP m

Fig 3: Neutrophils and Monocytes are the main                                        wereateused
                                                                                     CX3CR1-eGFP
                                                                                                  to evaluat
                                                                                                monocytes.
                                                                                                       mice w
                                                                                           representative     o
leukocyte subsets which accumulate early after DVT                                   ate monocytes.
                                                                                           (C) Dynamics
                                                                                     representative
                                                                                                        Bars
                                                                                                          n=
                                                                                                            of
                                                                                           subsets ofofinna
induction.

                                                                        (C) Dynamics
                                                                                           initiationof  the
                                                                                                       determ
                                                                                     subsets of innate im
                                                                                           copy. Rolling an
                                                                                     initiation determined
                                                                                           kocytes are give
                                                                                     copy. Rolling and firm
                                                                                           millimeter. Resu
                                                                                     kocytes are given as
                                                                                           SEM (n = 5 per
                                                                                     millimeter. Results a
                                                                                           frequency of ne
                                                                                     SEM (n = 5 per grou
                                                                                           6 h of flow rest
                                                                                     frequency of neutrop
                                                                                           vital video micr
                                                                                     6 h of flow restrictio
                                                                                           SEM (n = 5 per
                                                                                     vital video microscop
                                                                                           tative images ta
                                                                                     SEM (n = 5 per grou
                                                                                     tativecence
                                                                                             imagesmicrosco
                                                                                                      taken
                                                                                     cencerecruitment
                                                                                             microscopy6shh
                                                                                           IVC. Neutrophils
                                                                                     recruitment     6 h afte
                                                                                           mice. The numb
                                                                                     IVC. Neutrophils   were
                                                                                     mice.wasThe assessed
                                                                                                 number of  u
                                                                                           In both strains
                                                                                     was assessed     using C
                                                                                           (irrespective
                                                                                     In both   strains of of
                                                                                                           mi
                                                                                           by counterstain
                                                                                     (irrespective   of their
                                                                                           Acridine orange
                                                                                     by counterstaining      w
                                                                                           Bars,orange
                                                                                     Acridine     100 µm.(pse(E
                                                                                     Bars,LysM-eGFP
                                                                                            100 µm. (E)andFAC
                                                                                           IVC ligation
                                                                                     LysM-eGFP     and CX3usi
                                                                                           Ly6G antibody.
                                                                                     IVC ligation   using a n
                                                                                     Ly6Gmicroscopy
                                                                                            antibody. (F)ofInL
                                                                                           eGFP with
                                                                                     microscopy         PE-la
                                                                                                    of LysM-
 leukocyte recruitment or thrombus formation (Fig. 4 F). Hence,   only minimal   (
Published March 26, 2012
Fig 4: Leukocyte Adhesion Depends on Endothelial
    Published March 26, 2012

P-Selectin

                                                   Figure 4.
                                                   Figure 4.
                                                   leukocyte
                                                   leukocyte
                                                   of traffickin
                                                   of flow
                                                   to trafficki
                                                             res
                                                   to flow
                                                   after  DVTresi
                                                   aftershown
                                                   are    DVT i
                                                   are RT-PCR
                                                   (B)  shown
                                                   (B) RT-PCo
                                                   baseline
                                                   baseline
                                                   (n = 5 perog
                                                   (n = 5 per gd
                                                   standard
                                                   standard
                                                   immunohi
                                                   immunoh
                                                   endotheliu
                                                   endotheliu
                                                   ing  P-selec
                                                   ing P-selec
                                                   surface.   Nu
                                                   surface.
                                                   Bars,      N
                                                          50 µm
                                                   Bars, 50ofµm
                                                   images
                                                   images
                                                   and   SELPof
                                                   and SELP
                                                   Leukocytes
                                                   Leukocytes
                                                   orange   and
                                                   orange an
                                                   microscop
                                                   microscop
                                                   arrows   ind
                                                   arrows
                                                   Bars,    indµ
                                                          100
                                                   Bars,
                                                   of firm100
                                                            leuµ
                                                   of firm leu
                                                   restriction.
                                                   number
                                                   restrictionpe
                                                   (n = 5) and
                                                   number     pe
endothelium 48 h after DVT ind
                                                        Bars, 50 µm. (D, Left
                                               ing P-selectin and vWF on the
                                                        images of adherent
                                               surface. Nuclei are counterstai
                                                         µm. SELP
                                               Bars, 50 and
                                                                      / mice 6

Fig 4: Leukocyte Adhesion Depends on Endothelial
                                               images of
                                                              (D, Left) Represen
                                                        Leukocytes       were sta
                                                           adherent leukocytes
                                               and SELPorange      and6 hvisualize
P-Selectin

                                                          / mice         after ind
                                                        microscopy
                                               Leukocytes   were stained  (arrowhe
                                                                               with A
                                               orange and    visualized
                                                        arrows     indicateby intrav
                                                                                sing
                                               microscopy
                                                        Bars,(arrowhead
                                                                100 µm. (D,   indicat
                                                                                   Rig
                                               arrows indicate
                                                        of firm single     adheren
                                                                   leukocyte       ad
                                               Bars, 100 µm. (D, Right) Quant
                                                        restriction. Firm cell
                                               of firm leukocyte adhesion, 6 h
                                                        number per square m
                                               restriction. Firm cell adhesion        i
                                               number (n per=square      SELP
                                                               5) andmillimeters /

                                                        as mean
                                               (n = 5) and   SELP/  ± (n
                                                                         SEM.
                                                                            = 7).(E,
                                                                                   Da
                                               as meanimages
                                                          ± SEM. of (E, the
                                                                        Left)excise
                                                                                Repre
                                               images ofthrombus
                                                           the excised  after
                                                                           IVC48     h
                                                                                 inclu
                                               thrombus mice.
                                                           afterBars,
                                                                  48 h 1inmm.
                                                                            C57BL/ (E
                                               mice. Bars,  1 mm. (E,(n
                                                        in C57BL/6       Right)
                                                                            = 8)Thr an
                                               in C57BL/6
                                                        48 (n
                                                            h =after
                                                                  8) andDVTSELP
                                                                                  /
                                                                               induc
                                               48 h after  DVT   induction.
                                                        individual experimen    Dots
                                               individual experiments; lines sh
                                                        of each group. (F) Hi
                                               of each group. (F) Histological
                                                        harvested IVC throm
                                               harvested IVC thrombi 48 h aft
                                                        tion
                                               tion given  as given
                                                               thrombus as thromb
                                                                             load in
                                               limeters limeters     (n platelets.
                                                         (n = 5). plt,   = 5). plt,D
                                               as meanas    mean ± SEM.
                                                          ± SEM.

                                               formation    was significant
                                                       formation      was si
                                               compared    with WT
                                                       compared         anim
                                                                      with   W
                                               ing theingmajor
                                                            the role
                                                                   majorof mro
                                               cell–derived TF for DVT d
                                                       cell–derived TF fo
                                               (Fig. 5 D). The procoagu
                                                       (Fig.cells
                                               of myeloid     5 D).     Thefro
                                                                  isolated
                                                       of mice
                                               TFflox/flox myeloid     cells is
                                                                 is significan
Fig 5: Is Blood Cell TF Involved in DVT Formation?

                       Low-hTF-No mouse TF (
Fig 5: Is Blood Cell TF Involved in DVT Formation?

           Low-hTF

        Bone Marrow

             HCV

  Chimera expressing

little TF on blood cells
Are Neutrophil Extracellular Traps
                                    (NETs)involved in DVT induction?

                                 Fuchs et al       Neutrophil Extracellular Trap Impact on Deep Vein Thrombosis                 3
             Neutrophil NET formation is a process by which Neutrophils
             actively extrude DNA associated complexes which include granular
             proteins and anti-bacterial molecules.

             NETs serve a putative innate anti-microbial immune function

             NET formation has also been implicated in pathologic conditions
             such as autoimmune disease, TRALI, and VTE.

                                                                                                                                           Fuchs et al   Neutrophil Extracell

                                                                                         Arterioscler
Figure 2. Neutrophil extracellular trap (NET) formation and function. A, Electron micrograph                  Thromb
                                                                                             of NETs with trapped SalmonellaVasc   Biol. 2012
                                                                                                                            typhimurium;        May 31
Fig 6. NETs in DVT induction.

Published March 26, 2012

                                                                               Figure 6. NET
                                                                               (A) Leukocyte ac
                                                                               flow restriction i
                                                              Figure 6. NETs   treated   with DVT
                                                                                   propagate     con
                                                              (A) Leukocyte accumulation
                                                                               Ly6G mAb to    in vivo
                                                                                                  dep
                                                              flow restriction in the IVC of LysM
                                                                               aggregated
                                                              treated with control   antibodyneutor th
                                                                               ent cells.
                                                              Ly6G mAb to deplete          Bars, 10
                                                                                      neutrophils.
                                                              aggregated neutrophils; arrows: si
                                                                               48 h after DVT in
                                                              ent cells. Bars, 100 µm. (B) Thromb
                                                                               Ly6G–treated
                                                              48 h after DVT induction             WT
                                                                                          in isotype
                                                              Ly6G–treated WT     mice (n =individ
                                                                               represent      6 per g
                                                              represent individual experiments;
                                                              the mean of each thegroup.
                                                                                    mean(C)ofRepre
                                                                                                 each
                                                                               image of nof=intra
                                                              image of n = 3 experiments         3 ex
                                                              copy 3 or 48 h after flow reduction
                                                                               copy 3 or 48 h a
                                                              Sytox Green+ NETs in the IVC. Bars
                                                              (D) VisualizationSytox   Green
                                                                                          in vivoNE
                                                                                                +
                                                                                 of NETs            by
                                                              microscopy. Ly6G-positive     neutrop
                                                                               (D) Visualization
                                                              FITC anti-Ly6G antibody) attached
                                                                               microscopy.
                                                              sel wall (blue) release           Ly6G
                                                                                       Sytox orange
                                                                               FITC inside
                                                              (red) NET structures   anti-Ly6G
                                                                                            the IVC a
                                                              flow reduction (also see Video 7). S
                                                                               sel wall (blue) re
                                                              orange–positive nuclei correspond
                                                                               (red)have
                                                              neutrophils, which      NETnotstructu
                                                                                               (yet) e
                                                              their DNA to the   extracellular
                                                                               flow   reduction  spac
                                                                                                    (a
                                                              head: extracellular DNA; arrow: ne
                                                                               orange–positive
                                                              Bar, 50 µm. (E) Immunohistochem
                                                              ization of NETs neutrophils,
                                                                                by staining forwhic
                                                                                                  DNA
                                                              MPO, NE, and histones (H2A-H2B-
                                                                               their DNA to the
                                                              the IVC of WT mice 48 h after indu
                                                              DVT. Hoechst+ DNAhead:   extracellul
                                                                                   originating   from
                                                                               Bar, 50
                                                              neutrophils (arrows)       µm.be(E)
                                                                                     could          Im
                                                                                                 dete
                                                              Arrows, nuclei; arrowheads, NET fi
                                                              Bars, 10 µm. (F)ization
                                                                                Numberof  of NETs
                                                                                             NETs in b
                                                                               MPO, NE,inand
                                                              nic mice were quantified       throm his
their DNA to the
                                                                                    head: extracellu
                                                                                    Bar, 50 µm. (E) I
            Fig 6. NETs in DVT induction.

                                        ization of NETs
                                                                                    MPO, NE, and h
                                                                                    the IVC of WT m
                                                                                    DVT. Hoechst+ DN
                                                                                    neutrophils (arr
                                                                                    Arrows, nuclei; a
                                                                                    Bars, 10 µm. (F)
                                                                                    nic mice were q
                                                                                    treatment with
                                                                                    antibody (n = 3
                                                                                    mean ± SEM. (G
                                                                                    thrombi stained
                                                                                    treatment. Arrow
                                                                                    Shown is a repr
                                                                                    ments. (H) After
                                                                                    bus weight (left
                                                                                    after 48 h of flo
                                                                                    individual exper
                                                                                    of each group. Q
                                                                                    shown (right) as
                                                                                    tained in WT inj
                                                                                    (n = 14) or DNa
                                                                                    of NETs at 48 h
                                                                                    animals (n = 4 p
revealing a typical NET morphology (Fig. 6 C and Video 6).     whether NETs con-    mean ± SEM.
Intravital 2-PIVM revealed that extracellular DNA originates   centrate prothrom-
from Ly6G+ neutrophils (Fig. 6 D and Video 7). Extracel-       botic factors on their
lular DNA was located in close proximity to neutrophils and    surfaces. In fact, the
stained positive for the neutrophil granule proteins MPO,      NETs were decorated with TF and
neutrophil elastase (NE), and the histone proteins H2A-H2B     erase, an enzyme implicated in the
Fig 7. Platelets and Leukocytes Interact to Support
ed March 26, 2012

                                DVT Formation

                   A
Fig 7. Platelets and Leukocytes Interact to Support
                             DVT Formation

7. Platelet recruitment supports DVT formation in vivo. (A) Immunohistological cross sections of the IVC 48 h after DVT induction display p
               +
ch 26, 2012
              Fig 7. Platelets Induce NET Formation
Since Factor XII can
be activated by
negatively charged
surfaces, do NETs
activate factor XII in
DVT formation?
Fig 7. NETs serve as Factor XII scaffold and
                              facilitate Factor XII activation.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  Downloaded from jem.rupress.org on June 15, 2012
                                                                                                                                                                                                               Downloaded from jem.rupress.org on June 15, 2012
                                                                                                                                                            Downloaded from jem.rupress.org on June 15, 2012
Figure
 Figure8.8. Platelets
             Platelets
         Figure
                       induce
                8. Platelets
                                NET
                                NET formation,
                        induceinduce formation, which
                                                which
                                     NET formation,
                                                        triggers
                                                       triggers
                                                    which
                                                                  FXIIa-dependent
                                                                FXIIa-dependent
                                                          triggers
                                                                                     thrombus
                                                                   FXIIa-dependent thrombus
                                                                                               propagation.
                                                                                             propagation.
                                                                                   thrombus propagation. (A)(A)
                                                                                                                (A) Freshly
                                                                                                                 Freshly
                                                                                                             Freshly
                                                                                                                             isolated
                                                                                                                         isolated
                                                                                                                     isolated human
                                                                                                                                      human
                                                                                                                                   human      neutrophils
                                                                                                                                          neutrophils
                                                                                                                                     neutrophils were were
                                                                                                                                                          were
Summary/ Interpretation


Study provides novel insight into how restricted
venous flow can initiate an inflammatory response
during DVT induction.


à Flow restriction upregulates several chemokines in
vessel wall. Leukocytes are recruited early, predominately
neutrophils.


à Innate immune cells play an active role in thrombus
formation both by the delivery of TF and NETs. Platelets
enhance this process (in the absence of endothelial
disruption).


à Data suggests NET formation forms a prothrombotic
scaffold for activation of factor XII.
Inflammation

              ?
Stasis

            Hypoxia

    Venous Thrombosis
Proposed Model of Innate Immune Cell
2
                           Involvement in Venous Thrombosis

         Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol                              August 2012
            2       Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol     August 2012
                  2     Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol   August 2012

                                         A.

                                                             B.

                                                   C.

Figure 1.Figure      1. Neutrophil
                Figure
             Neutrophil                extracellular
                           1. extracellular
                               Neutrophil       traps traps
                                             extracellular(NETs) (NETs)
                                                              traps      thein the
                                                                     in(NETs)  time  time
                                                                                 in theline lineline
                                                                                          time    of deep
                                                                                                      of deep
                                                                                            Arterioscler
                                                                                              of deep        vein
                                                                                                           vein    thrombosis
                                                                                                                vein  thrombosis
                                                                                                                     Thromb
                                                                                                                thrombosis       (DVT):
                                                                                                                                     (DVT):
                                                                                                                                (DVT):         model.A,
                                                                                                                                          a model.
                                                                                                                                          a amodel.
                                                                                                                                       Vasc      Biol.  A,DVT
                                                                                                                                                       A,  DVTisis
                                                                                                                                                          2012
                                                                                                                                                           DVT    initiated
                                                                                                                                                                 is initiated
                                                                                                                                                                      May
                                                                                                                                                                             by
                                                                                                                                                                     initiated   local
                                                                                                                                                                              byby local
                                                                                                                                                                               31

                                                                                                                                                                                         hypoxia
                                                                                                                                                                                          hypoxia
                                                                                                                                                                                      local  hypoxia
          and activation
                and activation of endothelial    cellscells
                                    of endothelial       (ECs)   as aasresult
                                                              (ECs)       a resultof flow   restriction/disturbances.
                                                                                      of flow   restriction/disturbances.   Activated
                                                                                                                               Activated endothelium
                                                                                                                                            endotheliumreleases
                                                                                                                                                           releasesultralarge
                                                                                                                                                                       ultralargevonvonWille-
                                                                                                                                                                                         Wille-
and activation
          brand    of endothelial
                   factor
                brand       (ULVWF)
                         factor
                                        cells
                                        and and
                                  (ULVWF)
                                                (ECs)
                                               P-selectin as from
                                                    P-selectin
                                                              a result
                                                                   from
                                                                           of flow restriction/disturbances.
                                                                      Weibel-Palade
                                                                          Weibel-Palade     bodies
                                                                                                bodies (WPB)   which
                                                                                                           (WPB)  which
                                                                                                                           Activated
                                                                                                                       mediate
                                                                                                                          mediateplateletendothelium
                                                                                                                                            and
                                                                                                                                     platelet    neutrophil
                                                                                                                                               and
                                                                                                                                                           releases
                                                                                                                                                    neutrophiladhesion.
                                                                                                                                                                        ultralarge
                                                                                                                                                                adhesion.Activated
                                                                                                                                                                                       vonplatelets
                                                                                                                                                                                            Wille-
                                                                                                                                                                              Activatedplatelets
brand factor    (ULVWF)
          recruit   tissue
                recruit        and
                             factor
                          tissue     P-selectin
                                     (TF)–containing
                                   factor             frommicroparticles
                                           (TF)–containing    Weibel-Palade
                                                                microparticles         bodies
                                                                                  thatthat
                                                                                        enhance   (WPB)
                                                                                            enhance  thrombinwhich
                                                                                                         thrombin    mediateinplatelet
                                                                                                                 generation
                                                                                                                    generation    thethe
                                                                                                                                  in         and thrombus.
                                                                                                                                       growing
                                                                                                                                         growing  neutrophil
                                                                                                                                                    thrombus.B,adhesion.
                                                                                                                                                                     ActivatedActivated
                                                                                                                                                                 B,Activated    platelets
                                                                                                                                                                                  plateletsandplatelets
                                                                                                                                                                                             and
recruit tissue   factor (TF)–containing
                endothelium
          endothelium             or other
                            or other   stimulus    microparticles
                                             stimulus
                                                    induceinduce
                                                              NETNET      that enhance
                                                                          formation
                                                                      formation     in adherent  thrombin
                                                                                         in adherent           generation
                                                                                                          neutrophils.
                                                                                                      neutrophils.      NETs
                                                                                                                     NETs    inprovide
                                                                                                                                 the growing
                                                                                                                            provide    anan        thrombus.
                                                                                                                                              additional
                                                                                                                                           additional            B,
                                                                                                                                                          scaffold
                                                                                                                                                        scaffold      Activated
                                                                                                                                                                     for
                                                                                                                                                                   for   plateletand
                                                                                                                                                                       platelet      platelets
                                                                                                                                                                                   and          and
                                                                                                                                                                                         redblood
                                                                                                                                                                                        red  blood
endothelium     or other
                cell
          cell (RBC)  (RBC)   stimulus
                               adhesion,
                         adhesion,         induce
                                            promote
                                      promote          NET
                                                   fibrin     formation
                                                         fibrin formation,
                                                            formation,     andinandadherent
                                                                                      exacerbate
                                                                                  exacerbate      neutrophils.
                                                                                                       platelet
                                                                                                   platelet  andandNETs    provide
                                                                                                                     endothelial
                                                                                                                  endothelial          an additional
                                                                                                                                    activation.
                                                                                                                                activation.    C,C,       scaffold
                                                                                                                                                     Plasmin,
                                                                                                                                                  Plasmin,            for platelet
                                                                                                                                                             a adisintegrin
                                                                                                                                                                  disintegrin         and red blood
                                                                                                                                                                               andmetallopro-
                                                                                                                                                                              and     metallopro-
cell (RBC)   adhesion,
                teinase
          teinase           apromote
                     with with            fibrin formation,
                                 a thrombospondin
                              thrombospondin          typetype    1 and
                                                             1 motif,motif,exacerbate
                                                                              member
                                                                         member       13 13   platelet
                                                                                               (ADAMTS13),
                                                                                           (ADAMTS13),     and  endothelial
                                                                                                              andand           activation.
                                                                                                                      deoxyribonuclease
                                                                                                                   deoxyribonuclease            C, Plasmin,
                                                                                                                                              (DNase)
                                                                                                                                           (DNase)      mediate
                                                                                                                                                      mediate  athrombolysis
                                                                                                                                                                   disintegrin
                                                                                                                                                                   thrombolysisand by    metallopro-
                                                                                                                                                                                     bydegrading
                                                                                                                                                                                         degrading
teinase with   afibrin,
          fibrin, ULVWF, ULVWF,and and
                  thrombospondin     DNA, DNA,
                                             type respectively.      Monocytes/macrophages
                                                     1 motif,Monocytes/macrophages
                                             respectively.       member         13 (ADAMTS13),        (MØ)(MØ)
                                                                                                            and releaseanan additional
                                                                                                                 deoxyribonuclease
                                                                                                             release      additional      source ofofDNase
                                                                                                                                            (DNase)
                                                                                                                                       source         DNase
                                                                                                                                                       mediateandgenerate
                                                                                                                                                             and     generateplasmin
                                                                                                                                                                    thrombolysisplasmin    and
                                                                                                                                                                                        byand
                                                                                                                                                                                           degrading
fibrin, ULVWF,  promote
          promote   and      restoration
                       restoration          of blood
                                      of blood flow.
                           DNA, respectively.           flow.
                                                        Monocytes/macrophages (MØ) release an additional source of DNase and generate plasmin and
Questions for Further Investigation

Neutrophils appear to be important for early venous
thrombosis formation. What is the contribution of immune
cell subsets to thrombolysis?

Are the mechanisms described in this study clinically
relevant to human patients with VTE?

  Do these mechanisms apply to different clinical scenarios
  such as clots that form in neutropenic patients?

  Are any of the mechanisms of clot initiation/ propagation
  described in the study hyperactive in patients with
  unidentified thrombophilias?
Questions for Further Investigation

Do these results suggest novel ways to intervene in
VTE?

  • DNAse?

  • Neutrophil Elastase (NE) and peptidylarginine
    deiminase 4 (PAD4)?

  • RAF-MEK-ERK pathway? (GW5074, U0126)
Questions?
Additional References:

Lancet. 2010;375(9715):657.

J Thromb Haemost. 2012 May;10(5):815-21

Lancet. 2006 Apr 1;367(9516):1075-9

J Intern Med. 2012 Jun;271(6):608-18.

Thromb Haemost. 2012 May 2;107(5):827-37.

J Vasc Surg. 2002 Apr;35(4):701-6.

J Cell Biol. 2010;191:677–691

J Cell Biol. 2009;184:205–213.

Nat Chem Biol 2011 Feb;7(2):75-7.

J Clin Invest. 2012 Jul 2;122(7):2661-71.

Blood. 2012 Jun 28;119(26):6335-43.
You can also read